dazzledavey36

Jack has a poor record of judging when fit to play. By his own admission he returned early from his foot injury in 2017 and has had long periods on the sidelines and/or managed game time since. His game time was managed in games early in the season. Ditto vs Hawks - he played about 2 of the first 3 qtrs (prior to the shoulder injury). This suggests something other than the shoulder injury is causing the managed game times. Have someone else make the decision! Jsck isn't the sharpest tool in the shed. So yes, i agree wholeheartedly with you that someone else needs to make the decision, not Jack.

He has every right to be angered.. https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/teams/melbourne/shaun-smith-father-for-demon-joel-smith-takes-aim-at-melbournes-fitness-department-on-facebook/news-story/ba5bbf8adcfb07f2420cc1b3af91a7f2

Then had the nerve to fire back at Olive after he called him out on his weak effort on just letting the ball over the line. I bagged ANB for his fumbles but this bloke is borderline horrendous with his inability to keep his feet and fumbling at crucial stages of the game.

Yeah i actually didn't even think of that..

Disappointing either way.

Great article on both. https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/melbourne-matureage-recruits-marty-hore-and-jay-lockhart-are-making-a-difference/news-story/530af5c695bbc61266eb83a96efa22f4

You do realise that page is just a troll?

Agree, Anyone who thinks otherwise are kidding themselves. They are a big club and will continue to attract high quality players along the way.

Is this actually legit? If so weak as [censored] by the little grub.

Been saying it all along. Tom Morris is a [censored] little grub! Club needs to call him out big time. What i see there is two blokes who have copped a bit of [censored] over yhis year and its almodt like they're saying "we got each other's back"... Well done McCartney and well done Goodwin.

I have read a lot of social media comments in regards to this Hawthorn bloke. Apparently he gets quiet abusive at the footy and causes a lot of trouble against opposition supporters. I read there was an incident where he fully abused a woman saints supporter and her little daughter at the footy and other supporters had to step in and so did the police. Obviously has form..... Mr Ploegmakers, who has an intellectual disability, admits he threw beer on the Dees supporter but says the man had insulted him.

Haha of course you were..........

Lewis. Leave Stretch and Garlett in, they played their role well against the hawks.

How is Gunstan any quicker then Hore? If anything Gunstan doesnt exactly break out into strides, more so its his work rate that gets him moving in and around ground. And i would back Lever to do the job on him down back. Lever is also known as an attacking defender when he was at adelaide, highlighted by his 30 disposal 13 marks against St Kilda in round 11 2016 and also his 29 disposals 11 marks in round 10 2017. Hes many of these games where plays a genuine attacking game style. Marty Hore will only get better, he'll have a full year of AFL under his belt this year and will gel well once May and Lever are bsck full time.

Andre Gianfagna should never umpire again.

Thats what Pre seasons are for.. to get fit. He will be fine. He is a fine intercept mark who has plenty of upside. He doesn't have to be fast. Tom Stewart from Geelong is the same height and plays the same role, but he is not quick either.

Casey Demons Goal Kickers:S. Weideman 2, O. Baker 2, K. Chandler, J. Munro, M. White, A. Quigley Best Players:C. Wagner, T. Sparrow, H. Petty, T. Freeman, O. Baker, A. Quigley Footscray Goal Kickers:T. Boyd 3, R. Gardner 2, B. Cavarra 2, L. Nash, R. West, P. Lipinski, S. Barnett Best Players:B. Williams, L. Young, R. West, R. Smith, A. Scott, T. Boyd

How do you find Tom Freeman @KC from Casey? Already taken 6 marks in the 1st half. Could he be a draft smokey come years end?

Ok maybe that is a bit harsh but he is a very ordinary AFL player. He is up there with the likes of Zac Dawson, Josh Bootsma as one of the worst footballers i have ever seen.

Is Oscar's? Bloke looks like the same now as what he did in his first year.

Petty should be playing AFL footy instead of Oscar. I have seen enough of Oscar and im sorry but he is a spud. Get games into him and start developing him while May and Lever are out.

Forward

Just watched the reply. Jesus christ he was horrible. I'm sorry but Goodwin needs to swallow his pride and drop him and actually be made to earn a game. Such a bad look when a suppose leader is making horrible mistakes and then turning it back on blokes like Oliver who had the ball to call him out on it. Leadership my [censored].

There are times where i simply turn off the Melbourne Podcast because of him as co host (good lord...). Struggles to put a sentence together and is very uninspiring. Jake Lever is light years ahead and if he gets some good solid consistency in his football i would love to see him captain one day instrad of Viney.

Speaks like a true born leader. He is light years ahead of Jack Viney who is simply cringeworthy to the max.