ENDING THE DAYS OF PAIN by Whispering Jack

The media is reporting that one of the Melbourne Football Club's responses to recent intense media criticism in the wake of the team's poor winless record after nine rounds has been to institute a series of meetings for selected supporters where they can question the club chairman Don McLardy, CEO Cam Schwab, Coach Mark Neeld and his assistant Neil Craig on matters relating to all aspects of its performance.

I was fortunate enough to be invited to the first of these sessions on Tuesday night and can vouch for the fact that the evening could in no way be described as a "crisis" meeting although that is precisely the impression that many have of the club at present - a club in crisis. It was however, all about the way the club is moving to end the long days of pain it has been experiencing for more than half a decade.

From my point of view as a concerned supporter, the one and a half hours were in fact as positive, constructive as they could be in the club's circumstances. The three speakers, McLardy, Neeld and Craig outlined their plans and strategies and made a good fist of reassuring a group of fairly hardnosed supporters that the club is on the right path despite the fact that it sits winless at the foot of the AFL table in a season in which two very young franchises are currently ahead of them (albeit narrowly).

I know there are many sceptics but I have to say I was impressed by what the three had to say.

McLardy outlined where the club is off the field and this has been well documented. We a positive net asset position despite the loss of a major sponsor. McLardy defended Cameron Schwab and pointed to the red and blueprint which Schwab put together and which has earned praise from the AFL administration.

Neeld put together a very impressive presentation. He presented statistics of various indicators to show how his game plan is developing. It's a game plan that's based heavily on defence - not just from back line players but from every position on the field. He pointed out that statistics indicate that only one premiership team in the past three decades hadn't finished in the top four in defensive statistics (Brisbane Lions in 2003 were sixth but in the second half of that season were first). Neeld cited Dean Cox who said the difference between WCE of 2010 and 2011 was that the players adopted and embraced a strongly defensive approach.

Needless to say the coach is convinced the tide will turn but it might still take time. Both he and Craig said they were staggered that players were saying they went through their toughest pre season after the new guard took over. They said that in their view, training loads were kept fairly conservatively (to avoid major injuries) and the intensity will be ramped up more during the next pre season.

Neeld's view is that many players are brought up with attacking mindsets. The most talented players coming into the TAC Cup system are usually midfielders or forwards. They often remain good attacking players but don't measure up defensively. He found this with many players at Melbourne. He is convinced that the indicators show that his methods are working. Against Carlton, Neeld was happy with the figures both from a defensive and an attacking viewpoint. We were good in a number of areas but during the last quarter when the players were tired, Carlton was able to ramp up the pressure and many of our players reverted to old habits and didn't work hard enough defensively.

The easy way to coach would probably have been to follow the same path as Neeld's predecessors, a path that might have brought better results in the short term but would never have given the club a chance to challenge the big boys in much the same way as it struggled against them last year. We all well remember the meaning of "bruise free" and "186" from 2011 even if there were some big moments against the competition's lesser lights.

It goes without saying that we can expect changes in the makeup of the team and clearly, the midfield will be the area that gets a fair bit of attention.

Craig defended Neeld and his other assistants and pointed to the unbelievable initiation he's had into coaching ranks including the Jurrah situation, the Davey/Mifsud racism furore, the death of Jimmy, the injuries and poor form. Craig also defended Schwab noting that he hadn't seen any sign of interference from the CEO into football department matters (nor McLardy for that matter). Craig was full of praise for the entire leadership group.

For all that, Melbourne remains on the bottom of the AFL ladder, and faces Essendon and Collingwood in its next two matches. The days of pain may not be over yet.

THE GAME

Essendon v Melbourne at the MCG Saturday, 2 June 2012 at 7.40pm.

HEAD TO HEAD

Overall Essendon 126 wins Melbourne 79 wins 2 draws

At the MCG Essendon 63 wins Melbourne 43 wins 1 draw

Since 2000: Essendon 10 wins Melbourne 6 wins

The Coaches Hird 0 wins Neeld 0 wins

MEDIA

TV Channel 7 Fox Footy Channel live at 7.30pm

RADIO 3AW Triple M

THE BETTING Essendon $1.05 to win Melbourne $10.00 to win

THE LAST TIME THEY MET

Melbourne 15.11.101 defeated Essendon 10.8. 68 at the MCG

It was a great night for the Demons as the unexpectedly bested the Bombers in all parts of the ground. It was a big night for Melbourne's young midfielders with Gysberts, Trengove and McKenzie in outstanding form and Scully doing well on return. The problem from Melbourne's point of view is that its goal kickers that night were:-

Green 4 Jurrah 3 Jetta Moloney 2 Howe Scully Sylvia Watts

How many of these players will be in action on Saturday night?

