Demons11

This won't happen. If they don't trade he will go into the national draft and not hold off to the PSD. If this occurs they won't use pick 1 on him in the national draft.

What do they need to give up for him?

Grimes is slow and turns it over, that's why he has fallen out of favour. He plays a half back role and is not in front of Hunt, Salem, Jetta, Vince, Melksham and Hibbo if he come in. They also have Wagner and White waiting in the wings

He already played his 100th game

Trenners deserves another chance but unfortunately I can't see a spot for Grimes.

?

This is a Joke!!!

Great man!!!' I look forward to seeing him at the G celebrating with the players when we win a flag.

Not sure

Are you some of you kidding yourselves!!!! He is our best key forward and will be our best player within 2 years. He will be a top 5 goal kicker in the comp for the next 10 years and is they key to our future success. Supporters or trolls who think we would be better off without him, have no idea. Key forwards who have done what he has done in his first 2 years are once in a lifetime players and sadly players we have not seen much of at the Dees in the last 10 years. He has some things to work on but what 2nd year player doesn't? His signature is essential.

I think the Lumumba, Varcoe and Clark trade has actually came out pretty fair. They are all battlers. I agree on the Dawes one.

What recent experience??? Melksham was about right. It was never going to be a 3rd rounder.

There is no chance in the world it will be next years 1st rd pick.

Weed stays for mine. No forward was going to play well yesterday with how the ball was being delivered. Michie (out and unfortunately delisted) ANB ( not up to it this year, 2nd year blues I guess. I think he will be a good role player in the future) Vanders (out and has had a dissapointing year but seems to have been injury interrupted) INS - Harmes, Salem and Trenners

We have beat teams above us, around us and below us. Yes we should have won today but there is always games that you should win that you don't and there are also games that you not expected to win and you do. We have been outsiders in a lot of games this year. The team is developing and a very different prospect to Richmond who don't have the talent coming through that we do. Im not saying I enjoyed today and I agree in the 1st qtr they were crap but after qtr time they still continued to fight which is not the old Melbourne we know. Hogan missed some easy ones today but so did Vince, Jones, Petracca, Gawn, Vanders and im sure a few others. Hogans hands were very good but he does need to improve his kicking. I was having a go because the bloke said they were arrogant which is a load of sh*t.

What a load of bullsh*t. They have been favs against Brisbane, Richmond, Collingwood, GC x 2 and won all those games. Disappointing day I agree but they continued to crack in but nothing came off for them. 10 Wins is a good result this year and we will be finalist next year.

Sick of the fact he kicked a goal and has taken 4 contested marks in a half. Yeah let's get rid of him

So were you saying the same thing against Hawthorn????

Worst comment I have seen

You are not going to get him for nothing

Has to be our 2nd rd pick

Based on tomorrow's team he would be in front of Viv and ANB

Welcome to the Dees Hibbo

Hogan even with his slight slump averages more goals and marks than Watts. He also gets the best defender and his double teamed every week. Hogan has Watts covered.

Who is our best forward?