dazzledavey36

*Wrong Thread

Fair point Rusty. I know I did mention a potential trade but I take that comment back. Need him at least to have an extra big body there to help Weid and let Jackson develop in his own right.

Death, taxes and a random thread brought up from by the great @Elegt

I think we need to look to trade. He's about to turn 28 and I cannot see him ever improving again. Would be happy with a 3rd rounder .

Oh like Mark Neeld use to do right?

Played his best footy in the 2nd half of 2018 when Viney wasn't there. So yes I'd take Viney out who imo upsets our midfield mix. The fact Goodwin has even caught onto this shows why he hasn't improved as a coach. Its also being smart in using your midfield mix. Its no coincidence that we got our run on back in the back half of 2018 due to the tagging efforts of Harmes. Not only was he shutting down some of the best names in the league, he was going out and getting the pill himself. We've taken the biggest strength we had in our side and turned into [censored].

Its still a massive need. Vanders was exposed badly today by Hunter. He was not by himself. We have so many one paced plodders like Vanders, Jones, Sparrow, Tomlinson who we are having to run through the wings because we have nothing else on offer. When you're playing those guys on the outside, good teams expose you. Where is Oska Baker at? I really like his work last year, and much rather him or Hunt on a wing then a Vanders/Jones.

This will be up there as one of the strangest and bizarre coaching moves in my time supporting this club. A genuine gun midfielder when on song, and is yet being wasted away in another position where he's barely fired a shot for majority of the year.

I named 3 forwars who were simply poor. Yes Hannan and Spargo were not much better. It's highly disappointing how easy their backs were able to waltze out of their backing with zero pressure. Our mids don't get a free ride either. Not only did they fail to apply any pressure, but failed once again to capitalise on ruckman dominance. How is this not been rectified after so many weeks?? Brayshaw was poor, Viney is all about himself, bloke thinks he Jona Lomu half the time. Oliver too was poor and Petracca butchered at times. Lever, May and Tomlinson to a degree were our best.

Signed a 5 year deal last year didn't he? That's a heft contract to break.

Really don't know what to do with McDonald. Really thought last year was once off due to team performance. But this year he just hasn't been able to back it up. Do we move him down back??

The best tagger in our side is currently spudding it up down back.. Coaching masterclass by Goodwin.

Geez Bailey Smith for them is going to be a Star. Love the way he goes about it.

Utter disgraceful. Melksham, Harmes, McDonald, Hibbo, Fritsch, All disgraced the jumper. Goodwin shown up for a poor coach he is. Plan B? Where was that Goody? [censored] clueless as usual.

Time to retire Hibbo. You're done

Brayshaw back to being a [censored] spud again

Nope.. Melksham is another fraud like Goodwin.

Hibberd getting taught an absolute lesson. Time to blood Rivers. He's the future.

Outside run killing us.. Fancy that huh..

Reminds me of the Collingwood game of 2017. When stakes are high and the opportunity is right in front of us to grab, we simply fail.

He's a fraud. Playing on an absolute spud in Gardiner sand hes getting he's [censored] handed to him.

we are [censored] LAZY

Only shows up around Junk time. He's a liability

Goodwin is [censored] clueless

Lol Crozier started that play from the back pocket and now taking shot. Our forwards are [censored] Lazy!! Oh Melksham GAGF!!!