Everything posted by Little Goffy
-
Low Attendance
I really think people are just confused because normally a team on a high gets bigger attendances as the fair weather fans jump back on. Doesn't apply to Melbourne because we farewelled our last soft supporters long ago. I'm joking but also serious.
-
Simon, do we have a problem with the MCG?
One coached Fleamantle and the other Sidanhee. Even though I was just having a laugh, I may still have to ban myself from posting for a few days, there isn't a forehead-slap gif powerful enough. Jebus Chroist's extruded colon. I've spent at least a decade thinking they were brothers.
-
Simon, do we have a problem with the MCG?
The Cairns disaster games which cost us finals in 2020 were against Sydney and Fremantle. Our two losses in the last couple of weeks were also, of course, Sydney and Fremantle. Those four losses to Longmuir-coached clubs account for one half of all our losses since September 2020. Does anyone else want to help with a GOFUNDME for a special Longmuir family vacation? I'm thinking a month-long cruise of the Norwegian Fjords, starting at about the end of August.
-
Simon, do we have a problem with the MCG?
My gut feeling agrees. I've having a looking now at who we've played when. Thoughts; This season we've already played 8 games at the 'G. There's no denying that while we were getting the job done we weren't blowing teams away very often. Our two games against opponents in disarray, the Eagles and Kangaroos, were both away from the G, while our two games where we were messed around by disruptions etc were at the G. There may also be an element of coincidental timing - our run to the premiership last year coincided with our forward line getting organised, With Ben Brown and Bailey Fritsch combing for five and a half goals per game in the period after the loss to the Bulldogs in rnd 19, and Pickett adding almost two a game as well. In that period we only played once at the MCG, which was a solid 41 point win. In contrast, our mid-season slump last year (taken as the six games from the loss to Collingwood until the loss against the Dogs) coincided with a large chunk of MCG time. 4 of those 6 games were at the 'G, out of the season total 11 of 25. Outside that slump period in 2021 we only lost one game, by one point, and due to an umpiring error! So, I'm not too worried about the MCG, though I'd prefer if I was 'actively enthusiastic' about our presence at the 'G. What DOES have me worried is the Longmuir family. Since September 2020, half of all losses by the Melbourne Demons have been to a Longmuir.
-
NOT Taylor Walker
Such luxury! I have some feeling that way but would like to keep my hopes up that there actually IS a good option out there for the recruiters to pick out. I'm glad someone else went there so I wasn't tempted. We are basically looking for exactly Jesse Hogan but not Jesse Hogan! I've been irritated by Walker for ten years. He's in the 'punchable face' basket for me! Talk of recruiting him just sends my mind to the Fevola to Brisbane zone. That is really well gone up the river for me! Need to assemble a set of options first, but yes, a poll should be added.
-
Entire forward line standing still
Yeah, Fritsch was our only designated forward to kick any goals against Sydney. And here's what trouble's me most about that - if he can get them, then they are possible. So why did Brown and Brown, combined, had seven kicks and six marks? Meanwhile, our fleet of crumbers simply weren't getting forward to put enough pressure on to cause the rushed rebound-50s that are so crucial for our intercepting and counter-attacking game.
-
Complacency
Seems to me that it isn't our very best players showing signs of complacency, though. I wonder if there's a few lesser lights who are just kind of coasting now - maybe feeling very much like passengers. I don't mean that necessarily in a lazy or irresponsible sense, so much as they are struggling a little with motivation when they know they are 'Player 19th-25th'. The bye is coming at a good time (as always) but I'd like to see us get the system back working properly against Collingwood and get a solid win just so we have a little positive reinforcement.
-
How Good Is Max Gawn?
His final quarter against Sydney was just extraordinary. He finally got a pace ahead of the ruck-tagger that had (wisely) been stalling him all night and took, what, four, five important marks? It is very much like having an extra player, but tonight with the tall defenders depleted and disordered, and the tall forwards entirely failing, it was too much to ask him to be both ruck, extra forward, AND extra intercept defender. Considering he had a couple of 'just very good' games in the first half of the season, his sheer volume of work accumulated this year is extraordinary.
