Jump to content

Whispering_Jack

Administrators
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Whispering_Jack

  1. Unfortunate for the Tigers with that five day break and the need to manage two of their veterans as well as the last minute loss of another veteran in Grimes. The result gave the appearance of a team waving the white flag - they looked out of it both physically and mentally from the outset. This could also make or break McQualter’s coaching ambitions so it’s going to be interesting to see if he can get them to reset in the final three rounds.
  2. Today’s media is enraptured with Carlton forward Charlie Curnow and rightly so after his recent goal kicking feats. He was highly touted as a potential high draft pick during his draft year (2015) but a story came out just before the draft about an alleged (I stress “alleged”) indiscretion involving driving and alcohol which caused him to slide down the ranks. He was eventually picked at 12 by Carlton where his brother Ed was already a senior list player. He was the Blues’ third pick in that draft behind Jacob Weitering (#1) and Harry McKay (#10). Curnow was considered a bit of a “slider” as many pundits had him well inside their top ten. Melbourne had two top ten picks in that year and struck it rich with their pick four in Clayton Oliver who was a bit of a “bolter” having been well outside the early top ten boards. The Demons chose Sam Weideman at #9 so our recruiters considered him better than two ultimate Coleman Medalists. We weren’t the only club that would be ruing the fact that they allowed Curnow to slide in his draft year - the Lions selected current Demon Josh Schache at pick 2 in the same draft. So, when we mull over the pros and cons of trading up our multiple high draft picks, it might be worthwhile considering that not all that glitters is gold and that there can be bargains gained in looking at draft sliders and understanding why they might have fallen out of favour. These are Rookie Me Central’s top 5 draft sliders for 2023 and they include a player who impressed when he trained with the club as one of two AFL Academy work experience trainees in the pre season. Bargain Hunting: The 2023 AFL Draft sliders
  3. Back in 1990 Melbourne won and the votes went to the Bears -
  4. Does Graham Cornes know something we don’t know or is he just trying to outdo son Kane for outrageous, contrarian thinking?
  5. Amazing what a Dockers win has done to this thread which I found on Page 3. Anyway, this is how things stand with four rounds to play:-
  6. Now that he’s retired, this has been renamed “The Lance 'Buddy' Franklin Non Thread”.
  7. Cardinal rule in football is take things one week at a time. We’re playing North Melbourne this week - let’s concentrate on that game. 😀
  8. Whispering_Jack replied to Romey's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Could it be announced as early as tomorrow?
  9. The Rookie Me Central July Power Rankings are out and it’s no surprise that Harley Reid is still #1.
  10. People are referring to the fact that the results in the games played so far in this round have been upset games but Richmond are on a bit of a run having won 6 out of their last 7 games which is a better run that we’ve had in that time. So in reality, it’s us who have our backs against the wall and on that basis, I believe we’ll follow the trend of the round by upsetting the Tigers.
  11. Kelli Underwood late in the game at Carrara - "This is a significant 4 minutes coming up in the history of the Gold Coast Lions"
  12. Never rely on GCS to win games late in the season.
  13. Now Casey’s fate is in its own hands with Gold Coast’s big comeback over the Lions. All the Demons have to do is win their three remaining games and percentage won’t even come into it. A win tomorrow would put Casey half a game behind them with a home game against them in the final round. Box Hill won today and will probably win their remaining games to finish third.
  14. Meanwhile, Casey’s hopes of making the top four are evaporating. They depend on one of the teams above them losing one or two games and of course, winning all of their remaining games. I was hoping the Brisbane Lions might lose to top side Gold Coast at Carrara but late in the first quarter they were 40 points up on the Suns.
  15. On a happier note, we did get up to beat Essendon on the following Saturday. Robert Walters kicked nine goals.
  16. On this day, 28 July, in 1979 ...
  17. I just have this feeling that Carlton will win tonight.
  18. Jayden Short failed to come up for Richmond which is a win for us as far as I’m concerned.
  19. An interesting “in” ~ K. Brown, son of Doggy Casey has had some torrid clashes against the Seagulls in recent years so it needs to be at full strength. This team looks quite strong to me.
  20. I reckon Millie gets four weeks for the strike in the last round. Deliberate, high contact and high impact.
  21. Good fight but I’d like to see her playing footy in the future.
  22. No mention of Jake Bowey who copped a knock in the game vs Adelaide which makes him favourite for the mystery injury for this week.
  23. They just beat bottom three club Hawthorn with a last ditch effort late in the game. Yes, they are still aiming for the finals but I’m not convinced.
  24. There were some gems involved in early Saturday morning viewing during the late 70s.
  25. Some more mixed messaging to throw people off the scent?