Abyssal

One would hope that the Powerbrokers would have started the discussion once the final siren blew after the North game.

Yes, the good news is we’re only 3 games and percentage outside the 8. 😉

The way things are going anything is possible. I wouldn’t even rule out a player revolt against Goodwin currently being the problem, of course that being contrary to the popular belief that the players “love” the coach.

On what basis should that performance be “all we can expect for the moment” ? Your comment suggests that we can expect improvement in the future. From where is this improvement to come?

Just curious, did you see Van Rooyen‘s “performance” last week?

A Very skilful player with quick reflexes so no problem when in traffic. He might struggle for pace when out in the open or when chasing an opponent. My current concern however is a doubt over his confidence and self belief. Given time, this should not be an enduring problem, we hope. However a situation arose on the Sunday footy show which doesn’t appear to be mentioned here (perhaps no one watches the show). On the handball segment Harvey’s effort on the right hand was diabolical (the worst I can recalling seeing). It was jarring to watch and the panel members seemed to be in shock. No doubt a humiliating situation for the young bloke to find himself in. I suspect he knew of the likely outcome as he was reluctant to use that hand, saying he wasn’t aware he needed to use the opposite hand. Regardless, he now has to deal with the embarrassment and possible ridicule from opposition supporters and maybe even players. Which leads me to question why did the club sanction his appearance on the show. Surely someone would have known his “capabilities” of handballing with his right hand.

What is the Value of Fritsch ? If he’s NOT kicking goals, what is he actually good for? Is it his run and carry, his defensive efforts, his pack marking, his physicality, his high possession count, his leadership qualities, his desperation, his clearance work?

The reason for our current plight I believe are many and varied. However the start of our demise , albeit gradual, at least until last week,(now in freefall) can be traced back to the off season after the premiership win. Whilst nothing showed up on field until around mid season of 22, the affect of winning 17 straight and the way we did it IMO lead to and arrogance and inflated ego for many players, mostly senior. I suspect they thought they were unbeatable. Winning games in 10 minute bursts, kicking multiple goals at the flick of a switch, bang, bang, bang, must have felt like walking on water. Whilst all this was happening what did Simon do? Other than not changing anything, “ contested footy”, or adapting a new style or method or showing flair at selection, I suspect he did nothing. Perhaps he turned a blind eye to negative behaviours? By all means disagree if you like. But if you do, consider this, my understanding is that senior players were doing ‘sportsmans’ nights/shows celebrating the Premiership win around rural Victoria in late January 2022, only weeks from the start of the season. Surely those celebrations should have ceased by the end of November at the latest, probably even earlier. The start of the beginning of the End.

Why did he/Goodwin mention it, who knows? Maybe by making an excuse for the disappointing performance of the teams captain and driving force, by extension he is actually making an excuse for the teams performance overall. Consequently he could be covertly trying to taking some pressure off himself for the poor performance. I’m not saying it was definitely deliberate, possibly just a slip of the tongue. Regardless, the whole thing was hardly newsworthy.

Swap Petty and Turner, send Fritsch to Casey and bring in Oliver who I can’t see in your side and I think you may have it.

Sunday Herald Sun page 91 shows a photo of Darcy Moore shoulder charging Sam Darcy in what was referred as a “marking contest”. Does anybody know if this has been under the spotlight? Nb. I haven’t seen the video. Ps. I think this is now No.4 of questionable incidents by Moore since KB.

Yes, great point.

If Goodwin is to be replaced, now is the time to do it. Not after the season’s finished, not mid year, do it now. After just 2 games, this season is still salvageable. I just can’t see what Goodwin can do or say to turn things around after today’s horror show. A fresh voice/approach might just be the impetus the players need turn their form around. The alternative of keeping Goodwin in place and then things not improving on todays outcome would likely result in MFC finishing bottom 3 with a real chance for the wooden spoon. Trying to recover from that scenario next year (and beyond) would be near on impossible for a new coach and definitely impossible for Goodwin should he somehow remain coach next year.

Yes, could have been anything! Always thought he was G. Ablett snr Mk11 without the strength.

Too right, Jakovich and any of Schwarz (pre-knee) Neitz, Lyon or Jurrah would win by a furlong over the star-billing of Curnow and McKay. The Wiz for icing.

Struth, where to begin? So according to you “best forward in the last 50 years” equates to the forward that plays the most games? On that flawed rationale, how then can you say Fritsch is better than Lyon, Neitz, Green and Robertson, all of who played more games than Fritsch. Please clarify. PS. Jakovich 4.28 goals per game Fritsch 1.68 goals per game Jakovich not streets ahead, suburbs.

Are you serious? Did you see any of Lyon, Bennett, Jakovich, Schwarz, Neitz, or Farmer play? If Liam Jurrah could have played longer he would have out-rated Fritsch IMO. Did you mean the last 5 years, not 50 years—- typo perhaps?

I would add David Schwarz and Darren Bennett to that list.

Was at the match, for 57 years I’ve held the memory of Hassa kicking the winning goal by snapping over his shoulder from deep in the left hand forward pocket in heavy traffic. The video says otherwise. If only there was a replay of Queen’s Birthday Round 9 1967 v South Melbourne, Hassa kicked 7 in a big win.

Ditto

“WITHOUT WORRYING ABOUT THE FACTS” That being the case, surely it is unreasonable for you to criticise anybody on this site who makes an unsupported statement or even just for expressing their opinion.

Has the 2025 draw been announced? I must have missed it.

As an observer I think you will find he said a lot more than that amongst his numerous vitriolic posts.

This is the third post today by Jay Clark that has left me wondering, who does Jay Clark work for, Geelong FC or Clayton Oliver’s management.

No, I totally agree. If we genuinely want him gone I think we should fight tooth and nail for the best deal until the last minute of trading. And pay zero of his salary. I also think we should be working overtime with every other club and not giving Geelong the time of day. If no suitable deal can be done, he stays. If he then plays at Casey for the whole year @ $1,000,000- + it would bring into focus player contracts and farce the really are.