9 Christian Petracca (MELB)

6 Kysaiah Pickett (MELB)

5 Jack Viney (MELB)

4 Clayton Oliver (MELB)

2 Angus Brayshaw (MELB)

2 Max Gawn (MELB)

1 Tom McDonald (MELB)

1 Tim Kelly (WCE)

 

Split:

5/4 Petracca

3/3 Picket

5/0 Viney

4/0 Oliver

2/0 Brayshaw

2/0 Gawn

1/0 McDonald

1/0 Kelly

 

• Going on the DL votes many would be surprised to see both coaches rated Petracca so highly.
• Other than Petracca and Picket the coaches were all over the shop...
• Goodwin rated only one of Viney/Oliver, Brayshaw/Gawn.  Reckon it was Viney and Gawn.
• Good to see Kozzie among the votes by both coaches.  Great recognition.

 

Leaderboard

 

Oliver catching up to Cripps ☺️

 

53	Patrick Cripps	CARL
51	Clayton Oliver	MELB
49	Lachie Neale	BL
47	Andrew Brayshaw	FRE
44	Christian Petracca	MELB
41	Callum Mills	SYD
38	Touk Miller	GCFC
32	Bailey Smith	WB
31	Jack Crisp	COLL
31	Hugh McCluggage	BL
31	Darcy Parish	ESS
30	Max Gawn	MELB
30	James Sicily	HAW
29	Shai Bolton	RICH
28	Charlie Curnow	CARL
27	Jeremy Cameron	GEEL
27	Jack Higgins	STK
26	Tom J Lynch	RICH
26	Jack Steele	STK

Max is the only ruckman on the leader board so shaping up for a 6 times AA

Very interesting coaches votes this week

Yes, very interesting Luci.  
Last time I looked, Jack Viney was clear BOG according to the Demonland punters, but wasn’t ranked so highly by Goody.  No doubt the disparity relates to team roles and how well they were played in the eyes of our coach, and of course, we are not privy to this information.

Edited May 16, 20222 yr by Deeoldfart

Very surprised someone gave Oliver 4, and even more surprised that Viney received 0 from one of them.

  On 16/05/2022 at 06:37, Deeoldfart said:

Yes, very interesting Luci.  
Last time I looked, Jack Viney was clear BOG according to the Demonland punters, but wasn’t ranked so highly by Goody.  No doubt the disparity relates to team roles and how well they were played in the eyes of the coach, and of course, we are not privy to this information.

Goodwin may have been the one to give Jack 5 and Simpson gave him zip.  Like you I fail to see how either coach gave him zip.

And you make a good point about team roles as I didn't see Petracca's game as BOG or 2nd BOG but the coaches did so who knows what they see.  Sometimes, I wonder whether a fan's view is affected by the camera following the ball so we don't get to see the off ball work so well.

Edited May 16, 20222 yr by Lucifers Hero

5/0 a funny one, Imagine the 5 was Goody as he loves Jack. 

I reckon this is perfectly reflective of a messy scrappy game with lots of cameo roles but no clear story.

Goody absolutely gave Viney the 5 as Goody puts defence first and Viney nailed the defensive role all night.
 

I can understand Simos 0 because he would only see the offensive damage caused and Trac lit up with his score involvements 29 touches and 2 goals, which should have been 4.  

Goodwin absolutely loves Viney.  Simpson's votes are usually a bit left field.  I reckon Goody went Viney, Petracca, Pickett, Gawn and McDonald.  Kozzy was great.  On first viewing I wasn't overly impressed with Maxie, but having watched it back he was pretty dominant - as he should've been against the WCE no name rucks, and probably amongst the best half dozen on the ground in a pretty even effort.