JackVineyForPresident

I was hoping someone would make a threat addressing this absolute [censored]. This can be the official thread for this guy. I can't express my hatred for this guy

Out: Viney (Sadly), Byrnes and Frawley if injured In: Riley (in and under, might be a semi-adequate replacement for Viney, will be keen to see him in action), Gawn and Garland If Frawley isnt out, i'd probably just bring Garland in instead of Gawn

Both deserved the nomination for brilliant efforts on the weekend. Well done Tommy, JKH's time will come

Besides the point, isnt it amazing how he bounced back up and got the ball?

I want to hear the demon army roar when we tear the doggies a new one. Bring on 50,000 demons on sat night

I think he'll get weeks, it hurts to say it. Despite the fact i thought he turned onto his side to brace himself for contact, i think that you just cant do it.

Am i an idiot for making comparisons to O'meara and Prestia.. i seriously see this kid at his level. HIs numbers would suggest he's basically at that level, maybe Prestia abit better at this stage, not O'meara.

His kicking will surely improve, one can only hope. But i see him as a mixture of Watson and Pendlebury. He creates time with the ball, which is vindictive of the way Pendles plays. As for the times when he gets caught holding the ball, it's usually because there's no one infront of him and therefore he tries to hold it up, but gets caught

Your profile picture makes me happy Salem and Viney <3

I would still include Trengove in our best 22/25. Pederson also deserves to be in our best 22/25. Since the Stkilda game he has been very solid and the last 2 weeks one of our best

Viv Michie and Aiden Riley might also join the midfield at some point. Both look promising

He was rubbish today again. I hope he gets the same treatment as Watts, because Nicnat has been pathetic

Is it possible that they were going side to side for the same reasons we did in the first few rounds. No confident targets to kick to up the ground? Melbourne get Dawes back and poof, no more side to side all day long

I love the idea of this thread. Itll be very interesting to see our 2015 finals team- best 25.. Could be some very interesting names in there, im hoping a power forward is there, or midfielder

All of the bests were MFC listed players.. clearly our boys arent the issue

based on preference, I would keep him. But i would not keep him if it came as an underwhelming price. If it was a choice between Frawley and a GWS power forward, ill take the power forward. If we could do a swap for Patton, i'd do it

What about the forward line? But i agree

Averaging 23.1 disposals and 5.9 marks ... absolutely mad pickup

i think he has been poor the last 2 weeks. Very well held also. I reckon we should send him back, if not injured.

I am pretty sure that at the beginning of the year, Frawley would decide hell be a demon if he saw that the club is heading in the right direction. If we can secure a few more wins for the year, does this mean he will most likely re-sign? This was my interpretation, or do we have a Scully x2?

he had one particular shank where he took a mark in the middle of the ground yesterday that frustrated me. Something shocking. Redeemed himself with his goal in congestion

Forget Salem and Kelly for a second. This kid has all the makings of a star

Do we think his back is ok?

It will be a looked at, Viney should be safe. Vince also should be safe for his bump throughout the game

This was ultimately worse than the Carlton v West Coast game. That is an achievement from the maggots