whatwhat say what
Life Member
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Forum: Melbourne Demons
Everything posted by whatwhat say what
-
Jordan Lewis Announces Retirement
love his passion and enthusiasm for footy
-
The 2019 Draft and Trade Targets Thread
carlton need pick 9 in order to ensure they have collateral for swans with papley - i can't see what they would have that would tempt us to part with pick 3 from a draft pick perspective
-
Splitting Draft Pick 3
it's going to be interesting to see what happens i'm not sure we'll necessarily look to add a player from gw$ i wonder if pick 6, pick 18 and a future first would be TOO much draft collateral for the franchise to give away in order to get it... if they came with that sort of offer it'd be pretty tempting
-
WELCOME TO DEMONLAND - ED LANGDON
excellent result!
-
Farewell Sam Frost
makes sense, particularly the bundling for next year
-
Farewell Sam Frost
and $650k saved in salary
-
Farewell Sam Frost
values frost as a pick in the lower 30s - about his value not fussed tbh as if we're any good he shouldn't be in our best 22
-
The 2019 Draft and Trade Targets Thread
in a heartbeat wouldn't pay hill $900k a year tho
-
Sam Gray
My impression has always been that heโs a bit lax defensively
-
Tom Green (Drafted by GWS Giants)
maybe if you nominate a player i think it's cos you genuinely WANT him - we certainly would've taken both heeney and mills when we nominated them in consecutive years, but swans were always going to match green is meant to be a very inside midfielder type, i believe? we are not really in the market for one of those neither are adelaide with both crouch bros, sloane as their core midfield trio, plus gibbs as well under a new coach BUT if we do think he's the third best player in the draft - and there seems to be some love for that school of thought in some quarters - then perhaps we will nominate him if we have pick 3 cos we haven't split it interesting times!
-
Tom Green (Drafted by GWS Giants)
if we nominate him, then yes, they have to match pick 3 = 2234 points they need 80% of points in order to 'match' the bid but i was under the assumption that as long as they could accumulate the points with 'extra' picks they had in second and third rounds in order to do so, as i'm sure sydney did when they matched our bid for mills before we took oliver (and thank the football gods they did so!) however, my learned friends on demonland assure me that it's a case of they have to use points from their next available pick (pick 6 = 1751 points), as well as whatever else is required in order to be at 1787 points, which is what they'd need to match as the equivalent of pick 6's points less a 20% discount as an academy matching system whole thing is a farce
-
Farewell Sam Frost
godwin's law invoked; thread dead
-
Tom Green (Drafted by GWS Giants)
Even if we do, theyโll match Be interesting to see what they offer us for the pick
-
WELCOME TO DEMONLAND - ADAM TOMLINSON
So whatโs the process for blocking someone again?
-
WELCOME TO DEMONLAND - ADAM TOMLINSON
But thatโs not the MFCSS way?!??
-
Splitting Draft Pick 3
next year's second rounder, as per how we want to do it this year
-
Splitting Draft Pick 3
nah
-
Splitting Draft Pick 3
we really don't need any more key defenders
-
Splitting Draft Pick 3
i would be pretty unimpressed if we did that
-
Brad Hill
pick 12 and 18 are now with the aints - there's yr two first rounders for brad hill
-
Splitting Draft Pick 3
freo have said they want two first rounders for brad hill - well there ya go, there's two first rounders!
-
Splitting Draft Pick 3
St Kilda has completed a pick swap with GWS to turn a top-10 draft pick into two later first-round selections. The Giants have gained pick 6 and pick 59 in return for picks 12 and 18
-
WELCOME TO DEMONLAND - ED LANGDON
lucas was pretty clear that it'll happen late, once everything else has played out - they're working towards the wednesday deadline
-
Splitting Draft Pick 3
Just take pick 3 to the draft, add top end talent
-
Splitting Draft Pick 3
I donโt believe they would not have to use 4 to match a Green nomination They could use points from other picks