Roost it far

Surely he can now take your man Jefferson with him. Christ Picket, his game today was worse than bad. Zero impact.

Frustrating as per our new standard. If Jefferson is AFL standard then so am I, sheesh he’s ordinary. Apologies to the bloke but fair dinkum. Thankfully JVR reminded us that he’s an AFL footballer. We should bow out of the season now, it’s too painful to watch.

It’s annoying when the perfect comeback cones to mind later Ron.

No counterpunch…..you gotta work on that. There’s a host of them.

Personally I’d offer May to Nth Melbourne and play Petty at full back. I’ve loved having May at full back the last 5 years, the total package but he’s cooked.

There’s a lot of Melbourne supporters who would disagree with that sentiment.

I don't get the reference to a drinks card. Clearly I'm missing a simple explanation here. Which you can give in the next response :)

Whats drink card boy in response to?

It doesn’t float mine either. Watching ordinary football isn’t that enjoyable

You clearly haven't been reading my posts.

The bath's empty and the babie's gone!

I don’t see our problems as list issues, which is not saying we can’t improve in that area. I’m of the opinion on that MacRae would have this list in the top handful. Collingwood’s list is thin, Frampton, Markov and there’s others all slot into a system that is so well drilled that they keep winning. So where does that leave us? I’m ready for a new coach but get it wrong and we really are in trouble as we could easily do worse. We weren’t miles off this season but again the same issues persist which has to fall on the coaches. One point to remember in all this is Goodwin was also dealt the Oliver and Petracca disasters. They weren’t his fault and he’s now playing his 2 Aces when in actual fact he’s holding a 10 of spades and a Jack of Clubs. Put those 2 back at their very best and we possibly aren’t having this conversation. Imagine if Richmond after 2017 had a 20% drop in form from Martin and Cotchin? Anyway I’ll continue to oscillate from absurd confidence to general malaise. At least Kozz ain’t leaving at years end!

They’re there, you just gotta look

We got changed in the snow and then walked 9kms to the ground in bare feet in a blizzard.

Operation get the Bergman

I get that but he’s contracted and has been good at Casey. Sharp offers little and Tholstrup’s all fizz and no bang. JVR and Jefferson should be given a month to show if they can be our forwards.

Not sold on the changes. Not sure what Sharp brings, Tholstrup has no form, Jefferson is vanilla but the cheap type. I’d of kept JVR, dropped Viney and Lever and bought in Jefferson and Laurie, who surely deserves a run. Melksham as sub. If May gets flogged then it’s Adam’s time.

I wouldn’t think so.

If we go into next season with the The 3 Butchers in the midfield and our 21 defensive pillars we may as well not bother.

What if the club put Petracca , Oliver, Lever and May on the market.

I’d love LJ but surely it’s unlikely

Who would that be?

Having just watched the 360 segment I’m really not sure what else people expect from Goodwin. He answers the questions, explains his reasoning around quality of entries and provides a bit of hope regarding Caulfield. He does that whilst being clearly under an enormous amount of pressure. He knows the metrics that he’s judged by. I’m happy for him to be replaced but canning him on these segments is absurd.