-
NOT Taylor Walker
I've shuddered in horror every time I've seen the 'Taylor Walker possible recruit' thread on the main page, so I'm looking for reassurance that there are better options out there. I'm keen to hear people's opinions on possible next key forward options for the Demons. It is clearly the next item on the list management, erm, management list. Respectable veterans slightly younger than our current ones to cover the impending hole? Mid-career club-switch prospects? Young key forwards who aren't getting games but could provide an honest contest? If I can figure out how to add a poll to the post later, I'll take in people's nominations and create a poll. So, who have people got an eye on for this essential part of any 'dynasty creation'?
-
Poll - Demonland Demographics
I lied just a little. But I figured I deserved some time off for 2012-14. Also, my wife is in the age group I selected, and I definitely 'belong to' her. So, in an Obi Wan kind of way, it is true. From a certain point of view.
-
CHANGES: Rd 12 vs Sydney
Out: Flu? In: Oxygen? The Tomlinson-Langdon-Harmes-McDonald additions seem natural and a dramatic difference. Touch wood on May but as others have noted, concussion protocols probably mean no sighting in six days' time. I'm wondering how many weeks left until Salem is back? Would obviously replace Hunt, although I don't mean to be harsh on Hunt as he was just completely out of comfort zone today. Yhere was obviously something wrong with Petracca on the day and it really robbed our midfield and made it possible to tag Oliver and have it mean something. Viney was very good but Dunstan was pretty limited in accumulation as well as effect. Far too often the ruck - Jackson and Gawn - ended up chasing their own hitout instead of being part of any organised onball system. Anyway, it's not so bad. It is bad, though.
-
MFC tall forwards
Olisik - Literally no posts between march 11 and two hours after our first loss of the season. Gotta love him. But I'll bite for the actual topic. The forward line is an issue. Brown has down days about as often as Weideman has good days - if you average it out that would mean that if both played a full season that would mean we had one good forward out there consistently. Unfortunately today they both had absolute u-bend sludge days and when that combines with the heavy disruption to our tall defenders due to concussion and a wonky ankle, we were always in trouble. Petracca up forward for most of the game and not even reaching contests is also 'of note'.
-
Taylor Walker
I can't see us wanting him, so it is allegedly a club in the premiership window, but not the Demons? Very short list.
-
What They Are Saying at Cockburn Central
It'll be fairly tight early, they'll seem a little on top of us but only score a few goals without preventing us from grinding out a couple ourselves. The margin will be small in their favour at 1/4 time. In the second quarter we'll peg it back a little and by half time scores will be basically level. In the third quarter we'll push ahead a bit, peventing them from scoring much while adding three or four of our own. Early in the final quarter the game will open up just a little, both sides will kick goals, but then we'll get a couple on the trot, they'll realise they are beaten and then we'll kick the last three of the game, pushing the margin out to 50 points without anyone even noticing. [picture of a metronome]
-
Game Day Scribble: Rnd 9 v Eagles
This post made me realise that we just beat West Coast by 70+ and it didn't feel like we'd had a particularly good game. I've gone all squiggly-wiggly inside.
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 09 vs West Coast
Pickett is looking electric early again.
-
Will the next 2 games hurt us?
I think the North game is fine - despite their struggles they are still managing to score, rather than going out with 4-goal games and that kind of rubbish. We will still have our defensive effort tested and that's the discipline part that matters. West Coast I'm not worried about because I really think we should be aiming to absolutely shut them down. I know I'm not the only one who will relish any chance to humiliate that arrogant club, nevermind any revenge notions from 2018. The truly alarming thing for West Coast is how many of their goals have come well after the came is decided - not quite junk time but not much different, either. Counting back from round 8 to their win over the 'Pies (ha ha Collingwood), their first half goal tallies have been - 1, 2, 1, 2.
