Coaches Votes are out for Round 12 and i must admit im a bit surprised. The calculations would indicate that Bailey got 5 votes. Yes he was good but 5 votes worth? 

VOTES

PLAYER (CLUB)

8

Christian Petracca (MELB)

7

Zac Bailey (BL)

7

Clayton Oliver (MELB)

6

Max Gawn (MELB)

1

Tom McDonald (MELB)

1

Eric Hipwood (BL)

Edited June 7, 20214 yr by CYB

He was very good in the first half, just as Oliver was very good in the second half.

Hipwood with 1 vote is surely taking the absolute p!ss.

Just now, Jaded said:

He was very good in the first half, just as Oliver was very good in the second half.

Hipwood with 1 vote is surely taking the absolute p!ss.

Just goes to show that some coaches still look after there own.

8 minutes ago, CYB said:

Coaches Votes are out for Round 12 and i must admit im a bit surprised. The calculations would indicate that Bailey got 5 votes. Yes he was good but 5 votes worth? 

VOTES

PLAYER (CLUB)

8

Christian Petracca (MELB)

7

Zac Bailey (BL)

7

Clayton Oliver (MELB)

6

Max Gawn (MELB)

1

Tom McDonald (MELB)

1

Eric Hipwood (BL)

Baily 5   -   Clarry  5

Trac 4     - Trac   4

Max 3   -   Max  3

Clarry 2 -  Baily 2

or

Clarry 5 - Trac 5

Baily 4 - Max 4

Trac 3 - Baily 3

Max 2 - Clarry 2

32 minutes ago, Grimes Times said:

Baily 5   -   Clarry  5

Trac 4     - Trac   4

Max 3   -   Max  3

Clarry 2 -  Baily 2

or

Clarry 5 - Trac 5

Baily 4 - Max 4

Trac 3 - Baily 3

Max 2 - Clarry 2

The second option is the most likely.  Very rare for a player in the losing side to get 5.  I can understand the disparity between a 5 and 3 for Tracc and a 5 and 2 for Oliver - Oliver had 8 possessions to half time but was brilliant in the second half. Gawn as a 4 and 2 makes sense.  Bailey at 4 and 3 is perfectly understandable.

2 hours ago, Grimes Times said:

Baily 5   -   Clarry  5

Trac 4     - Trac   4

Max 3   -   Max  3

Clarry 2 -  Baily 2

or

Clarry 5 - Trac 5

Baily 4 - Max 4

Trac 3 - Baily 3

Max 2 - Clarry 2

OR

Tracc 5 + 3

Bailey 5 + 2

Oliver 4 + 3

Max 4 + 2

Cant dispute the coach's opinion, because that is all it is, but IMO a great first half in a losing team is not nearly as valuable as a great second half in a winning team.

If it was Brownlow votes , it’s 3- Trac 2- Gawn 1- Oliver 

5 hours ago, Jaded said:

He was very good in the first half, just as Oliver was very good in the second half.

Hipwood with 1 vote is surely taking the absolute p!ss.

If I'm Chris Fagan I'd have given Harris Andrews a vote before Hipwood.