old55
-
Posts
9,713 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
38
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Everything posted by old55
-
Where have you "heard" that "picks are seperate bidding systems" - link please. How will they know "pick 1 would cost too much"? A club could wait until pick 1 is gone before getting involved but why do that - they might make the best offer and GWS might accept it for pick 1. It just makes no sense.
-
GWS can't trade pick 2 until they've traded pick 1 - what happens if they can't do a suitable trade for pick 1? They'll have to trade the picks in order and clubs will be bidding for pick 1 first. I expect it to go down to the wire on Thursday with clubs bidding for pick 1 - the offer GWS thinks is best will get pick 1, they'll offer pick 2 to the next best offer - the club making that offer can accept pick 2 or decline, etc until the the offers are not acceptable or time runs out.
-
I imagine the keep trading up to 4 until they stop. For example, they trade pick 1, then theyy trade pick 2, then they say "that's it for this year" unless they get an offer too good to refuse for pick 3.
-
There's Trade week this year, there's a Mini Draft this year at the end of the Trade Week, GWS can trade up to 4 picks in this year's Mini Draft, deals have to be finalised by Thursday of the Trade Week. The traded picks are 1.2.3. up to 4 in this years Mini Draft. If GWS don't trade any picks there's no Mimi Draft this year. If they trade all 4 picks this year, there's no Mini Draft next year. If GWS trade less than 4 picks this year, then next year same thing happens as this year with the remaining picks . Next year's picks become picks 1,2,3 etc in next year's Mini Draft. What's so hard to understand?
-
They've got a maximum of 4 over 2 years but they don't HAVE to trade any. They'd be mad if they didn't but they don't have to. Thety can't take O'Meara this year, but if they don't trade any this year, they can pick up O'Meara with ND pick 1 (which they'll probably have for finishing bottom next year) in 2012 when he eligible.
- 454 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- Trade week
- Jaeger OMeara
- (and 1 more)
-
Good find Lulz. That's great news about the deals having to be stitched up by end of Thursday trade week - I was worried Sheedy and Gumby would hold up all other trades until the death. RPFC, my understanding is the trades work like any other, there's a week long Trade Period starting on Monday, half way through is the deadline for these trades. Clubs offer GWS trades, GWS makes a decision on what to accept and gives the picks out in order, clubs are bidding for pick 1 first, then pick 2 - through to as many as GWS want to trade up to the maximum of 4.
-
They have 2 years to do it over and they don't HAVE to, but they can and it's in their best interests to do so because they can't pick up those players.in that year.
-
OK typical of the HUN they f'ked it up. Here's the real order from the AFL site with the Priority selection for GC, Port and Brisbane included: http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/122666/default.aspx
-
See WC Priority Pick 26 Jack Darling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_AFL_Draft
-
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/complete-2011-draft-order/story-fn69a32t-1226157936865 Looks like you're right Jack - no Priority Picks this year, but WC picked up Darling with a PP last year - it doesn't seem fair to Port and Brisbane (not that GC needs any more picks).
-
I think you mean "compensation picks" not "priority picks" they're something else for less than 5 wins. Last year WC had a priority pick at the end of the 1st rouind for less than 5 wins - where are the picks for GC and Port? It looks like Brisbane may have one at 27. It doesn't make sense.
-
McLean on what $350K? How are they going to realise any of that - he's contracted next year and no-one will touch him unless the Blues give him away and pay his salary? Godadrd would want $800K+ to move.
-
I call impossible - Goddard is in contract and what have they got to offer that they'd give up? Kane Lucas and pick 25 (or whatever they've got) is not going to do it. If Goddard went to GWS next year the Saints would get band 1 compo = 2 x 1st rounders - that's the minimum starting position.
-
Ah yes, great get - where is he now?
-
Went to Richmond. They were always the biggest threat.
-
Surely not us - it seems likely Collingwood leaked the Neeld appointment on the Friday when he told them he was off, before his announcement as our coach on the Saturday.
-
Saw a thread on that Demonland forum suggesting they might get Patrick Dangerfield ...
-
It's worth consideration - I thought he was OK late in the season - they're missing Kruezer (and Waite) who is clearly far superior. The fact is you get what you pay for and those wanting someone for Bate, Warnock or Dunn are shopping in the Setatnta department. Kosi would cost considerably more in trade and salary.
-
We need midfield stars full stop. I'm unconvinced any midfielder on our list will be a star.
-
He was out of contract in 2009, think he got 4 years - expect a big year in 2013.
-
A million Kims and a million keyboards?
-
Hagdorn kiss of death - guaranteed not to happen now.
-
Looks unbelievably good. Both Compo picks plus decent player if necessary.
-
That looks right to me - not sure if that makes "8 coaches" but the structure looks right - a "senior assistant" in addition to that sounds like overkill
-
Craig is a big PR win and morale booster for the club.
