The Cameron Bruce Debacle

[rpfc 28,433]

This has been done to death.

Maybe we would have asked Junior to go around again but it comes down to what I have been saying for ages (and a few others):

I want a fracking flag!

Someone tell me how Cam Bruce playing in 2011 and 2012 will get us that flag?

And if someone says we are a chance this year or next - you are playing with yourself. You're sitting there in your own little world, masturbating in your mind.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Well said cranky. We'll see how our youth policy works without Junior and Cameron. We could have had both this season if not for the so called 'youth policy'. Successful clubs manage to combine youth and experience. We are lacking badly in the latter. Time will tell.

Successfull clubs rebuild off a quality list and culture that's not run down.

We've gone deeper back to the bone, with our list, and had to bottom out to do it. The old list, (excepting Junior) was of the old culture. Greeny has turned himself around, and inside out, improving over the last 3 Years.

[BAMF 4,353]

Hardly a debacle. Now that the dust has settled im very happy for Bruce to be at the hawks. He has a shot at a flag and he will make them a better team. All he would be doing for us is taking the spot of a youngster.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Actually we better hope none of us, or anyone reading this thread, or any young players who may happen to read it Today,,, get a week ahaed of ourselves.

We'd better focus on Sydney, for today...

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,654]

I can't wait till we play the Hawks.

I've been waiting for years for Bruce to consistently kick it to our players and to put some pressure an our opponents.

Looks like I'll get my wish

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Why don't we talk about Brock McLean wanting out to go to Carlton while we're at it.

Or Farmer wanting to go to Freo.

WHO CARES?!

[Nasher 33,616]

Why don't we talk about Brock McLean wanting out to go to Carlton while we're at it.

Or Farmer wanting to go to Freo.

WHO CARES?!

Yeah. And let's have a little chat about this Gerard Healy fellow. And Ron Barassi.

Barassi, Healy, McLean and Bruce all have equal relevance to the MFC playing squad in 2011.

[rpfc 28,433]

Yeah. And let's have a little chat about this Gerard Healy fellow. And Ron Barassi.

Barassi, Healy, McLean and Bruce all have equal relevance to the MFC playing squad in 2011.

And I also hate the way Bruce is lumped together with JMac as if they are tacitly saying that they had a commensurate level of leadership...

In terms of leaders at our club over the past few years, it has been:

Junior.

That is all.

Now we need the next level of leaders to assert themselves and it starts on Sunday.

[DeeMfc 621]

The exit of CB at the end of 2010 will prove a blessing in disguise ( for more than 1 reason).

Other than what has already been discussed, the most notable will be the retention of 1 or more of our young guns over the next 2 years due to relief in salary cap pressure.

Do we want flags from 2013 onwards or to end the seasons 2011 & 2012 in 7th and 5th place ?

Give me a flag or 2 or 3 !!!

I'm happy to wait another couple of years for a serious tilt.

Cam Bruces best chances of a flag was when he himself was a youngster at the Dee's or now with the Dorks, it was the right move for all party's involved- a classic win-win situation imo.

[Cranky Franky 2,061]

Most people are missing the point.

I want to know why our well paid list managers turn up to trading week & draft day without having the current players sorted - that means either signed on the dotted line, traded or delisted.

If CB didn't want to sign it should have been sorted out prior to the draft.

[e25 5]

Is it not clear?

CB deceived the football dept to get to his new club on the cheap.

He did what was in the best interests of the hawks, and by proxy, himself.

He had his eye on a move whilst games were still being played.

[Big Kev 369]

I am generally very happy with the Club but it needs a kick up the rear over the Bruce saga.

We were told the deal was done just a matter of finalising a few minor details. Well the deal was not done & CB walked.

Surely you need to have your list finalised BEFORE the trading period & the draft. There should have been a deadline of signing on well before the draft & trading.

If this had been sorted MAYBE we would have got a small token for releasing CB or MAYBE we would have kept Cheney or MAYBE we would have kept on Junior as insurance for another year.

Sloppy work by the Club. If I did the same thing in my job I would get the sack.

Sounds like someone just got their MFC jumper out of the drawer and realised there was a Number 32 on it.

[e25 5]

Nice

[DeeMfc 621]

Is it not clear?

CB deceived the football dept to get to his new club on the cheap.

He did what was in the best interests of the hawks, and by proxy, himself.

He had his eye on a move whilst games were still being played.

I tried the diplomatic response.....

I hope what e25 said is now clear enough for you cranky franky, cos it's as clear, true and frank as it gets !

Now lets move on and start fresh with the future on show on Sunday.

[H_T 3,047]

Most people are missing the point.

I want to know why our well paid list managers turn up to trading week & draft day without having the current players sorted - that means either signed on the dotted line, traded or delisted.

If CB didn't want to sign it should have been sorted out prior to the draft.

What e25 said. In addition, contracts expire Oct 31st. Even after trade week Bailey was confident (publicly) that Bruce would put pen to paper and train as good as he does every pre-season.

This has been discussed many times over and over last year ! The answers should already be in this thread and you can do a search for them in last years threads./