dazzledavey36

This is a great deal for us. Well Done Mahoney and co.

What a pathetic and uneducated post. Give yourself a right hook to the face and walk yourself out.

Is Caldwell name actually been mentioned by anyone from the media? Or are we just pipe dreaming. Caldwell would be a fantastic get. Huge talent who the Giants rated on par with Dylan Shiel on talent alone.

I wpuld not be surprise that we get towards the end of the trade period and throw a late pick towards Jenkins. I think we are trying every alternative (Josh Bruce) and eventually if don't land who we want we'll go for Jenkins last minute.

The Shaun Smith reminds me of the movie Concussion starred by Will Smith. If anyone has seen it you would know it's a brilliant but yet scary reality about the after effects of concussion in the NFL. It seems like it's having an effect on former players like Greg Williams, John Barnes and Shaun Smith.

So apparently it was mentioned on SEN this afternoon and then later on channel 7 that we are making a late play for Bruce? Did anyone catch this??

How was your holiday?

Rumour is false..

Yeah those 11 disposals 4 tackles and 2 goals were definitely looked at seriously as a potential Norm Smith winner ?‍♂️ Fmd some people are really simple.

It's Josh Bruce? Was apparently reported on sen that we've made a late play.

Does not fit our needs or lineup at all. I would be extremely disappointed if we are chasing him.

I have easily warmed up to him as well mate and really think he add mores to pur side then Serong or Flanders. I don't think you can't go wrong with Young or Stephens at pick 3 but i feel like Stephens edges Young due to his breakaway speed.

In my opinion he is the absolute prototype winger that we've been crying out for years. I have always said that I think Young or Serong will be spoken about around the mark, but do we go with the Smokey as Stephens for pick 3? I definitely would not hesitate at all personally.

Townsend is a scrubber. No thanks.

Not live mate but this might help..

If we do split our pick into the teens then maybe I could see a potential bid from us perhaps. Depends if we are that interested. Heard Graham Wright I think last week who spoke about Finn and he had huge wraps on him. Hawks rate him highly and would have got excited when they saw his last Finals game. Absolutely dominated! Cannot see us bidding on him with pick 3 though.

You want players who actually add tackling pressure and intensity. This bloke is the complete opposite and one of the worst going around in terms of defensive pressure. Next

Don't rate him or his leadership skills. Would rather trade.

No

Yep I agree, could see him playing across a wing half back as he provides run and carry

I am backing the club to bounce back next year.

So we were told that all vacant have been filled, yet now report has come out that we are still in the hunt for another coach? Something not adding up....

Spoke extremely well on both trade radio and SEN. We've got yourself a fantastic individual who will add a lot not only on field but more importantly off field.

Beat me to it. It certainly pricked my ears to the family t that they'd still look at other options of need be.