Everything posted by whatwhat say what
-
2024 NATIONAL DRAFT ORDER AND SELECTIONS
quick request @Whispering_Jack, can you please highlight each mfc pick per round for easy viewing?
-
Welcome to Demonland Koltyn Tholstrup
common reoccurring theme for winners since the inaugural winner in 93: nathan buckley ben cousins byron pickett sam mitchell jared rivers brett deledio danyle pearce rhys palmer dan hannebery jaeger o'meara lewis taylor jesse hogan jaidyn stephenson luke jackson all played for two or more clubs
- Adam Simpson departs West Coast
- POSTGAME: Rd 17 vs West Coast
-
Adam Simpson departs West Coast
open season on meth coke players now, or does this actually make it less likely that they'll leave? middle aged blokes i'd be keen to have a chat with: tom barrass jake waterman liam ryan jack petruccelle (vic lad) alex witherden (vic lad) young'ns: harley reid (vic lad) rueben ginbey campbell chesser jack williams a lot of their players are wa born-and-bred - given our sheer number of wa lads, they might feel right at home with us, weather aside he's the ceo, so he's going to be appointing the next coach, not taking the job
- Adam Simpson departs West Coast
- Adam Simpson departs West Coast
-
TRAINING: Tuesday 9th July 2024
when was spargo last seen?
-
Jason Taylor - visionary or overrated
very hard - both have helped build premiership lists i would argue hine got kotd cos of the dacaii, moore father-son selections plus quaynor as a 'cheap' nga pick before the rules changed to limit access only to outside the top 40 unless yr a franchise 'club'
-
Jason Taylor - visionary or overrated
talls drafted by taylor... max king - rookie draft pick 19 2012: 0 afl games ❎ oscar mcdonald - pick 53 2013: 87 ✅ sam weideman - pick 9 2015: 75 ❎ mitch king - pick 42 2015: 0 ❎ liam hulett - pick 46 2015: 0 ❎ lachlan filipovic - rookie pick 8 2017: 0 ❎ tim smith (mature ager) - rookie pick 25 2017: 13 ❓ declan keilty (mature ager) - rookie pick 41 2017: 2 ❎ harrison petty - pick 37 2018: 75 ✅🏆 luke jackson - pick 3 2019: 91 ✅ 🏆 fraser rosman - pick 34 2020: 0 ❎ daniel turner - mid year pick 22 2020: 11 ✅ jacob van rooyen - pick 19 2021: 34 ✅ matthew jefferson - pick 15 2020: yet to debut ❓ jed adams - pick 38 2020: yet to debut ❓ will verrall - rookie pick 14 2020: yet to debut ❓ luker kentfield - mid year pick 11: yet to debut ❓ i'm probably being a bit generous to the 'later' picks, like o mac, but to get over 80 games out of a pick 50+ is not bad going, while i think it's pretty hard to judge the success / otherwise of those mature age picks like tim smith and i think turner is going to be a serious player for us for a long time, so that's a personal bias if two of jefferson / adams / verrall / kentfield contribute at afl level then his ratio of hits: misses for talls will look markedly better
-
Jason Taylor - visionary or overrated
derek hine at the filth
-
Welcome to Demonland: Caleb Windsor
i still think he's going to end up developing as an outside / inside player - judd is the high water mark i LOVE how he hits the packs at pace and is still balanced when he kicks it, especially for goal; he just moves so beautifully around the ground
-
"Very sore" Max Gawn in doubt for next Saturday vs Essendon
peptides love to play a fast moving, quick ball movement, low contest game where they stretch the ground and use their pace we will need to turn it into a slog
- TEN YEARS AFTER by Whispering Jack
-
Jason Taylor - visionary or overrated
oh, and i didn't even count in the rookie draft - james harmes is also a chance of cracking 200 games by the time his career is done all three of salem, hunt, and harmes are now at over 150 afl games that's a great trio of selections
-
Jason Taylor - visionary or overrated
for starters, jimmy toumpas was brilliant in his draft year, captaining south australia at the underage tournament, played in the sanfl all year, and played in a premiership at that level the previous year as a 16 year old... i would have thought that taylor has little to do with trading so that's completely irrelevant to any rating of jason taylor's performance as national recruiting manager, where his focus is on the kids coming through two of the three picks he made in 2013 will end up playing over 200 games of afl - that's a massive win by any measure
-
Welcome to Demonland: Ricky Mentha
it'll be interesting to see if he goes top 40 or slides out to being available to us
-
Welcome to Demonland: Ricky Mentha
any reports on how it went?
- PREGAME: Rd 18 vs Essendon
-
Welcome to Demonland Koltyn Tholstrup
i presume it's just the hair and the low centre of gravity body shape, but kolt reminds me of buddha hocking he has incredible enthusiasm for the contest - after one of the roo f50 marks he first pumped like crazy, and after high fiving someone else he turned around and went to high five...a meth coke player
-
Potential Father Son Prospect Noah Yze
apaz he played on one of the likely top selections today (i presume josh smillie), and more than held his own? fwiw, yze was voted 2nd best for oakleigh today, and smillie was not named in the best stats here he's played for oakleigh 6 times and been in the 'best players' in the last 4 games he's played in for oakleigh
- POSTGAME: Rd 17 vs West Coast
- PREGAME: Rd 18 vs Essendon
- VOTES: Rd 17 vs West Coast
-
Jake Melksham returning
9 marks, 9 kicks, 2 goals 1 on return opened up our forward line, and minimised their ability to rebound super to have him back out there