Garland

[youami 54]

I really like this bloke, he impressed me a lot last year at sandy playing across half back. If he hardens up and builds up his body he is very much in the Jared Rivers mould. I prefer him as a backman but can play forward, im not sure that he believes in himself yet, he played really well in two pre season games and his body language was almost of embarrassment.

Only when he strings a few games together and is shown faith by our coaching staff will he thrive. He hasnt yet got the body for key position but he reads the play so well that he would be well served as a backman that zones off and gets to the marking contest, rivers style to make the spoil. I cant believe Franklin was constantly left one out last weekend.

Im a big wrap for Garland and I certainly prefer him to others. Give him a go. The same goes for Newton.

[Jarka 767]

I really like this bloke, he impressed me a lot last year at sandy playing across half back. If he hardens up and builds up his body he is very much in the Jared Rivers mould. I prefer him as a backman but can play forward, im not sure that he believes in himself yet, he played really well in two pre season games and his body language was almost of embarrassment.

Only when he strings a few games together and is shown faith by our coaching staff will he thrive. He hasnt yet got the body for key position but he reads the play so well that he would be well served as a backman that zones off and gets to the marking contest, rivers style to make the spoil. I cant believe Franklin was constantly left one out last weekend.

Im a big wrap for Garland and I certainly prefer him to others. Give him a go. The same goes for Newton.

We don't really have a choice but to give these guys a decent shot because the majority of the senior list are not up to it.

[Gorgoroth 12,910]

I think he looked well out of his league for most of last week, but I for one have not given up on him, but maybe a few more weeks at sandy is required.

[Dee man 303]

He played a fantastic tackle in about the first minute of the game last week but went pretty quite after that. Would like to see him persisted with, but can't help but wonder whether the team would be better off with having Holland as a key defender while Garland develops and matures in the VFL.

[Keepin up with the Joneses 48]

I really like this bloke, he impressed me a lot last year at sandy playing across half back. If he hardens up and builds up his body he is very much in the Jared Rivers mould. I prefer him as a backman but can play forward, im not sure that he believes in himself yet, he played really well in two pre season games and his body language was almost of embarrassment.

Only when he strings a few games together and is shown faith by our coaching staff will he thrive. He hasnt yet got the body for key position but he reads the play so well that he would be well served as a backman that zones off and gets to the marking contest, rivers style to make the spoil. I cant believe Franklin was constantly left one out last weekend.

Im a big wrap for Garland and I certainly prefer him to others. Give him a go. The same goes for Newton.

I totally agree; from all reports, he's much bigger than last year, which is a credit to him considering BBs philosophy of Skinny footballers with no physical presence.

They are kids playing in a selfish team. We must get games into them! Someone needs to tell Newton though that we don't need another Robertson.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

He gives me less hope than most.

I was thoroughly unimpressed with him against the Hawks.

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

I liked the look of him in the first NAB cup game when he was playing foward, but thought he looked completely out of his depth last week.

However, the whole backline looked out of their depth, and Ricky Petterd was the one to get the chop this week. Garland is obviously a good, tall athlete, but has shown me nothing yet to suggest he'll be anything to get excited over.

[Demons 32 235]

He is a poor mans Wheatley at this point, and thats saying something.

[The Emblem 1]

BBs philosophy of Skinny footballers with no physical presence.

My God...is that really his philosophy ? ...Might work in Netball, won't win us a final let alone a Premiership!

[titan_uranus 24,963]

He is a poor mans Wheatley at this point, and thats saying something.

Yeh, and at least Wheatley can kick (well, could kick). Garland missed targets 15 metres away from him under no pressure last week. Btw, I thought he was a forward. Let's hope DB doesn't swtich him between forward and defence this year, or we'll have another Miller issue on our hands.

[mo64 5,843]

Well I don't agree.

I've seen 50 + Colin Garlands come and go over 30+ years. He gives me less hope than most.

Does Frawley fall into this category?

[Bay Riffin 1,466]

how is Frawley going - I see his named on the wing for Sandy !?!?!? maybe we do need our own seconds.

Lamb playing full back ahead of Frawley does f$ck all for us at the Melbourne footbal club.

He is a bit bigger this year and needs to be in defence. I think he could develop into a real defensive type of player that can shut down one particular player.

The Rivers types are more creative, but we need Frawley to just take a man and be told to shut him down for the afternoon, and if they are a foot taller or 10 kg heavier, then so be it. He can then learn how to play on the big boys.

how is his development going ?

[The Emblem 1]

Garland missed targets 15 metres away from him under no pressure last week. Btw, I thought he was a forward.

TU...you rotten bugger. I had just about erased the memory of those disposals from my mind...now they will replay again & again & again to the soundtrack of Beethoven's 9th.

And yes...I think if anything Garland's a HFF.

[Gouga 566]

I agree Petterd had a bad game last week but at least he showed a lot last yeah. Garland hasn't shown anything yet. I'm not giving up on him but I think he needs more time at sandy.

As for Frawley, I'm puzzled as to why he can't get a game. In a depleted defence I thought he would put his hand for a run.

[youami 54]

this one is for hannabal