Deeko2

Two names here that I thought were going to be stars for us for a long time. Both of these players I was against trading at the time and when so I deep down hoped they'd go on to have decent careers somewhere else.... I don't recall either of them ever firing a shot. Living in the bush I don't get to go to many games but I was at the G early on in Sam's career where he put on a clinic on the wing. He would have had close to 30 touches and I'm pretty sure polled some Brownlow votes. I was there the next year when he kicked a few against the Saints.... must have been his good luck charm. Jordy also started positively I believe winning a lot of the pill early on in his career. It seems both of these players got worse the longer they played for us. I hated Cam after his first year, thought he was the biggest flop of all time... especially after he ducked his head early. By the end of his time however I had a massive man crush on him. The way he kept using his body as a battering ram and played with passion made him one of my favourites and was happy to see a bloke finally get all he could out of his body - although I think it took a few rockets for him to click. I thought out best trade out was Watts. I was personally sick of defending him and had heard stories that he was a little bit naughty away from the club. Obviously a talented boy but I think everyone agrees he lacks the dedication to be great. Very happy with your Fritter - when he plays forward!!

FB: Jetta. May. Hibberd. HB: Young. Lever. Salem Mid. Langdon. Viney. Tomlison HF. Petracca. Weid. Melksham FF. Fritsch. T Mac. Bennell R: Gawn. Oliver. Brayshaw Int: Harmes, Hunt, Jones, P8 It’s actually a fairly strong 22 if in form but there are some fair dinkum “what if’s” in this squad that it’s still worrying. Will Viney, Jetta and Hibberd get back in form? And we’re our forwards in TMac and Weid one hit wonders? Will Young (assuming) become a Nick Haynes or a James Strauss? We’ve seen what nearly every player in this squad can/has done so if we’re fit and not a top 6 team this year I’ll be asking serious questions

I never bought fully into the hype last year on Sam but haven’t also committed to the pessimism that a few around here have either. I still feel as I always have that Sam will be a solid CHF, not a star, just a decent role player. He’s still a kid who basically gets tagged every week by a gun defender and has to deal with crappy delivery and a non functioning forward line. He’s clearly low on confidence at the moment as his set shot kicking in his short career (up until the last few weeks) has always been beautiful and his hands aren’t quite as sure however we have seen enough moments to back in the kid for a while to come. He should still be playing twos even now and make him tear games apart there and kick the door down, demanding to get back into the ones. Instead, through no fault of his own we’ve thrown him (and Oscar) into the wolves as under developed players trying to be key men in a poorly playing team and have had to deal with over the top expectations. I still think he will be fine and will continue to improve with time. Have faith

Has been playing on a wing which is where demon players go to die the way we move the pill. I think he adds more on the HFF than Spargo/Garlett and adds more in the guts than Viney at present. Id just leave him as a forward. He’s quick enough in close and still hard as a cats scone. He just gets burnt in space and it’s hard to watch

Frustrating basic mistakes from our defence. Oscar and Wagner spoiling to dangerous spots and Fritta wrapping a bloke up for no good reason. Just little things they all need to be better at.

The season is cooked and there would have been zero reason to play him anyways. I’d rather continue with ANB, Strech, Spargo etc, all players I don’t rate at the moment but need to be given chances to see if they’re up to it going forward. I don’t particularly care that he smacked someone in the twos and gets a week. I’d be more upset if he got picked to play over giving time developing some kids. As a recruit he has been fine. Yes it was a superfund top up but he gave us further relevance as a destination club and I’m sure his insights as a once wonderful player with the ultimate success has been priceless. Now Jordy, please retire from senior footy for the year and provide some guidance in the twos and/or on match days in the box.

I'm not a fan of Billy unfortunately at the moment. Works hard but his skill level is awful. Still - I'd persist with him over say Lewis for the rest of the year. The season is cooked so mind as well get as much time into Stretch/Lockhart/Baker/Spargo/Hore etc as possible to see if they will make it or not and to harden there bodies to stress of AFL footy.

