i read that cloke wants to return to afl next year , would he be worth getting for a low draft pick, ala edwards or not

sorry at avalon airport and bored out of my brain

LOL

You must be

Where are you heading?

nah

back to brisvegas and this bogan in a carlton jumper is ing me off

i read that cloke wants to return to afl next year , would he be worth getting for a low draft pick, ala edwards or not

maybe we could organize a package with brent grgic

i read that cloke wants to return to afl next year , would he be worth getting for a low draft pick, ala edwards or not

Depends on his form, and you would only use a low pick. He is still young and would be Hungry so who knows ?

Couldnt be any worse than some of the players people are willing to sack. eg Holland etc

I don't think he is too bad a player Jason Cloke, and was stiff not to get picked up.

Worth considering IMO.....we are hardly overloaded with key backs at the minute.

If we got him it would be for next to nothing.

I think he'd be worth having on our list. I think he'd be a decent full back.

I think he'd be a decent full back.

The guy has one skill: punch from behind. Also from memory his kicking is not too flash.

Maybe as a spare third defender for when Rivers, Carroll or our new CHB/FB (whoever that runs out to be) are injured.

maybe as a spare bench warmer for when whelan mclean bartram bate dunn holland sylvia davey robertson neitz miller white mcdonald trav bruce green carroll bell jones ward brown pickett frawley petterd garland newton weetra neville johnson jamar godfrey yze ferguson bizzell moloney buckley johnson rivers warnock and wheatley are out

He can't play a key post, too slow and plays too loose. Sounds like Bizzell. I'm sure he can still play good football like Bizzell did on the weekend but like Bizzell consistancy will be his problem because if he gets found out being too slow and playing too loose he will struggle to get a game.

I'd much rather get back Nick Smith.

I'd much rather get back Nick Smith.

Backwards Maurie backwards

No. Flat out No. Sh!t kick, and we have all the loose defensive players *coughwardcough* we need.

Cloke or Ferguson ?????

Would rather The Biz than a Cloke!!

Would rather The Biz than a Cloke!!

Agreed..........but I think he would offer more than Fergs.

Is Fergs the prime example of the difference in class between VFL & AFL? or is it a lack of confidence when playing in the seniors??

he smashes them stupid in the vfl - his job on ablett in last year's grand final nearly won him the best on ground!!

Agreed..........but I think he would offer more than Fergs.

That isn't saying much.

I think we have enough defenders who can't kick

My friend who works at the CBA sees him every week when he comes in reckons hes hot but up himself cos he is a "footballer" he tells them. She didnt realise he was VFL now which I reminded her of. And we dont want him

we all know that cloke is going no where fast as an afl footballer. we have a players who are capable of preforming the same back up roles cloke would play already on the list. these players are part of the team already. i'd rather keep the team together and have an extra draft pick than swap like for like or picking up an extra dud.

is this thread for real? jason cloke? the collingwood hack who had one good year? whose 14 year old brother was better than him, granted he looked about 34. we can't seriously be debating picking up jason cloke! must be a different one