Bay Riffin

one of the best kicks in our side, and better decision makers but agree with the rest.

Do remember this is one of their top 5 players. Probably the equivalent of Harmes in value. Not elite but much valued. What would you accept for Harmes? Imo if we give up just a second rounder for a top 5 player who is only 23 years old, we are laughing.

I like this acquisition. What many supporters don’t mention is were are average in the air. Both marking and punching. He rates elite in marking for his position. And that can only help us.

You’re assuming we didn’t?

Throw everything at Papley? Who’s left ?

Langdon for a second rounder would be one of the better trades im seeing. He is only 23, an absolute line breaker, top 5 in the B and F at Freo and looking at his stats is getting better every year. and instead of Lewis and Jones on the wings, we can play Thomlinson and Langdon there, with Oscar Baker the apprentice in waiting.

still be nice to get someone with skill who can kick and has pace.

Geez we a

Frost handballs are worse than his kicking. He and Hunt are the worst handballers in the league. Just atrocious.

Brisbane have been an under performing mess for years and had one good year. So let the dust settle a bit. They also had the best injury run in the AFL and a great draw. yes they played very well but ultimately they finished lower than us last year.

tomato sauce ?

99% confident ? If he doesn't come to the Dees will you buy everyone on demonland a beer ? just a thought.

at the very least, we will make the pies do something they much prefer not to and extend his contract to 3 years.

Tomlinson is a decent kick

if you know that, then hes definitely not doing his job.

I think its a compelling argument.

I honestly believe this as well. he is so far off the pace at times its mind boggling he gets a game.

if they take Oscar they can have Frost. NFI if they rate Oscar over Frost.

Reiwoldt was too good for us so not sure. which match ? Franklin was not beaten by Frost. agree Oscar is just not AFL standard.

this gives me the same feeling as Martin to Brisbane. He gave a point of difference, great athlete who was not great with ball in hand but was getting better. Back then I hoped we got a second rounder, then gave him off voluntarily for a pack of twisties. big mistake. at least play hard ball. we played a second rounder when he was untried, now hes worth a second rounder which is speculative anyway. otherwise no deal.

Unbelievable really. They had a good hit at the super draft and now this. Top 2 seem clearly the best. Victorian players. Can you believe it?

I think if we get Thomlinson and Langdon we will have done well given were bottom 4. they are role players but definitely give us much need pace. and for goodness sake recruit some pace and class in the draft.

then not so cranky when he came for just pick 6, they owe us big time.

interesting how things could turn if we recruit a few players and our regulars can stay on the park. that's a forward line to work with.

he gives us a point of difference. I think he could become a good back packet in a lock down role on the most athletic dangerous forward. if he learns to kick, which is still terrible. Maybe 'frost ball' is a function of bad coaching and Clarko can teach that out of him. a lot of it is just calming down a bit.