-
Daisy Pearce on Wikipedia
Accompanied by Banksia integrifolia as the previous day's feature article, I think Daisy will need to adopt it as a lucky flower!
-
When was the last time you watched Melbourne lose?
Collingwood at the SCG. I'd been to the Brisbane game in 'westish' Sydney the week before and there was a strange difference in the feeling. Against Brisbane we were down three goals at half time but I didn't really have any alarm bells going off. I felt like the system was going alright and we'd be able to get the game back on our terms. I also recall that was the strangest crowd I'd ever been in - 1/4 capacity rule, but that 1/4 was packed seat-to-seat in 1/4 of the stadium. Seemed complete madness. But against Collingwood the feeling was that we were genuinely failing when moving it forward. The old-fashioned breaking down across half forward. Sam Weideman had a dog of a day and I was up close to see it, which was upsetting because I was and still am on the 'Sam can go alright' wagon. But aside from a brief glimmer in the third - and despite that fact that we almost levelled the scores - we never really looked like we were about to dominate the game.
-
Dylan Shiel
I'd suggest that Tom Browne's entire basis for the rumor is the joke mention of him on Gus & Gawny, but that would require Tom Browne to have spent 30 minutes actually researching football news, so it is unlikely.
-
Goodwin, Jackson, Pickett, Sparrow, Petty & Neal-Bullen All Out with COVID
Interesting that the list of players out with Covid includes basically one player from every 'line' on field. Would seem very difficult to contain that, but on the other hand you'd expect to get these 5 or so back next week, and as mentioned many of our players have already had Covid. Confirmed on the Gus & Gawny podast, too! Ramp up the protocols, flatten the curve, all that jazz. Booster shots in the bye round, all set for September. In the meantime, trust in the power of Bowey to get us the win over the Hawks.
-
First Option
We are a lot fitter than we were a few years ago and we are committed to creating options. Fact is, not so long ago if you didn't take the first option then there probably wouldn't be any other good ones come up. Now, if a player isn't sure of that kick then they can look around confident that at any time there will be teammates working to create both a good attacking option and a good escape hatch and defensive outlet. You wouldn't dig up your garden unless you actually thought there was buried treasure. Similarly, now that there is a real prospect of good options being available, our players have built the habit of looking for them. We are a very good, maybe even great, football team.
-
22-0 or 21-1
I have the alarming feeling that right now we ARE pacing ourselves. I think our team has the most precious gift available to a top-performing side; the ability to respond to circumstances and deliver super-intense surges when required, but the rest of the time we maintain full defensive discipline as the standard expected. We are almost literally using the main season as a training problem with live targets! Anything can happen with Covid lurking around ready to knock four or five players out at a moment's notice, but that would be why we have the likes of Dunstan and Smith, who each reminded us last night that they are capable at the level when required and would still be thinking they are a shot at their own premiership medals.
-
Tom Scully
201cm? It's a wonder what a solid diet of bananas can do for a young man.
-
POSTGAME: Rd 05 vs GWS
Whenever I read or hear or have a chat with someone who wants to tell me all about my club, Viney gets a mention as symbolic of the disciplined coverage at stoppages and around the group which makes it so hard to get good quality clearances against us. Let us all take a moment to remember the frustration of just a couple of seasons ago when we would see, far too often and far too easily, opposition mids break away from a stoppage without having to so much as evade. Back then it was 'oh, we didn't win the clearance, so now it is up to the defenders'. It took me a moment to figure out who it was I was being reminded of - Viney being mixed with Petracca and Oliver puts him in a position a bit like James Kelly during the Geelong golden run. A fixture in the best 22, a three time premiership player, an All-Australian, but never the leading light. Mind you, in-form Viney is a step up on Kelly, especially now that his brain understands the limits of his body and he knows he doesn't have to be a hero.