Demonsone

Hawthorn to send its own 2017 second-round pick to Gold Coast, along with pick No.10 for Jaeger O'Meara. Scully was pick 53

Hogan didn't want to stay & wanted the trade done...dont disagree not looking great now but if a player wants to leave...

Its a lottery @ times....hawks gave up a bit & are taking risks with Omera & Scully & who both come to the club with severe injuries.

Tragic History of disaster continues at the MFC!

My apologies correct 17

Agree with Roos, were has working both ways gone??? Hogan wanted to go back home so not a club decision. Watts he continues to frustrate Port in the same ways & turning up underdone.

Were is David Mission in all this as it appears we have major fitness issues.....

Hogan wanted to go back so his decision Watts well enough said he's struggling at Port Howe been gone now 3 years Kent I agree

They were ok last year in finals bar one game

History repeating itself, saw it with the Daniher sides.

Dermott Brereton says Melbourne is a ‘team of downhill skiers’ Here is the answer Goody!

55 years going strong & MFC continues to find a way to self destruct!

Writing on the wall, after 22 surgeries & interrupted pre season, ask any fitness guru that unless u have a proper preseason you are [censored] for the season! Coach needs to answer as to whats happened to our defence foundations that Roos put in place, even last year we were getting scored against heavily Why did we get rid of Kent, not that he was the difference but we are lacking goal kickers.

Stole my thunder....Neeld Years & unfortunately Goody will be the same by 2020

Kiss Finals Good Bye! & 2019! From Prelim to fizzling out just to live up to the busted [censored] failure of the MFC of the last 55 years! Goodwin needs to answer some tough questions of his game plan as we get scored so easily against!

Nothing new from this club who find a way to disappoint, will call it want play finals on this form!

Finally pulled out Roos plan to work both ways!

Every team has a player who comes last in a time trial.... the question what were his times vs the others & afl benchmark? not denying his fitness was not up to scratch but would be good to all the facts

You are correct factually ....my point is many clubs role the dice, with the Hawks both those players have serious injuries which may impact their playing futures. Fact is May admitted himself he was behind the 8 ball, come last in time trials,

Simple Roos implemented defending & working both ways...Goodwin is attack & down hill skiers

Hawks have rolled the dice with Scully & Omera...only difference they gave late picks.....Whats concerning is Lever is bad luck buy May coming into a new club & presenting himself in poor shape says a lot about him, not sure how recruiters can miss that

Not to mention JLT games got scored very easily..

Great Defensive Goody 18 goals in Prelim 20 goals vs Cats 20 goals vs Ess

Real Concerns... Roos defensive foundations of working both ways gone 6,6,6 exposed us badly Losing a Key forward Hogan though didn't want to stay & has own issues got in May who has come in under done & overweight questions what type of player is he Viney & Jones look like they are still in preseason History repeating itself of the last 55yrs of the MFC, tease your supporters into a false sense of success only to come crashing down

Means nothing when 40 goals are scored against you in 2 weeks