Everything posted by Little Goffy
- AFL lookalikes
-
Forward Coach
Hawkins hasn't been confirmed officially, but his 'prestige house and land package' is officially on the market for a Geelongzillion dollars, so I presume he's moving across the bay to be closer to Casey.
-
Contend? Yes We Will! Another [censored] quiz
Pretty sure @Timothy Reddan-A'Blew just gave out his Netflix password.
-
AFL Draft 2025: Phantom Drafts
Is there a thread for 'questions already asked and answered 15 times?'. Including this one? How does father-son and academy selection work once you're through to the rookie draft? And what happens if a bid comes in at technically zero value - pick 55 or later? And is the value calculated according to when the pick is taken or when it is officially recorded - for example if over a dozen picks are burned in the 20s and 30s, does pick 37 get valued at its rank number or at the late 20s range it is actually taken? Such a simple, elegant system they set up.
-
AFL Draft 2025: Phantom Drafts
Flicking through Twomey's guide again and just got the feeling like Sam Cumming looks a little bit like Harvey Langford. Similar hair, similar broad face with comparatively small eyes, they've both got the chin-knuckle. Anyway, I'm only becoming more convinced that a Sam-based draft strategy is the way to go. If we're lucky both Cumming and Grlj will be available, and while they are different types they each would bring a great level of speed and fitness to our new midfield dynamic. We could be terrifyingly mobile in the middle and the wings in a very short space of time, with Windsor, Lindsay, Langford, Cumming, Grlj, Rivers and Pickett all rotating through.
- AFL lookalikes
-
Tim's Try at Treacherous Trickery
Well, I got that one right away. Although there was a red herring with Prince and Damien Barrett both being able to [censored] [censored] [censored] themselves.
-
AFL Draft 2025: Phantom Drafts
That zero hanger 'one pick per reload the page' format is a proper bonfire, thank you for grinding it out for us. Duff-Tytler sliding would be a marvel and an abomination. I'd happily live trade 6 and downgrade 7 to nudge up a couple of spots to get him. I feel like we'll be watching the draft with some 'acceptable' picks in mind but desperately hoping for a slider.
-
Tim's Try at Treacherous Trickery
This one has beaten me - I reached the point of just staring at the screen hoping the words would unjumble. Still, I liked my 'major figures of 18th century British history' theory.
-
2026 AFL Free Agents
I'll take Walsh and Bailey, thanks. Bailey would be kind of a hybrid successor to Nibbler and Melksham, which we definitely want. Not much needs to be said. Brisbane is looking at the Salary cap squeeze to end all salary cap squeeze, surely? Walsh because he is an in-and-out midfielder with enough utility to help cover the succession of whichever of Viney, Steele, Salem and Langdon begins to fade and isn't naturally covered as the kids develop. Walsh has played with all manner of niggles over the last few years, and I think people underrate his 'fundamentals' a bit because of the obscene Daicos-level hype he copped early in his career. If you slot him in mentally as a 'valuable, versatile utility' rather than the hyped no.1 pick, he's a great addition to a team. Fingers crossed he has a poor 2026 and falls out of love with Carlton, comes cheap and then gets his body right for us, ready for the 2028 premiership.
-
Any experienced players worth picking?
Just getting in ahead of any suggestions we give Elijah Hollands a try. The thought was making me uncomfortable.
-
Demonstone's Big Bad Bewildering Brain Baffler
I'm going to push my luck and choose Taylor & Taylor.
-
Demonstone's Big Bad Bewildering Brain Baffler
Boooooo boooooooo Shun! Shun the unbeliever! Shuuuuuuun.
-
Kozzi Pickett - Will he be an all time MFC great?
I had similar thoughts, recalling happy times at Clayton's 150th mark, doing some projections to 'if the second half of his career is the same as the first, he'll easily be the all-time record holder for clearances, contested possessions, and handballs'. I'm resetting my hyperbole to focus on things like 'three of Melbourne's all-time games-played record holders are currently in our team' and 'our list has a really interesting variety of players who are each highly capable in their style'.
-
Kozzi Pickett - Will he be an all time MFC great?
He fell just 9 disposals short of being the first player since peak Stevie Johnson (2011?) to have both 20 disposals and 2 goals per game for a season. The lift in his sheer volume of output, without any drop in quality, has proven beyond doubt that he's a worker as well as a genius. 2025 for Pickett would seem almost as important as Ablett Jrs 2007, except that Pickett has never been an unrealised talent - he has been a 40ish goals per season forward since his second year. It'll be fascinating to see how his dynamism is woven together with the stalwart types Viney and Steele and the unpredictable amd diverse mix of young midfield and mid-forward candidates.
