JackVineyForPresident

I see the humour in this. It's pretty funny. Some people on here just want serious threads, which is okay... But he's been gone over a year now, lets put it behind us. Colin Sylvia jokes are appreciated though

The only way we can do this is to play with hear, ferocious attack on the ball and fierce tackling

You definitely knew what i meant when i was talking about talent.. I think we should try and develop our midfielders as they are incredibly promising and very young.. whereas we desperately need a KPP or two. Wouldnt mind getting a star midfielder though

I would love him and he' worth the money. But i that a culture you want to build? i say no

All the ones in the blue are very talented players who have the ability to be really good. Whether they get there is another issue, i'm not sure we need anymore 'talent'.. we really need a developed Shiel or Trealor

Absolutely. Does anyone despise Ablett for taking the money and the challenge? no, because he didnt go about it in a manner that deceives everybody around him

Whilst you're correct, we have an abundance of talent yet to truly shine through. Trealor would be the necessary midfielder needed to complete our midfield on paper. (obviously performance is another issue). But talent is definitely there Kent, Toumpas, Watts, Viney, Tyson, Jones, Vince, Michie, Salem, Grimes, Trengove, JKH, maybe Riley and Howe. The talents there, we need a big gun

Why?

I wouldnt give up that much for Tomlinson. maybe pick 6 and 3rd rounder for Tomlinson and pick 20

He is an absolute brute with no delivery. The GWS boys dont kick it to his advantage so he cannot outmuscle his opponent. If we have any opportunity i'd love him

I do not want to throw everything at O'Rourke. I'd throw abit, he hasnt proved anything

I'll admit he does look pretty solid.. but something about young skinny players doesnt excite me.

However, i'd love that Adam Trealor kid.. Imagine.... Viney, Trealor and Tyson..

Why do we want O'Rourke? he doesnt find the footy enough. I would rather take someone from the draft who can find the pill. I really believe that there are other midfielders on the GWS list who we could look at infront of him. As for Plowman, i'd love him

I do not want Hoskin-Elliot, reminds me of Cale Morton. Skinny and tall.. eww

If Scully wasnt on one million per year he wouldnt even make their team

and suddenly Kelly isnt playing too well. Good one Barret and Voss

Lol. Love Dawesy

I would very much like Shiel, watching the kid today highlights how good he can be, in such a [censored] team. Also Trealor and Coniglio, both are absolute jets. Do we throw the kitchen sinks at them or someone like Patton?

The case is the same, but Dom has always been a ball winner, especially in junior levels. whereas O'Rourke is not a prolific ball winner. I would love to have O'Rourke but wouldnt pay such a price for him

I want another midfielder.. But i seriously would rather a forward first

No he hasnt. But the more i see of him, the less im enticed.. He's not a good ball winner

Another good reason is the brand of footy we are beginning to play. Who wouldnt want to come to a club that prides itself on relentless pressure

I'd be really upset if Sylvia came back. He left us for a "better" option. Dont complain when it backfires

My team for Port B: Jetta Mcdonald Garland HB: Howe Dunn Grimes C: Vince Viney Cross HF: Watts Gawn JKH F: Pederson Frawley Bail Foll: Jamar, N Jones, Tyson INT: Matt Jones, Riley, Terlich Sub: Salem