Judd deal snafu ...

[DV8 2,271]

Kennedy doesn't want to go. What about one of our players for Kennedy?

(edit) one of our players to carlton for Kennedy, we get kennedy, they send maybe green or a (carroll+) to eagles + 3 + 20

something like this.

[grazman 7,451]

Kennedy doesn't want to go. What about one of ours for Kennedy?

One of our what?

[DV8 2,271]

One of our what?

see edit above.

[grazman 7,451]

see edit above.

I actually think Kennedy will be all right, but I don't like the idea of trading something the Eagles want to get him. My natural inclination is to say "stuff em all!"

[Yze_Magic 3]

Kennedy is a big dud

has shown nothing

At best he may become a Drew Petrie type. No thanks

[w00dy 146]

how about we trump their offer, put it on the table to west coast, and give chris the choice between us and the tigers... we will know who he'd choose i'm sure...

[StevenStretch 1]

Kennedy is a big dud

has shown nothing

At best he may become a Drew Petrie type. No thanks

Agreed... I wouldnt trade kennedy for one of our water boys he is a super dud.

[hangon 0]

This whole Judd saga is becoming completely ridiculous and very, very funny.

Its basically come down too ... Carlton vs Tigers or

Cheating tanking wankers vs wankers that cheat and tank. :lol:

[Sydney Pennski 299]

This whole Judd saga is becoming completely ridiculous and very, very funny.

Its basically come down too ... Carlton vs Tigers or

Cheating tanking wankers vs wankers that cheat and tank. :lol:

The man with the golden groin has come to the right club and the right culture. It starts at the TOP and it permeates all the way down. When the wheels start falling off it's going to be the bonfire of the vanities all over again!

[Diablo 1]

Shouldn't it be FUBAR? Or haven't we quite reached that stage yet?

[Johnny Karate 559]

If we assist Carlton in anyway to get Judd I'm going to bury the MFC offices in chicken [censored]. As someone else has stated we should be trying to trump both Carlton and Richmond's offer.

[Demon Disciple 12,274]

Apparently Judd has been traded to the Blues for picks 3, 20 and Kennedy

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story...32-2722,00.html

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Ch.10 just said Kennedy is weighing up his options?

West Coast have been well and truly ripped off. Now lets hope that Judd's groin ensures that Carlton too get ripped off!

[beelzebub 23,383]

Kennedy has yet to commit one way or other.. for Carlton much hinges on this decision. I might be wrong bit I think Kennedy is origianlly from the west. He might opt to join a successful team still with realaspirations or remain with a bunch of f**ked up tankers with tickets on themselves !!! If Kennedy could swing a possible renegotiation of his contract it might indeed be to his advantage to go.

I mean...wouldnt you want to be getting out of princess park as quick as you could ???? lol :D :D :D

[Sydney Pennski 299]

Apparently Judd has been traded to the Blues for picks 3, 20 and Kennedy

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story...32-2722,00.html

Apparently, WCE are going to pay 10% of Pratt's ACCC fine as part of the deal. Talk about being screwed over!

[WonnaJurah 5]

if he says no , blues will send him to psd id think

[Kit Walker 225]

Ch.10 just said Kennedy is weighing up his options?

West Coast have been well and truly ripped off. Now lets hope that Judd's groin ensures that Carlton too get ripped off!

You reckon?

From a fairly weak bargaining point it looks like they will get pick 3 (which is likely to be a choice between 3 very good WA midfield prospects), a 195 KPF prospect with two years' development who was pick 4 only two years ago, plus a pick at the start of the second round.

In relation to Kennedy, it's worth noting that he has been in the system a year less than Newton, Dunn and Bate and is an inch taller. Given that West Coast are pretty light on for tall forwards (hence the reliance on Lynch and Hansen), I don't think they will be too unhappy in the circumstances.

[Adzman 2,154]

So you are telling me that Kennedy would rather stay at the blues than go to the eagles?? Not a bright young man!

If Carroll is to be traded anywhere, the blues are the most likel;y destination. The blues will msot likely trade thornton for hawthorns Boyle, and give nthe history between mark rily and Chopper carroll, Rily would lobby to get chopper to carlton.

I think we could deal with the blues, but we will not be getting kennedy.