-
Welcome to Demonland: Picks 7 & 8
I've become increasingly convinced of the argument that things drop off by 7 and 8, which is unfortunate. I'd be perfectly okay with some of the options at our current picks (obviously I'm hoping for a double-Sam selection) who would likely be stalwart contributors, but every phantom draft and power ranking and anything else pumped out by the track watchers suggests that once you set aside the academies there are really only four or five of this year's crop projected to be outstanding players. Anyway, I'm an absolute sucker for nearest-the-pin speculations; Option 1, use 7 and 8 to build up a full 'best 25', with White and Sinnema completing our list. Option 2, go nuts burning 7 and 8 for an early selection and hope for a star, take White and Sinnema late, and have a SSP/midseason slot available. Option 3, use 7, live trade 8 with Carlton so they get ahead of the Harry Dean nomination, shenanigans ensue.
-
Rumours
So same age as Essendon's last finals win!
-
Welcome to Demonland: Jack Steele
If St Kilda goes off the rails, it'll be because they didn't have enough Steele. There, I did it. Mostly just for Demonstone's benefit. Who wants to make the 'something something staying on trac' joke? Nobody? Excellent. I think I'm just bumping this thread to reaffirm what a great acquisition Jack Steele is. And to wonder is the Saints are for the first time without a successor to the great Nathan Bourke-Robert Harvey-Lenny Hayes-Jack Steele progression of indomitable midfielders?
-
Rumours
Hawks falling short of a premiership and Essendon sinking another rebuild on the back of a petulant trade war is something we can all get behind. Ideally both clubs are left with disgruntled players on excessive retention payments dominating the locker room while losing honourable stalwarts to other clubs on the side. Not that we'd know anything about that.
-
Rumours
Remember from just before Game of Thrones went to absolute rot, there was a scene where Tyrian Lannister gave three different people each a different version about who some princess was going to be sent to marry, so that when the rumour broke it identified who was leaking and gossiping. Anyway, unrelated to that - I have a theory about the ridiculous "De Goey to Melbourne" rumour.
-
AFLW TRAINING: Wednesday 22 October 2025
I think 'I is i' brings an important philosophical side to the training routine. Tomorrow's session will focus on transition from half-back and Wittgenstein's early work. It will not be open to the public. Troop on, Ghosty, every typo is a proud scar! Speaking of which, did they 'put a fork in the ground under Steven King' as described over a zero hanger? https://www.zerohanger.com/melbourne-captain-breaks-silence-on-star-duos-departures-170124/ Ten points for whoever can get a player or coach to do that first.
-
Training Ground?
Please introduce me to these tier 1 builders - the apartment building I live in has been getting a 4 week remedial works program done on the balconies, which probably should only take 2 weeks, ongoing since early July... But at least there's no noise. The main challenge is getting builders who will actually prioritise your site over their multitude of off-the-books work. Hopefully when its a big enough project that problem is solved, he said, naively.
-
Rumours
Now there's a locker room conflict pre-packaged in a box with a bow. Or bottle, I guess. Makes Geelong look above board with the jobs at sponsors and property 'tips', too.
-
Demon Jacks
Jack Fitzpatrick. Jack Grimes. Hmm, that's just about the full box set.
-
Dawn of a new Era - Paul Guerra article 18.10.2025
As a side note, journalism was ruined because improvements in 'productivity' technology, as basic as microsoft word and a google search, made it possible for total non-experts to churn out $1 dross that resembled $10 real journalism enough to flood the market. Its a cycle that sits somewhere between the pottery wheel, which crashed the market for prestige ceramics for a millenia, and AI which is currently crashing the market for undergradauate essays, sincerity in communication, and [censored]. If you dig around you can find great sources of football news and views and inside knowledge, not least of them Demonland of course. The only thing holding it back at the moment is the power of the AFL HQ and 'Broadcast rights' holders. If the material was more open sourced, just imagine the kind of content which could be produced by the current enthusiastic and informed amateurs, if they could go full time! In the end, it is the monopoly on access and footage shared by an old clique which is the ENTIRE problem, and every time we undermine their business model we are doing football, journalism, and football, a favour.