Stretch Baker Lockhart Fritsch Garlett C Wagner J Wagner O Mac Petty Garlett Spargo Smith All VFL standard footballers. Some may get there but right now there is a lot of battlers above. A good team has to carry some players and that’s where role players can shine. Usually it’s only when 3 or 4 of the above get a game. No team however can carry a dozen fringe players like we are and can expect to compete. Unfortunately when the heat was on today, GWS looked faster, tougher and hell of a lot more skilful than our mob. There cue was well and truly in the rack for the last and I take nothing from that. Even with all the effort in the world you need some skill across the group and there is so many in that team who have minimal

Frost is such a polarising player. He has moments where I sit back in amazement with his chasing, tackling and courage in the air only to see him completely shank something so simple later on. I think Hore is just a solid role player and chipping away nicely. I saw this thread whilst playing golf with a fello dees supporter yesterday who summed it up asking would you rather play an even round with 18 pars (Hore) or an even round with 9 birdies and 9 bogeys (Frost) I’d still lean towards Frost as we need all the speed we can get but christ he stresses me out with the pill in his hands

Just read the report on the Melbourne FC web page about Hibbo only being out for a couple which is handy. It’s hard to compete when your first choice backline is looks like: FB: Knee. Knee. Concussion HB: Groin. Groin. Collarbone emergency (Lewis) to be advised. edit: forgot our forward line: HF: Knee. Soreness. Ankle FF: Foot TMac Jeffy

6. Salem. Absolute class. Never worried when the pill is in his hands 5. Milkshake. He was everywhere early while having a defender all over him. 4. Oliver. An amazing last quarter, he just bullied the opponents and never gave in 3. Jones. Back in the guts where he belongs and has to stay. Having a good couple weeks 2. Frost. Christ this bloke is frightening, exciting, mesmerising and then utterly ridiculous. 1. Harmes. Was everywhere early and kept powering on

I will keep defending the Weid as I always say young key forwards need a lot of time and patience however I feel we have massively over rated the impact that we expected him to have this year based on about 5 quarters of finals footy. I really worry that trading Hogan is going to turn out as a disastrous move.

The cats are looking seriously good and will be there late in September..... again.... Not flinching and backing themselves into hold Kelly was ballsy but could pay off with a flag the way they are looking. Plus getting some genuine speed in Rohan and Dahlhaus is paying huge dividends. I’m so sick of them but worse, I’m incredibly jealous of them.

Scully was cheap (trade wise) not just because of his injury if I remember correctly. He was still on big dollars and in contract which means that the hawks have to pay this in full. GWS clearly accepted less than what he would go for (trade wise) in order for someone to take over and pay his contract in full.

I get what you’re tying to stay but all teams have to give players mandatory leave post the end of the year and then usually start preseason the moment that finishes. So teams finishing earlier without finals obviously start preseason earlier. One would expect the boys who finish late in September would still be professional enough to look after themselves.

FB: Jetta. Lever. Hibberd HB: Smith. May. Kolodjashnij We have one person available from our best backline (imo) in Hibberd who isn’t exactly in great form. Id say the backline is the most important group of players who need to ‘gel’ for a team to be successful. They need to know who is going to go and when and back there team mate to win the contest. I genuinely feel this year is toast. Can only hope all these boys get ten weeks after the bye to play together and develop something great.

We can’t play Weid/TMac/Preuss in the same forward line. Teams walk it out when it hits the ground. If all three are to play TMac to play CHB and take one of Lynch/Riewoldt. We have been hiding him up forward and he’s in Struggletown big time. ANB may have had plenty of it in the twos but still butchered it from all accounts. He has to stay and work on that as he’s a momentum killer in the ones and the biggest down hill skier we have. I’d be disappointed if he was back in. Stretch didn’t deserve to be dropped after one match and should come back in. Garlett as well must play. Lewis, well I loved recruiting him and his first year and a half I was a big fan. He has his superfund topped up and now he can sail into the sunset. He will be destroyed by the tigs leg speed. It’s time to put a line through him like the hawks did courageously three years back. I hate the hawks but admire the way clarko is ruthless to win. So for me: Out: C Wagner and Lewis In: Stretch and Garlett.

The way teams have sliced us open this year on the rebound is frightening and I worry this will lead to at least a 10 goal loss of the Tigs bring there pressure. Lynch/Riewoldt would be picking there lips for Wednesday night. Not sure how we will stop them from kicking a bag against us.

