Leoncelli_36

I don't want any of those you mentioned and none of Terlich, Riley or Bail. I would have been happy to axe the lot. I would also trade Watts, let Frawley go. Offer up Grimes.

So the unconditionals are conditional now? As long as you are giving your all you are ok to have [censored] skills. I don't get the message here

Like others said, what doesn't make sense is that Roos said that basic skills were fundamental to remaining on the list and then goes and gives deals to two guys that have been worst offenders are screwing kicks, getting caught and butchering the ball. FFS

If u stalk his Instagram and look at his girlfriends you will see that she is at uni in Melbourne away from Mitch ATM. Also that her bridal plans are all being done from a place in Elwood, what does that all mean? Probably nothing, but interesting to note that his partner has stayed here for uni and mskybe he plans to return once he is well. Grasping at straws really, but just hoping there is a chance he returns. I think he had taken up some photography opportunities in Melbourne also

Your bother sounds like a typical North [censored] trying to pot our supporters. If I am not mistaken our players were booed off. Hardly applauded, we may have been guilty of being content with mediocrity in the past but I think fans are disgruntled and disgusted by the skills displayed by our players

Yep. They have more passion as a group and would be harder at the contest

I am telling you the three best non AFL listed VfL players are better than those three. Port Melbourne would beat our team ATM. They have a better list tan our bottom 15 of 22. Our basic skill execution is that bad

Rohan bail is a turnover king! Has the poorest foot skills, so what IMF he gets the ball, it constantly results in a turnover. Looks like the massive clean out we were all banking on wont come to fruition and we will persist with the same group of duds!

I like Wagner and the Jackal. Another thing I was thinking bout the other day, we the success of Hanley at Brissy, should the mfc look at another tilt at the Irish Experiment? Roos seems a fan of it. Reckon we should look at it again. Be a nicevtributevto Jimmy too, could set up a scholarship type scenario

I agree Chook, even if we take him pre season draft or late pick or trade for him, I reckon his leadership and experience would be a serious asset to us.

Same age as Judd and Hodge, interesting that everyone thought Judd's body was cooked a month ago too

Reports coming out of Collingwood that Bally is being pushed out of the Pies but has said he wants to play on. I know when he left the Saints there was some talk about him coming to Melbourne as we controlled the picks in the draft. Anyway, wondering whether he could be a target for us at seasons end. He is a brilliant leader with a very strong work ethic. Premiership player, captain - I reckon he fits the bill. Interested in the thoughts of others

Guys like Mckenzie Blease Evans Nicho Strauss may not have played yesterday but clearing those guys out and bringing in some actual talent may squeeze out a few blokes who played yesterday or at least create competition for spots. Something has got to give and as far as I am concerned a mass clean out is called for

I am still seething after what can only be described as a deplorable effort yesterday. Like a few others on here, I seriously think that a majority of this current list need to be turned over. The untouchables for me are Nathan Jones, Vince, Tyson, Michie, Gawn, Hogan, Dawes, Jetta, Dunn, Viney, Salem, Cross and Howe. in all honesty, the rest can be shown the door, I would rather go to the WAFL, VFL and SANFL and get ten blokes on the cusp of AFL that really want an opportunity to play for the MFC and would show desire and hunger for the contest, right now wee have a bunch of blokes just happy to be calling themselves AFL footballers. I would look at guys being pushed into retirement at other clubs and offer one year contracts. Just to add leadership and a fresh attitude. Tom McDonald, as much as he does right, is an out an out liability. He constantly f...s up. never learn from his mistakes, why he thinks he can take guys on every time is beyond me. jack grimes is useless, horrid foot skills and general decision making ability. Trengove is slow. Toumpas weak. Garland gone backward and was only am honest trier anyway. Frawley has already left. Matt Jones is useless. Riley notice better. Bail blease tappscott Strauss are all gone without question. Add Evans and nicho to that group. Guys that I would have question marks over; Pedo (thought he had beengoodbthis year) and Jamar. In all honesty would anyone have a problem with axing twelve guys and looking to bring in a complete new list. Roos has a history with taking fringe talent and making them believe, this group has lost belief, it will take a radical decision to redirect this ship

I feel that we must find a genuine crumber in the forward line. Our talls need support. We gave up so many rebounds out of our own fifty last week. Also, who gets Crameri? He flogged us last time.

Posted on Instagram as well. Declared this is his last weekend in Melbourne before heading home to Perth. You can rule out ever seeing him in red and blue again I think. Expect the Dockers to make a play for him next season.

Hi Giles, Not sure were you leave but there is a footy memorabilia shop on Smith Street Collingwood that sells old woollen style replica guernseys. If you can get there its worth it. I think they are about 40 dollars at most. I have several. here is a link - http://www.memorabiliaonsmith.com.au/ suggest you call and see what they have mate

One simple change "It's Melbourne's Grand Old Flag, Its the towns high flying flag, it's the emblem for you and for me. The emblem of, the team we love, the team of the red and the blue....."

hence my initial point. we need to stand up on this issue

Amazing that Collingwood have been allowed to wear their predominantly black jumper against Carlton tonight. AfL have.rules for some

Thanks everyone..got the smart player to work. Annoying size like people said but still enjoyed it. Yesterday was a great day.

Cheers Pennant..i did go to the AFL site but it said i needed a pass

Anyone know where i would be able to download the replay online? Unfortunately still waiting for foxtel to connect me..taken 4 weeks...would love to watch it again. Cheers

Can anyone compile a list of teams we generally wear white against?

Yeah..they should be wearing yellow