THE TEAMS

ESSENDON

Backs Cale Hooker Dustin Fletcher Courtenay Dempsey

Half backs Ricky Dyson Kyle Hardingham Jake Carlisle

Centreline David Zaharakis Jobe Watson Brent Stanton

Half forwards Angus Monfries Stewart Crameri Patrick Ryder

Forwards Leroy Jetta Michael Hurley Alwyn Davey

Followers Tom Bellchambers Ben Howlett Heath Hocking

Interchange Travis Colyer Sam Lonergan Nathan Lovett-Murray Melksham

Emergencies David Hille Tayte Pears Henry Slattery

In Dustin Fletcher Kyle Hardingham Leroy Jetta

Out Mark McVeigh Tayte Pears Henry Slattery

MELBOURNE

Backs James Frawley Jared Rivers Tom McDonald

Half backs Jack Trengove Jack Watts Colin Garland

Centreline Jack Grimes James Magner Nathan Jones

Half forwards Rohan Bail Mitch Clark Joel Macdonald

Forwards Jeremy Howe Brad Green Luke Tapscott

Followers Mark Jamar Brent Moloney Jordie McKenzie

Interchange Sam Blease Lynden Dunn Daniel Nicholson Colin Sylvia

Emergencies Matthew Bate Jamie Bennell James Sellar

In Joel Macdonald Colin Sylvia

Out Jamie Bennell James Sellar

THE TROUBLES by Whispering Jack

It's hard to fathom that twelve months down the track from their last meeting that the two combatants in this game would be at almost polar opposites to each other and that Essendon would be starting as such an odds on favourite to win.

The Bombers are sitting in equal top position on the ladder with just one loss for the season (by a single point to Collingwood on Anzac Day) while the Demons have lost their first nine matches of the season.

That's enough to make it a lay down misere that an Essendon brimming with confidence will win and win easily and that's how I'm predicting the game to pan out.

Part of the question why is already explained above in some shape or form. The type of game that is being instilled into the Melbourne team is radically different to that which applied in past years and the team is not yet ready in terms of make up and fitness to conquer top eight teams in full flight.

In last year's encounter, we caught a glimpse of a better Melbourne midfield. It was headed by Brent Moloney who won the club's best and fairest and polled 19 Brownlow votes. Beamer's form has been well down on that and he would be very lucky to have polled a vote at all to this stage of the season. But the better midfielders that night included Jordan Gysberts, Jack Trengove, Jordie McKenzie and Tom Scully, who all racked up good numbers on their possession counts. Two of those players haven't played this year. Gysberts is injured and Scully jumped ship. The so called "compensation" for the latter won't kick in for a while. Other potential young midfielders on the list also languish with injuries and loss of form. So the club's all important midfield has taken a hit just at the time when it's most needed and much development time is being lost.

But if the midfield has taken a hit then there's also the matter of the attack. Even with the changes that Neeld's defensive approach entails, the end game is always to score ... at least more than the opposition in any given game. So here is something that the club's harshest critics seem to have missed.

Last year, Melbourne's top three goalkickers were:-

• Liam Jurrah 40 goals

• Brad Green 37 goals

• Colin Sylvia 25 goals

That's 102 goals between the club's three most attacking playmakers. These players alone directly contributed almost five goals per game between them and I dare say would have been responsible for setting up a few more goals to others on a weekly basis. It's not unreasonable that we should have expected this trio, Mitch Clark and perhaps Ricky Petterd as well, to do most of the team's scoring.

Alas, after nine matches we have had very little from the players we might have otherwise expected to contribute to the scoreboard. Instead, we have this:-

• Liam Jurrah 0 goals

• Brad Green 2 goals

• Colin Sylvia 1 goal

Now, if you take the three top goalkicking forwards as completely out of the equation as the above figures indicate, it's not likely that a young team with a completely new style of play to learn is going to show very much, particularly if the midfield is also performing at well below its best.

Sure, you might say it's the coach's role to get the best out of his players and that will certainly be the case in the medium to long term but after nine games in these circumstances, there's is no reason to do anything other than to cut him some slack.

The troubles are by no means over but there needs to be a much greater understanding of Neeld and his team's plight. When it all starts to click the results will be quite dramatic; the club will be in a much better place and the days of pain will be over.

But, I don't think we can expect that to happen this week.

Essendon by 34 points.

With all due respect to the lead up to the Ess game, this excellent write up by WJ of the 'non-crisis' meeting should be its own thread.

Agreed.

Great write up WJ.

