Fat Tony

Key points from the AFL trade and contract news: Jack Macrae (Western Bulldogs) has requested a trade; St Kilda is a possible destination, offering a mid-draft pick. Geelong is not interested. Bailey Smith is expected to join Geelong. Mitch Duncan may sign a one-year deal with Geelong, eyeing 300 games. Jason Johannisen (Western Bulldogs) hopes for a new one-year deal. Jack Darling (West Coast) may join North Melbourne. Tom Barrass (West Coast) is linked to a potential trade with Hawthorn, with two first-round picks in play Brandan Parfitt (Geelong) is looking for a new club. Josh Battle (St Kilda) is likely to leave, with St Kilda aiming for free agency compensation. Liam Baker and Jack Graham could join West Coast. Harry Perryman and James Peatling (GWS) are also being eyed by several clubs. Jake Kolodjashnij is expected to sign a two-year extension with Geelong. Shaun Mannagh (Geelong) will be out of contract at the end of next year. Gary Rohan, Jed Bews, Rhys Stanley (Geelong): All are off-contract at the end of the season. Zach Tuohy (Geelong): Set to retire. Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong): Needs a new deal, likely after the season. Lawson Humphries (Geelong): Close to a new multi-year extension. Alex Keath, Dom Bedendo, Kelsey Rypstra, Lachie McNeil, Taylor Duryea (Western Bulldogs): Waiting on contract decisions.

I agree with this. Membrey makes sense as a depth option, but the mix of forwards is an issue. Pressure acts are crucial and Petty (14 per game), Fritsch (8), JVR (8), Turner (6) and Melksham (6) are poor pressure players. Membrey (10) is not much better We need more speed. Matt Owies (12) would be a player we could look at and Brandon Parfitt (25) was the eight best pressure player in the AFL this season. ANB was 10th best with 24 pressure acts per game.

He looks too heavy and slow anyway ;-)

Looks the goods. So much athleticism and looks coordinated. The future of AFL is African.

The more we hear about the challenges Goodwin is dealing with in managing key players (Oliver and Petracca in particular), the more respect you have for him as a coach and what he has achieved. Plus, the soft cap makes it unrealistic to sack a good coach with three years left on his deal. Even West Coast baulked at paying a tax for exceeding the cap and they have $50m in the bank.

Still a valuable player on the field but he is on a good wage. It would depend on the cost in picks and salary cap.

The sooner Christian and his family realise that HE is responsible for going back onto the ground, the sooner he will be able to move on. It was obviously the wrong decision (and I thought he should been taken come off because he was not going in for the ball in the second quarter) but the blame game is ridiculous. These things happen when you play contact sports.

Lindsay looks more like Jack Billings than Josh Kelly.

Brodie is contracted for 2 more seasons and would be on good money. I only see it working if Freo pay some of his whack. The other options include Setterfield, Hewett, Shiel, Zac Jones, Davies, Peatling, Perkins, and Couch x2.

This is partially correct, but the recruiters regularly get it wrong. (Darcy Wilson was pick 18 last year.) It very hard to pick AFL players in under 18s. Also, in any population distribution, it is the tails where there is big variance in ability. Some drafts have Hodge, Ball and Judd and some have some have Whitfield, O'Rourke and Plowman. But the difference after the pointy end the draft tends to be less between draft classes.

Goodwin has a history of making hard calls on talented players who lack professionalism, so it is no surprise that Oliver is on the table for the right price. With any potential Oliver trade, I would be much happier if we would accept less in picks and avoid paying salary. The draft is still highly inefficient and you can pick up players without premium picks. Look at the Cats side last night, which included Atkins (Rookie), Close (Rookie), Dempsey (Rookie), Duncan (#28), Zac Gutherie (Rookie), Jack Henry (Rookie), Homes (#20), Humphries (#63), Kolodjashnij (#41), Mannagh (#36), Miers (#57), Neale (#33), Mullin (Ireland) and Tom Stewart (#40) pulled out ill.

Sorry Frosty! I hate the Hawks more than I love you!

I think this strategy is a bad one. It is expensive and only made sense when we were definitely in the window. I would prefer we be more patient and focused on the long term now.

Houston is 27. Plus With free agency and such a liquid player transfer market, I am not sure the number of years is as valuable as it used to be. I think Port's asking price is a bit too rich, but Houston would be a good get.

Hynes looks a safe bet to be an AFL player. Big, powerful and skilled. I approve this message!

Obviously there is good depth of talent, but no players like Petracca, JHF, or Reid who you know are going to be AFL stars because of their size, speed and power and ball winning ability. I don't see a big gap between top 5 and top 10 or even top 30 here. Jagger Smith (expected to go number 1) looks a safe bet to be a very good player, but he is only small. Jhye Clarke had a similar game at U18 level and has not been able to establish himself at AFL level. I like the idea of sliding or selling our pick into the future because clubs pay a credit card interest rate to push up the draft it makes more long-run sense to receive interest than to pay it.

I don't see any slam dunk picks in this draft. I would be happy to trade down. That said, Sam Lalor looks the most ready made from the limited vision I have seen.

Not sure if this has already been posted. It gives the perspective of someone who knows the player trade market intimately. Pickering explains how poorly advised Trac has been throughout this process.

You need to be a leader who others will respect to be captain.

I’m glad I can still enjoy watching the 2021 grand final!

If we trade Petracca for sub par value all of the key people except for Goodwin and Taylor need to exit. Lamb, Roffey, Richo and Pert need to know they will never work in the AFL system again if they are spineless here.

Roffey was interviewed on SEN and made it seem like she had not been in contract with Petracca after his injury. This was clearly not the case (based on Petracca's interview on the MFC website where he even stated Roffey by name). The football media has been all over her for not offering enough support and this was clear from listening to SEN callers immediately after the interview. She needed to be on the front foot and correct the record.

It makes Roffey look like a dill for letting this idea hang out there for 30 hours uncorrected.

He would be slow at AFL level.

The club will need someone to fall on their sword and Roffey and Pert will suffice. The issues at the club are all because we have some DH players, but it is time for a fresh voice.