This is a joke right?

When you lose to the tiges by 50+ points there are NO players deserving of votes.

Should be suspended until we play for 4 quarters.

Edited April 14, 201213 yr by DemonOX

This is a joke right?

When you lose to the tiges by 50+ points there are NO players deserving of votes.

Should be suspended until we play for 4 quarters.

Does this mean that Gary Ablett can pick up 40 touches in each of his first two games, and not deserve any votes? I don't think so.

By the way, Jeremy Howe picked up 130 dream team points. Our next best was 79. Jeremy deserves a vote; maybe even a Brownlow vote.

Lol, player of the year. Whatever, I'll give the points to Howe for exciting me with some of his grabs. Give some to Clark and Watts too. Don't care how much you give to each. Surprise me.

6. Howe

5. Watts

4. Jones

3. Clark

2. McKenzie

1. Trengove

This is a joke right?

When you lose to the tiges by 50+ points there are NO players deserving of votes.

Should be suspended until we play for 4 quarters.

Agreed. This is a pointless, patronizing exercise.

Trengove was shocking today. Missing when it counted. It was a Green-esque captains game.

GRimes not any better with his ridiculous clangers.

6 Howe (although the 50% DE is a worry)

5 Jones

4 Watts

3 Clark

2 McDonald

1 Trengove

Very difficult this week. There's a few who stood up and played well, and then there's daylight between everyone else.

6: Howe

5: Watts

4: Jones

3: Clark

2: McDonald

1. Frawley

6: Howe

5: Mckenzie

4: Frawley

3: Jones

2: Watts

1: Davey

Surely winning any MFC award at the moment would only prove you can put your jumper on the right way round and you can tie your shoe laces

Moderators please close the thread immediately. No one has deserved a vote all year. Re-open when we finally play 4 quarters of good footy (ie 2015)

6 Howe - did almost everything well in unfamiliar territory

5 Jones - puts in consistently and not getting caught with the ball like he used to be

4 Watts - see Howe above but not as consistently for the 4 quarters

3 Clark - impressive (mostly)

2 Rivers - I've got no idea why he's not rated by some. Almost always does the job when he's not on a monster

1 Bate - stood up and will continue to improve if he gets the ame time. Strong over head.

Too late?

6. Howe

5. Clark

4. Watts

3. Jones

2. Frawley

1. ..nope that's it

6. Howe

5.

4. Watts

3.

2.

1. Jones

Ed: someone gave Morton a vote FFS! Joke surely.

Edited April 15, 201213 yr by Mono

Apologies for the delay but here are the standings after the Round 3 game v Richmond.

32. James Magner

31 Nthan Jones

26 Mitch Clark Jeremy Howe

22. Jack Watts

15. Jack Trengove

9 James Frawley

6. Jared Rivers

4. Stef Martin

3. Joel Macdonald Jordie McKenzie

2. Rohan Bail Matthew Bate Lynden Dunn Jack Grimes Tom McDonald

1. Clint Bartram Aaron Davey

I ho

pe to have the Round 4 standings up in the next day or so.