Gouga

Its chris scott in catman's make up

Starting 0-5 would have cost thousands of memberships. We also have the MCC disadvatage. Paul Guerra has just come from an organisation that only exists because of membership. He needs to find a way to bring previous memners back and attract new ones.

May have been covered above, but pretty sure Sharp is out of contract. Was traded with one year to go and we have not extended.

Anyone know the rule? It would be awesome to see white and yze at the dees.

Oscar Berry the cat b selection is tagged as a tall defender in the James O'Donnell mold.

No doubt he gives his all. Just too limited too impact and prone to mistakes. Viney turned it over to carlton in the 2023 semi and viney failed to push back on the square against saints in the 46 point meltdown. He tries but often fails.

I am sorry, viney very rarely stands up in last quarters. He is a grinder but can't influence when momentum is against us. 3 last quarter disposals on the weekend...

Agree. We didnt have a pick in the rookie draft which meant our a list is full. If we had a spot we cpuld have passed to keep it free. We are rolling with 43 players this year including mentha as our sole cat b.

At his best, a matchwinner. Was just happy to go this year. Pretty disappointing. He knows he is our best forward, and safe irrespective of effort which was clearly lacking those last 5 weeks or so.

The AMW situation is confusing. Is it the case we would push him to Rookie A so that we can pre-list both Riak Andrew and Ricky Mentha as Rookie Bs - which assumes they do not get bids in the national draft... If JT doesn't have a smokey in mind for our late pick, AMW or Hore could go straight to the senior list?

Got it. Makes sense.

Wow. If not caulfield than where? Surely these new board members realise a reasonable solution is better than no solution...

Does AMW need to find his way to the main list like mcvee? He has had 3 years as a b rookie but i can't find the rule about whether he can have a fourth?

Chaplin and McQualter have contracts. Would like to see McQualter shift to forwards and a new voice working with the midfields. Given we are tactically outcoached week to week, we need to look at the Opposition Strategy and Analysis role currently held by Sam Bradford too.

What is the vibe? Does trac look like he is part of the group?

Petracca watches us play live once and wants out... Now he knows how us supporters feel.

Only need one word for Clarry - "Selfish". Prefer to give away free kicks than work through the tag. Made it all about himself and not the team.

In addition to being the oldest professional football club... We codified the laws of the game, we were a foundation vfa and vfl club, we lost players in both world wars, we originated the father son rule, we were first to recruit irish players and we established the womens game and were a foundation aflw club. Also, we are the only team to have won a mens afl premiership and women's premiership with all 18 team competing.

A key forward???

Surely mcadam for billings...

Agree with many others. This bloke never gives credit to the opposition. Sore loser.

Any ideas who was running around in #13, #34 and #46? Current players or train on players?

100% agree. Hopefully this happens. Anyone know the average afl salary for 2023 v aflw?

We definitely had bad luck... BUT we didnt do enough to overcome it. Collingwood lost mcstay heading into the gf and murphy to concussion in the first quarter. If they lost they could also say they had no luck. But they didn't lose... Suprised how many here think we were the best team in it. We finished 6th and thats all we deserved.