You may have missed our ginger headed All Australian and Bluey Truscott winning midfielder.....

Didn’t Clark re-injure his foot and then have some soft tissue injuries (calf) on the same leg multiple times? From what I remember, he continually tried to come back to early as he wanted to repay the faith but should have been told to cool his jets. Not sure if this is Missons job or not. Trengove story is similar in continually playing injured. This has more to do with us picking a 21 year old kid as captain (similar to what we may have done with Viney!!!)

Wow I feel sorry for our key forwards , what chance do they have? The only contests they get to are 50m bombs in where they are flying for massive contested grabs each time. I’m a fan of the Weid but he has no chance of out marking multiple men and even when he brings it down it’s just gone so quickly. TMac struggling even more is worrying. He did have off season surgery but remained one of the fittest in the club with the time trials. He shouldn’t have lost much touch but looks a shell of his 2018 self. Still, my biggest worry remains being this crap footy of bombing it in to big contests has got to stop. It’s u/14 rubbish. You’re an afl footballer, lower your eyes and hit a lead for goodness sake. Back your skill. It’s the same crap we whinged about last year when we were playing poorly. Unfortunately, even though he has played well, Preuss makes it very hard to retain the ball up forward. His hands aren’t great and he adds zero pressure on the deck. If he is going to stay in (seems likely) then TMac or Weid must go to bring in another quick to lock it in. We are missing AVB and Hannan more than we are missing Lever/May at present. It’s embarrassing how quickly the ball hits the turf and rebounds so quickly with minimum pressure.

I don’t think it was Hibberd alone handling him. Hore had a go at him for a while as well from what I saw. Don’t think we had any other options with Frost taking Bruce. Membrey is a different match up being quite quick for a tall defender and still marks quite high for a mid defender (Hore/Hibbo). If he was a hawk, pie or tiger everyone would rave about him imo. He’s a pretty handy player who loves playing us unfortunately

Linked up nicely twice then had a shocker of a turnover under no pressure which looked very lazy. Zero tackles to half time however is the biggest glaring stat for me. Isn’t this what he is meant to bring? Very disappointing today. Needs a massive second half or it will be Jeffy time vs the tigs

I’ve been calling for it but I never take satisfaction in a young kid being dropped. I still think at present we will be better off without him in as he’s having a poor season. I’m intrigued around your comment on if May/Lever were playing that he’d play on the third tall. He very well could but I still think he will always get the main man as a pure stopper with May/Lever floating across for help and a chop out. Those two are better defenders but by far more valuable to intercept and rebound as well. If Oscar plays, I think it will be in a role similar to Astbury/Talia/Frawley who would still take the key forward and focus on nothing more than defence defence defence.

I wasn’t aware of this stat to be honest and was having a read of footywire to get some context. Its a positive he is leading our club but his average per game lists him at 37 on the list and is behind nearly every fullback in the league. This is not only poor as he offers zero offensively but poor because the pill is in our defence more than every other team in the comp. We have been the host heavily scored against team this year by far. I’m just as disgusted in the rest of our defenders who don’t appear higher in this list. They are getting plenty of opportunity. I know he puts his body on the line and will cop one for the team. I don’t doubt this courage at all in that regard. What I meant was courage in the air taking the intercept mark. Hes our key defender playing for the heaviest scored against team and doesn’t appear in the top 100 players of intercepts this year. I want him to back himself, mark the pill or fist it 30 yards from the contest. As for Goodwin picking him, what other choice does he have with the main two on the sidelines? Also, he’s clearly not rated that highly noting that even though we have the poorest kicking team in the comp (my thoughts) and the slowest, we still traded our last three first round draft picks for key defenders.... what does that tell you? I sound like an Oscar hater and I’m really not. I’d love nothing more than him to turn it around this week and you to come back and say “told you so” but he is clearly playing his worst footy since arriving this year and it’s hard to watch. I want him to have a spell in the twos, learn to mark, gain some confidence and come back a better player as right now he looks like a deer in the headlights. I hope nothing more that he proves me wrong but I can’t see him “wowing” me anytime soon and would be surprised if he even holds his spot this week.