Roost it far

He’s not disenchanted. He wants a Premiership and he’s very unlikely to get that here

West coast were a powerhouse with recent premierships. We’re a battling nobody that no one cares about. You start losing your best players and Oliver is a once in a generation mid and we’re [censored]. How many more years do you want to wait for a Premiership? You’re kidding yourself if you don’t realise that.

If this club starts losing players of Oliver’s caliber it’s all over. If you don’t agree you’ve got no idea

If Oliver were to leave that would be the end of this club

I like the sound of Phillips

Word is that Clayton is uncoachable

Keep

I really hope we don’t lose TMac.

Could he become our Benny Gale who’s had a big influence on turning the tigers around?

I thought Pickett showed plenty and expect as fitness and confidence grow he’ll become a very handy acquisition

Take him in a heartbeat. Anyone who thinks a fit Brown doesn’t improve us is mad

No, no and no. He’s not the player we need.

We need people who know how to get the best out of this club. Is he that person? I think Yze is our next coach

Yze was a match winner at his best. His years under Clarkson can only bring valuable insights. Personally I don’t care if we get him or not. Our head coach has a lot to learn and he best get started soon

No idea ?

I’ve changed my mind, keep them all, get in some outside talent with experience and get TMac fit and firing

Yes we can and for the right return we should consider it. It’s a team game and he’s but an individual

?‍♂️?‍♂️

?‍♂️

As a team we lack the outside polish. If a Premiership is the only reason to exist then surely one or two or even three of Viney, Harmes and Brayshaw have to be traded. I’d be shopping all of them around and would be shocked if the club wasn’t. If TMac’s body can be got right and you’d think it could he’s a must keep. Add some run and polish, a forward line of Weideman, TMac and Jackson and a couple of quality assistant coaches and we win 4 more games and end up top 4. We’re actually not that far off. In a year when there’s going to be a lot of assistants looking for work surely we can find our next coach. Goodwin has less than a year to get this club where it should be.

Haven’t you got anything better to do

Must keep

At the right price, absolutely yes. Weid as the third tall, TMac at CHF and Brown at FF. If all captured their best form surely we could kick a winning score??

Can he get fitter and run a wing?

It’s a great opportunity to win the flag. If, and it’s a big if, we can keep a settled 22 injury free and win the close ones Richmond remains the team to beat. Must capitalise on a strong preseason and finish top 4. Was 2018 a fluke? I’m really only interested in a flag, seen other clubs improve quickly and can’t see why that can’t be us. I’m confident as still think our best 22 playing together is a good side. oh and I think some here massively over rate Fritsch. I’d be surprised if he didn’t find himself back at Casey as he continues to develop