sisso

If Dunny plays whoever is on him needs to run him all over the field, unless looks are deceiving in his current condition it looks like he'd blow up in 10 mins

He's going to be underdone even if he does get up

Certainly no point risking Max if he's sore, with the state Collingwood are in he shouldn't be the difference between winning or losing if he isnt right to go

I think its a touch too early to plan for life after Max yet - ruckmen often are still playing their best footy in their early 30s and at 28 he has many good years left in him...Id say 5 more seasons after this one at least, and by that stage Jackson will have done his 80+ game apprenticeship

Don't remember Robbie I was too young when he was in his prime...the Ox was the next that springs to mind before his knees gave way. Trac is ridiculous some of the things he can do on a football field, he appears untouchable: his next challenge is to do it against the best teams and not simply beat up on the strugglers.

In my 40 years supporting our beloved club....he could well be the best player we've had

Agree: we’ve spent years putting together a such a talented midfield now isn’t the time to start breaking it apart

I like that idea...and save Jack’s body a bit for finals when you need his battering ram attack on the ball in the guts

We ran into the two worst teams in the comp at the perfect time....smacked them off the park and hopefully that gives the boys confidence to go on with this season. Agree that Gus always plays way better when Jack is out, not sure what to do about the balance of our midfield when both are fit

We look the better side with our ball movement but we are making bloody hard work of it

Worst umpired quarter I’ve ever seen

We might as well pack 2020 up if we can't beat North they are pretty awful...a dirty scrappy game shouldn't worry us, we have the players built for that. Its the quick, skilful sides that cut us apart.

Enjoyable last quarter but Adelaide are at their lowest ebb. A young side that completely ran out of gas, however was good to see guys like Brayshaw find a bit of form.

Perhaps we’re just rubbish

We are struggling against a sanfl side

FFS

This could be our all time greatest choke

I wouldn’t do it unless we got a great deal: he’s still a good player if we had a decent system for him to play in I’m sure he’d do well. Goodwin/Richardson appear able to turn any good footballer into a potato...

FFS

For what’s supposed to be our greatest strength this happens way too often

I agree the sardine can grounds really suit our crash and bash style, it's at the MCG where we have struggled with teams playing keepings off. You'd think we'd have the edge in contested ball over Hawthorn, even though every time I think that our midfield fails to turn up...

Embarrassing....Richmond ended up with half a side and we still cant do anything

Have we sacked Goodwin yet? Horrific team to watch whatever we had in 2018 is long gone and we are getting worse under him

We've been unwatchable for too long now, something has to change

After least after last week we should be fresh to run it out hard in the second half