Round 10 Melbourne team

B: James Frawley, Jared Rivers, Tom McDonald

HB: Jack Trengove, Jack Watts, Colin Garland

C: Jack Grimes, James Magner, Nathan Jones

HF: Rohan Bail, Mitch Clark, Joel Macdonald

F: Jeremy Howe, Brad Green, Luke Tapscott

FOLL: Mark Jamar, Brent Moloney, Jordie McKenzie

I/C: Colin Sylvia, Lynden Dunn, Sam Blease, Daniel Nicholson

EMG: Matthew Bate, Jamie Bennell, James Sellar

IN: Macdonald, Sylvia

OUT: Sellar, Bennell

Round 10 Melbourne team

B: James Frawley, Jared Rivers, Tom McDonald

HB: Jack Trengove, Jack Watts, Colin Garland

C: Jack Grimes, James Magner, Nathan Jones

HF: Rohan Bail, Mitch Clark, Joel Macdonald

F: Jeremy Howe, Brad Green, Luke Tapscott

FOLL: Mark Jamar, Brent Moloney, Jordie McKenzie

I/C: Colin Sylvia, Lynden Dunn, Sam Blease, Daniel Nicholson

EMG: Matthew Bate, Jamie Bennell, James Sellar

IN: Macdonald, Sylvia

OUT: Sellar, Bennell

This the official team GTG?

If so I can only add the first thing that comes to mind every Thursday... WHERE THE F#@K IS COUCH?!!

OUT: Sellar, Bennell

old dee will be most disapointed!

This the official team GTG?

If so I can only add the first thing that comes to mind every Thursday... WHERE THE F#@K IS COUCH?!!

Yep, posted on the MFC site's live chat. I'm happy with the outs, but not so thrilled with the ins.

Round 10 Melbourne team

B: James Frawley, Jared Rivers, Tom McDonald

HB: Jack Trengove, Jack Watts, Colin Garland

C: Jack Grimes, James Magner, Nathan Jones

HF: Rohan Bail, Mitch Clark, Joel Macdonald

F: Jeremy Howe, Brad Green, Luke Tapscott

FOLL: Mark Jamar, Brent Moloney, Jordie McKenzie

I/C: Colin Sylvia, Lynden Dunn, Sam Blease, Daniel Nicholson

EMG: Matthew Bate, Jamie Bennell, James Sellar

IN: Macdonald, Sylvia

OUT: Sellar, Bennell

Yes thank you!

I am tempted to say this looks like a good side But I have thought that the last two weeks and we have lost by10+ goals

I think I have worked out the problem.

I am forgetting to look at the other team.

Oh no!

Yes, its the official team.

Couch hasn't played for 3 weeks now. Bit hard to put him in for his first game after that.

MacDonald as usual is meh. Happy with both outs though - and only having 2 is good as we WERE competitive for a decent amount of time last week...

Sylvia, time to shine please mate.

old dee will be most disapointed!

Funnily DemonWA I looked at the team, then Essendon

I now wonder will it make any difference.

Very negative I know but I struggle to see much that is positive in the Dees after three months of 2012

I don't understand this scenario:

-MFC elevate Couch from rookie list

-Couch tears up VFL

-MFC midfield struggling badly, especially for clearances

-Couch can't get a game

WTF?!

J Mac as a Half Forward. Interesting.

J Mac as a Half Forward. Interesting.

I doubt they'll line up like that. J Mac shouldn't venture up the ground.

Yes, its the official team.

Couch hasn't played for 3 weeks now. Bit hard to put him in for his first game after that.

MacDonald as usual is meh. Happy with both outs though - and only having 2 is good as we WERE competitive for a decent amount of time last week...

Sylvia, time to shine please mate.

Could couch be worse than 10 that played last week?

Interesting rhaz that we consider 60% of a game as a good result this year.

I don't understand this scenario:

-MFC elevate Couch from rookie list

-Couch tears up VFL

-MFC midfield struggling badly, especially for clearances

-Couch can't get a game

WTF?!

I agree that earlier in the season he deserved a game, but he hasn't played for the past 3 weeks.

Keep Couch in a winning side until 2013.

Make winning second nature.

I agree that earlier in the season he deserved a game, but he hasn't played for the past 3 weeks.

Doesn't matter, most of our mids haven't showed up all year...

J Mac as a Half Forward. Interesting.

since when did you start believing thursday team placings?

Keep Couch in a winning side until 2013.

Make winning second nature.

Why would he stick around with us when he deserves a chance but isn't getting it?!

Doesn't matter, most of our mids haven't showed up all year...

I completely agree with you, and I'd love to see him replace Moloney or Sylvia. THis is probably just the angle that the selection committee are coming from.

Why would he stick around with us when he deserves a chance but isn't getting it?!

Because he might not be put on another AFL list.

Why would he stick around with us when he deserves a chance but isn't getting it?!

No sure there is a third option available stuie

I completely agree with you, and I'd love to see him replace Moloney or Sylvia. THis is probably just the angle that the selection committee are coming from.

Just don't understand why they think our best VFL player doesn't deserve at least a sub role in a team getting smashed in the middle and losing by 10+ goals every week.

If thats the bench make up then either Dunn or Sylvia should be sub. We need Blease for his pace against there midfeild and Nicholson did well last week,

Who should Mckenzie tag. Watson or Stanton?

Because he might not be put on another AFL list.

Really??! You really think no one would pick him up after the form he has shown at VFL level and the current trend of teams picking up more senior players?!