Dylan Shiel

[jumbo returns 6,741]

And that's because this "pact" stuff is carp.

If it were true like you tell it, they'd all have singed in January.

Believe it or rot, M

But, isn't it all unfolding as reported???

Hmmmm?

[Machsy 2,858]

Oh come on, you're not that daft.

There may have once been some sort of pact, and they may have signed on for the most part, but that's because they can tell they're odds on to win a flag there with their mates if they stay.

It's not because a handful of them made a pact as teenagers.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Oh come on, you're not that daft.

There may have once been some sort of pact, and they may have signed on for the most part, but that's because they can tell they're odds on to win a flag there with their mates if they stay.

It's not because a handful of them made a pact as teenagers.

No, no, my mail came in late last year.

It wasn't a witches' coven or some sorority prank....a group of players pledged that they would all sign on to see how far they could go.

That's all. No need to believe me.

[Adam The God 30,537]

I think it all depends on what they're offered by other clubs. Unless they get Boyd-like money, there's not currently a great reason to leave. I'd give Treloar Boyd-like money though. But that's just me. Apparently, Collingwood have offered him $750k. That shouldn't be enough to prise him, unless he really wants back to Victoria.

Edited June 12, 2015 by AdamFarr

[jumbo returns 6,741]

I think it all depends on what they're offered by other clubs. Unless they get Boyd-like money, there's not currently a great reason to leave. I'd give Treloar Boyd-like money though. But that's just me. Apparently, Collingwood have offered him $750k. That shouldn't be enough to prise him, unless he really wants back to Victoria.

750k?

Gee whiz...and he does a knee? Wow.

Clubs are getting desperate.

I hope our club stitches up Hogan ala Freo with Pav....they managed to hold onto him.

[KingDingAling 3,758]

750k?

Gee whiz...and he does a knee? Wow.

Clubs are getting desperate.

I hope our club stitches up Hogan ala Freo with Pav....they managed to hold onto him.

We have a better young list than Fremantle. I know Fremantle look good atm, but Pav, Sandilands, Mundy, Johnson, and even Barlow, aren't too far off retiring. When Fremantle go through that inevitable football regression - where they slide outside the 4, MFC will be going through the opposite - hopefully anyway. It is all about timing, and IMO, the timing will be on our side in regards to Hogan.

[dee-luded 2,959]

We have a better young list than Fremantle. I know Fremantle look good atm, but Pav, Sandilands, Mundy, Johnson, and even Barlow, aren't too far off retiring. When Fremantle go through that inevitable football regression - where they slide outside the 4, MFC will be going through the opposite - hopefully anyway. It is all about timing, and IMO, the timing will be on our side in regards to Hogan.

haven't looked at the Freo list, but if what your saying is right, then Rossy Lyon had better do better with his list, than he did at the Saints.

[picket fence 17,716]

Mods Close this thread, Dylan Shiel is now persona "Non Gratis"

Why let pain continue!!?

[Adam The God 30,537]

Give it two more years.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Mods Close this thread, Dylan Shiel is now persona "Non Gratis"

Why let pain continue!!?

Exactly, it's like continuing to talk about a player we could have drafted three years ago.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

would love to be a fly on the wall of the inner workings of the club, and see how much we had a crack at him, in terms of contact, offers etc.

[Machsy 2,858]

Mods Close this thread, Dylan Shiel is now persona "Non Gratis"

Why let pain continue!!?

You're unintentionally hilarious.

[spirit of norm smith 16,596]

We can offer pick 4 and Howe for Dylan Shiel. Thoughts???

[dee-luded 2,959]

Give it two more years.

absolutely, IF we can afford him then?

[dee-luded 2,959]

Exactly, it's like continuing to talk about a player we could have drafted three years ago.

more like temporarily close & pin, for a later date

again we should have gone hard for him when he wasn't a name 2 years back.

just like Danger & Boak back about 5 yrs or so.

Its should be Henderson now... & Prestia. et al.

[Machsy 2,858]

We can offer pick 4 and Howe for Dylan Shiel. Thoughts???

Now that Shiel has signed, surely Treloar or Coniglio would be the target?

Happily give up either pick 4 (about correct weight) or Howe (a steal) for Coniglio.

I don't think Treloar would be realistic.

[picket fence 17,716]

Exactly, it's like continuing to talk about a player we could have drafted three years ago.

Totally different case. 3 Years ago Ollie Wines was available and wanting yes Wanting to get to the MFC!

Dylan Shiel already a GWS Player and clearly see's his team going places!

Time to wise up to the reality!

One we could /should have got , the other was just smoke and mirrors!

Moving on!!

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Totally different case. 3 Years ago Ollie Wines was available and wanting yes Wanting to get to the MFC!

Dylan Shiel already a GWS Player and clearly see's his team going places!

Time to wise up to the reality!

One we could /should have got , the other was just smoke and mirrors!

Moving on!!

Actually, no. You're not moving on. You're trolling.

[picket fence 17,716]

Actually no, stating facts!!

Fact Ollie Wines wanted to come to MFC

Fact Dylan Shiel was just a figment of a lot of peoples Pipe dream ( A bit like thinking gee I'm gunna win Tattslotto tonight!!) show me where there was any any facts he was entertaining coming to us! ??

Nup The reality bus has just hit the delusional posters on this site!

I couldn't give a stuff!

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Actually no, stating facts!!

Fact Ollie Wines wanted to come to MFC

Fact Dylan Shiel was just a figment of a lot of peoples Pipe dream ( A bit like thinking gee I'm gunna win Tattslotto tonight!!) show me where there was any any facts he was entertaining coming to us! ??

Nup The reality bus has just hit the delusional posters on this site!

I couldn't give a stuff!

Dog. With. Bone.

No one cares with your retrospective carp anymore. Get over yourself.

And drink less......or maybe more.....

Edited June 13, 2015 by Moonshadow

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Now that Shiel has signed, surely Treloar or Coniglio would be the target?

Happily give up either pick 4 (about correct weight) or Howe (a steal) for Coniglio.

I don't think Treloar would be realistic.

Nope - both part of the pact.

Signed in blood....