Who would you like to see on the Demonland banner next season. For me (in order):

EDIT: Jim Stynes; a given

1. Watts

2. Trengove

3. Frawley

4. McKenzie

5. Moloney

6. Jurrah

7. Sylvia

8. Martin

Edited August 16, 201114 yr by Watt and Howe?

Who would you like to see on the Demonland banner next season. For me (in order):

1. Watts

2. Trengove

3. Frawley

4. McKenzie

5. Moloney

6. Jurrah

7. Sylvia

8. Martin

Gotta be joking about Jurrah and Sylvia. No way. For me I would have 1 person and that is Martin. Only one who has improved this year, watts to a lesser extent. The others are a disgrace

Who would you like to see on the Demonland banner next season. For me (in order):

1. Watts

2. Trengove

3. Frawley

4. McKenzie

5. Moloney

6. Jurrah

7. Sylvia

8. Martin

ADD (keep) Jimmy there and that sounds about right. Maybe Garland for Mckenzie.

ADD (keep) Jimmy there and that sounds about right. Maybe Garland for Mckenzie.

Agree about Jimmeh, he was a given for me

Mick Malthouse

Gotta be joking about Jurrah and Sylvia. No way. For me I would have 1 person and that is Martin. Only one who has improved this year, watts to a lesser extent. The others are a disgrace

You're right McKenzie and Trengove have had crap seasons...muppet!!!

I know Sylvia and Jurrah don't deserve to be there based on form (hence why low on my list, they are just a few of my favourite players) . You also seem to forget that despite Jurrah having a bad year he is still our leading goal kicker and most damaging forward.

Mick Malthouse

+1

Jim Stynes is the only deserving one so far....Maybe Jack Watts And Trenners either side..

The rest of the entire club needs one hell of a pre season.

Mick Malthouse

HaHa!! I love the way that Mick is distancing himself from Eddiewood further each day.

My Bet for 2012 is looking better & better by the hour.

You're right McKenzie and Trengove have had crap seasons...muppet!!!

I know Sylvia and Jurrah don't deserve to be there based on form (hence why low on my list, they are just a few of my favourite players) . You also seem to forget that despite Jurrah having a bad year he is still our leading goal kicker and most damaging forward.

Trengove year has not been anything special nor has McKenzie. Geelong, Collingwood, WCE, Hawks etc would not concider these players quality. End point!

Trengove year has not been anything special nor has McKenzie. Geelong, Collingwood, WCE, Hawks etc would not concider these players quality. End point!

You're right in this banner we should put Geelong, Collingwood, WCE and Hawks players. This isn't an AFL banner it's a MFC banner you FOOL!

Trengove year has not been anything special nor has McKenzie. Geelong, Collingwood, WCE, Hawks etc would not concider these players quality. End point!

Yes, they would...

McKenzie and Trengove would be snapped up and played in any team in the league.

Any team.

Trengove year has not been anything special nor has McKenzie. Geelong, Collingwood, WCE, Hawks etc would not concider these players quality. End point!

Pull the other one Mate...Jordie and Treeners put in 110% each week, you obviously don't.

ahem.... Moloney chaps

Jimma, then Watts, JT, Jordie, Joel Mac and Stef Martin

ahem.... Moloney chaps

0 possessions in a half of a game.

Jim, McKenzie, Watts, Trengove, Garland

No one else deserves a sniff of an oily rag

1. Jimma

2. Trengove

3. Scully

4. Watts

5. Moloney

6. Jurrah

7. Jones

8. Malthouse

This question applies to most topics on here ,but not all .

Does it really matter?

This question applies to most topics on here ,but not all .

Does it really matter?

Its more fun than talking about Scully and Fev.

I'd give Yze Magic a run on the banner.

Without question....Adriana Lima.....

Adriana for Banner!

Edited August 16, 201114 yr by Rusty Nails

If I was going to make a banner purely for my fave players this year -

Watts, Tapscott, Trengove, Bail, Jurrah, Pettard, Martin, McKenzie

These guys are all awesome. I don't give a [censored] if some people think Jurrah has had a bad year. He has clearly playing injured and is awesome.

I'd like it to be hard earn't, and If the player disgraces the club in some way or won't committ to the club, they should be taken down, Until such time things are remedied.

This question applies to most topics on here ,but not all .

Does it really matter?

It should, & it could.

It's a reflection of who we are and what we believe in re Melbourne. So it's a statement of Demon supporters, & how we feel & think.

We have a habit of adulating players, before they've proven anything in football. We are part of the problem of our players getting Big Heads way before their football improves.

@ Maybe we could put our real champions Up on the banner???

What about Barassi? Flower? Smith? Neitz? Schwartz? Hughes? Stynes? Wight? Spencer? any other one club Demons?

* Arthur Caldwell?

Edited August 16, 201114 yr by dee-luded

How many on that current Banner wear Bruises with Pride?