Deeko2

I’ve been calling for it but I never take satisfaction in a young kid being dropped. I still think at present we will be better off without him in as he’s having a poor season. I’m intrigued around your comment on if May/Lever were playing that he’d play on the third tall. He very well could but I still think he will always get the main man as a pure stopper with May/Lever floating across for help and a chop out. Those two are better defenders but by far more valuable to intercept and rebound as well. If Oscar plays, I think it will be in a role similar to Astbury/Talia/Frawley who would still take the key forward and focus on nothing more than defence defence defence.

I wasn’t aware of this stat to be honest and was having a read of footywire to get some context. Its a positive he is leading our club but his average per game lists him at 37 on the list and is behind nearly every fullback in the league. This is not only poor as he offers zero offensively but poor because the pill is in our defence more than every other team in the comp. We have been the host heavily scored against team this year by far. I’m just as disgusted in the rest of our defenders who don’t appear higher in this list. They are getting plenty of opportunity. I know he puts his body on the line and will cop one for the team. I don’t doubt this courage at all in that regard. What I meant was courage in the air taking the intercept mark. Hes our key defender playing for the heaviest scored against team and doesn’t appear in the top 100 players of intercepts this year. I want him to back himself, mark the pill or fist it 30 yards from the contest. As for Goodwin picking him, what other choice does he have with the main two on the sidelines? Also, he’s clearly not rated that highly noting that even though we have the poorest kicking team in the comp (my thoughts) and the slowest, we still traded our last three first round draft picks for key defenders.... what does that tell you? I sound like an Oscar hater and I’m really not. I’d love nothing more than him to turn it around this week and you to come back and say “told you so” but he is clearly playing his worst footy since arriving this year and it’s hard to watch. I want him to have a spell in the twos, learn to mark, gain some confidence and come back a better player as right now he looks like a deer in the headlights. I hope nothing more that he proves me wrong but I can’t see him “wowing” me anytime soon and would be surprised if he even holds his spot this week.

I think your clutching at straws a little binman to say his gut running to assist zoning is a reason he played well. If this is all he is offering to the team at the moment plus some token “one per-centres” he’s on thin ice. With the 6v6 he can’t just slide a little spoil down in front of him, he needs to really smoke it ten rows back. I’d love to see him more courageous in the air and throw himself at some contests. I’m not going to get into him about a couple possessions he turned it over as he’s usually fairly safe with the pill once it’s in his hands. Hes not looking confident at the moment but I still think he will be fine within a couple years. Just not right now for me

Was this said by the coaches during the game? Interesting comment if so. If he’s playing a pressure forward role and he laid that many I’d be stoked but if he’s on the wing I’d rather see him racking up bulk linking touches that are effective and no fumbles - or at least getting some touch back. Im honestly not a big fan but hope he gets back to his best as he has battled big time this season

Dylan Grimes what a last quarter! Amazing work. Wasn’t he meant to be the brother who wasn’t as good? He’s played some good footy the last couple years. I was hoping for Port but figure the tigs will definitely play finals footy where we might end up battling with someone like port for a spot in the 8 so the result probably favours us. Tom Lynch is worth every cent as well. What could have been if we had a draft pick one pick earlier.....

Great to see Hunt back playing good footy. I think a lot forget how good he was a couple seasons back before getting ko’d. Loves a chase, tackles hard and can take a decent grab. Great to see him playing well again.

Did he do his job really well? I can’t remember seeing him in the last quarter. I honestly thought he might have been at least injured

Why was Oscar in the track suit? Obviously was poor but I can’t imagine he’d just be dragged but didn’t see him in the second half. Unfortunately for him we were better when he was off....

They both need a spell in the twos. Tmac must be injured as I can’t believe how far he has regressed from last year. Still, he has a bucketload more presence than Oscar. Send him back, he was a solid CHB before the move forward and get rid of little bro. Keilty up forward. ANB is the biggest front runner I’ve seen in my 30 years supporting. The kids scared of his own shadow. I would have kept Bugg, Tyson and Kent over ANB - and probably rather the Pedo Bear in front of Oscar!!