joeboy

So if Dangerfield is innocent, shouldn’t Walsh be cited for ‘acting’ ?

I see a very similar comparison physically and attitudinally to another indigenous player who was well loved by all Dees’ supporters, and who ironically also wore #45, Mathew Whelan . i hope Andy’s career is as impressive as Matty’s

Just an aside: there’s a video going around of Max riding a bike with his young child, who’s actually singing the Carlton theme song😳

I’m not sure I follow your logic. On the one hand you say his development SHOULDN’T get set back if he’s beaten , however you then offer the point that he’ll be better by next year if it DOES happen 😱

The ONLY reason not to play Jefferson this week is because he’ll be demolished by Andrews and set back 6 months in his development

Steven should be rewarded for his quick thinking under pressure

Not to mention the 80 metre penalty ((instead of 50) dished out against Windsor who’d been sucked in by a feigned play on, even though that rule had been removed.

Gawn - played with passion Viney - certainly stepped up Rivers - promising in middle Neal-Bullen - successful tagging game May - owned his opponent Sparrow - just a game Tholstrup - exciting in bursts Langdon - some critical touches McDonald - wasted in defense Chandler - needs a demotion Tomlinson - was generally effective Salem - slow and underwhelming Pickett - exciting when involved Petty - had some moments vanRooyen - was never involved McVee - classy and composed Windsor - some uncharacteristic errors Howes - little to commend Turner - no second efforts Bowey - needs to lift Oliver - distracted and wasteful Fritsch - a lazy liability Brown - game saving tackle

BB actually played very well for Casey last week when put in the ruck… he seemed to be playing less encumbered than he’s been recently. I don’t expect he’ll be attending any centre circle ball ups but I DO think he’s a certainty to come back into the seniors against North

History tells us that pinning our hopes too soon on a forward prodigy is doomed to fail. Jack Watts says hello

I believe Darling was overlooked because of other issues to do with members of the opposite sex

I suspect that ‘banning’ the process of knees into the back will eliminate the whole concept of taking a hanger There’s only a handful of players who have the dexterity to leap above their opponent’s shoulders without including the back for liftoff

Thankfully we’ve got the quality and depth at Casey to replace him… oh wait🤦‍♂️

I’ve seen the ending

Gawn - performed as expected Rivers - lost his dash Salem - poor under pressure vanRooyen - showed some energy Pickett - didn’t convert chances Windsor - couldn’t get involved Viney - off the pace Oliver - disposals were amateurish Fritsch - poor first half May - great after first Neal-Bullen - a disciplined performance Petracca - there goes season Sparrow - continued poor season Laurie - a schoolboy footballer Bowey - had little influence Turner - a year away Howes - two years away McDonald - impressive under pressure McVee - was rarely noticed Langdon - career worst game Billings - nothing to commend Chandler - was he playing? Petty - offered team nothing

Gawn -overwhelmed and outplayed May - slow and frustrating Petty - embarrassing and inept Rivers - career worst performance Viney - disposals occasionally amateurish Sparrow - provided virtually nothing Chandler - lost all confidence Salem - loose and slow Hunter - useless before injury Fritsch - invisible until last Windsor - tired , seemingly disinterested Petracca - tried without influencing Neal-Bullen - couldn’t get started Tomlinson - seemed to care McAdam - not on field Pickett - played with passion McDonald - little to enthuse Langdon - tried but ineffective Bowey - loose but tried Turner - reserve grade quality McVee - career worst game Woewodin - made little difference Oliver - cared but limited

Gawn - Brownlow votes again Viney - more energy displayed Bowey - resilient and impressive Rivers - great first half Neal-Bullen - played with passion May - loved his energy Salem - back in form Tomlinson - career best game Windsor - had limited involvement Oliver - performance gradually improved Petracca - class when required Pickett - brilliant in bursts McAdam - far from ready Petty -out for Jefferson Chandler - little to enthuse Fritsch - only cameos again Woewodin - a smooth mover vanRooyen - important but limited Sparrow - is looking tired Hunter - disposal was average Langdon - impressive first half McVee - reliable and skillful McDonald - was virtually impassable

Upon retirement, it’ll be Max

2 month old golden retriever

Maxi

I was of the same mindset in my teenage years and the regret was profound after attempting to take a Russell Robertson type ‘hanger’ , losing balance , then landing on the steel fence, mouth first😱 6 months of dental therapy later, I was fortunately able to retain my bottom front teeth , 3 of which had been indented 45 degrees upon impact🤦‍♂️

Gawn - played with heart Viney - without impact again Salem - some contested wins McDonald- tried but lacking McVee - given ridiculous tasks May - lost without mate Sparrow - little to commend Brown - embarrassing and unfit Fritsch - played in spurts Pickett - only dangerous forward McAdam - will be valuable Billings - Saints are laughing Oliver - poor decision making Petracca - couldn’t influence game Woewodin - not the worst Neil-Bullen - good in close Petty - unfit and limited Howes - little to commend Windsor - needs a rest Chandler - had no influence Bowey - just a game Rivers - loose and tired Lever - was desperately missed Fox footy coverage -commentary from hell

Petracca - left nothing behind Neal-Bullen - in and under Gawn - fought the fight Viney - not a tagger Oliver - regularly butchered possessions Sparrow - energy and endeavour Windsor - persisted and energetic Billings - some innocuous possessions May - reliable and impressive Chandler - little forward pressure Rivers - important all game Langdon - rarely broke lines Bowey - an impressive return Lever - had no influence McDonald - some crucial errors van Rooyen - little to commend Howes - was rarely noticed McVee - a quiet game Pickett - a disappointing performance Fritsch - was well held Petty - riches to rags Woewodin - had some moments Turner - another nothing game

Yes Robbie WAS taller but the comparisons were more to do with balance, agility, and timing.