ST. KILDA IN STRIFE

[Range Rover 1,935]

There is a new Facebook page purporting to be hers.

My link

Questionable authenticity but there are a couple of pics of 'Kim' there.

[H_T 3,049]

Hotel in Miami is very simular to the photo with Saint shaven nick in it

Big holes are poping up in that young lady's story...........

You should work for Scotland Yard.

[Summer Blease 0]

Anyone want to PM me the link to these pics? I must be the only person in Australia who hasn't seen them yet. Yes that's right, I am publicly asking to view man penis.

In any case this girl is an attention seeking vengeful piece of work who is using every form of social networking medium there is to extract her "revenge"/get herself 15 minutes of fame and it just stinks. It is troubling to think that any mentally unstable (and if you have watched DA's link you would understand) person with a computer and Internet access can cause this much mayhem so quickly and easily.

WTF is with these stupid footballers also? Why can't they just play their sport, be good role models and NOT take naked photos? If you are in the public eye, don't do anything you don't want them to see. So simple.

[hardtack 10,627]

There is a new Facebook page purporting to be hers.

My link

Questionable authenticity but there are a couple of pics of 'Kim' there.

It's not purporting to be her page at all:

"A page for discussion surrounding Kim Isabella Duthie.

Kim is aware of this page and will quite possible be posting and responding on this page soon."

[Range Rover 1,935]

It's not purporting to be her page at all:

"A page for discussion surrounding Kim Isabella Duthie.

Kim is aware of this page and will quite possible be posting and responding on this page soon."

Corrected. The pics do appear to be her though.

Edited December 21, 2010 by Range Rover

[mordja 187]

HUN has a facebook conversation between Jane AKA Kim Duthie and "An AFL Player" which she has obviously fed them.

I cant find it online but its in the hard copy.

If she can prove who that is (one presumes it may be Gilbert) then it tells an interesting tale about the clubs culture etc as the player refers to it as "team bonding" or words to that effect.

Good luck living that down if she can authenticate it.

Edited December 21, 2010 by mordja

[gOLLy 401]

Anyone want to PM me the link to these pics? I must be the only person in Australia who hasn't seen them yet. Yes that's right, I am publicly asking to view man penis.

I just spat my coffee all over the screen in laughter from your post.

[gOLLy 401]

To think this is the Captian of the St Kilda Football Club.

[JJJ 1,313]

That's whack!

[WonnaJurah 5]

No need to comment after only watching first 5 secs and turning it off. Not doing herself any favours whatsoever.

me to , wonder what time the loony van will be at her house?

[H_T 3,049]

me to , wonder what time the loony van will be at her house?

What does that tell you about SG.

[45HG 1,559]

Some people just shouldn't write articles.

[Range Rover 1,935]

Some people just shouldn't write articles.

I think the questions that underpin that article have merit.

Why were these blokes taking nude, sexually charged photos of each other? And why were they stored on a laptop?

[The Big Ticket 94]

This from the age sums it up for me

"A child of the age of narcissism, using the uncontrolled medium of the age, acting out the age-old wrath of a woman scorned."

Couple of questions I have, how is Del Santo not getting any press? he has the more incriminating photo

Also, I have lost total respect for Nick R, not because of the photo or the whole sordid affair but because of the man gardening hes has done to his groinal region. Anyone who shaves their b@%%s is kinda wrong in my book!!

So what if he does some man-scaping? It's the norm these days.

And as for Dal Santo - he needs a PE.

[45HG 1,559]

I think the questions that underpin that article have merit.

Why were these blokes taking nude, sexually charged photos of each other? And why were they stored on a laptop?

Why is it anyone's business?

There's nothing illegal/sinister about them.

[Range Rover 1,935]

Why is it anyone's business?

There's nothing illegal/sinister about them.

No, there's nothing illegal or sinister about them. It's just a couple of mates in the nude taking happy snaps of each others' willies ...

[H_T 3,049]

And as for Dal Santo...

I hear he is going to be the face of the new Subway 3 inch Sub!

[Akum 2,660]

What does that tell you about SG.

The phrase "serious errors of judgment" doesn't even begin to cover it. He's the one who should bear the brunt of the criticism here - does an "AFL groupie" with serious issues, then dumps her when she claims to be pregnant; takes compromising photos of mates, and instead of deleting them he downloads them to his computer (god alone knows what he wants them on his computer for - he probably put them in a file on the desktop marked "embarrassing photos of teammates"). His serial stupidity has made life a lot harder for many others.

And if his computer is the source of the other photos yet to be published, he would know which players from other clubs are the potential future targets and will have told them already. Wouldn't he?

[Range Rover 1,935]

And if his computer is the source of the other photos yet to be published, he would know which players from other clubs are the potential future targets and will have told them already. Wouldn't he?

Those would be interesting conversations to listen to.

"Hey (Insert name of Carlton/Sydney/Melbourne player), I have some naked photos of you stored on my laptop, but they appear to have been stolen by a girl who might post them on the Internet. Just giving you a heads up."

[Keyser Söze 0]

Those would be interesting conversations to listen to.

"Hey (Insert name of Carlton/Sydney/Melbourne player), I have some naked photos of you stored on my laptop, but they appear to have been stolen by a girl who might post them on the Internet. Just giving you a heads up."

I think it would hard to know.

He won't likely have a folder marked "nude/embarrassing photos".

More likely he'd have albums of trips & events and within those certain photos would be... risqué.

The girl would go through and copy the ones worth using, or copied them all & gone through them later.

It all depends on what she deems to be a dodgy enough photo to release to be of any public interest.

I'm guessing she has used her big guns and the follow-ups, if there are any, will be more the ilk of guys running around tackling each other in their jocks. Gradually less severe.

[45HG 1,559]

No, there's nothing illegal or sinister about them. It's just a couple of mates in the nude taking happy snaps of each others' willies ...

Should I just copy-paste my previous post, or do you want me to write it out again for you?

[rpfc 28,779]

I think the questions that underpin that article have merit.

Why were these blokes taking nude, sexually charged photos of each other? And why were they stored on a laptop?

All valid questions.

For their wives, girlfriends, dads, and mums. No sisters or brothers! They don't get to ask those questions!

It's none of our concern, nor is it the AFL's or St Kilda's.

[Akum 2,660]

I think it would hard to know.

He won't likely have a folder marked "nude/embarrassing photos".

More likely he'd have albums of trips & events and within those certain photos would be... risqué.

The girl would go through and copy the ones worth using, or copied them all & gone through them later.

It all depends on what she deems to be a dodgy enough photo to release to be of any public interest.

I'm guessing she has used her big guns and the follow-ups, if there are any, will be more the ilk of guys running around tackling each other in their jocks. Gradually less severe.

Although it's the Saints who seem to be her primary target, so she's wanting to damage them the most. And she's quoted as saying the photos are of players doing drugs and pretending to have sex with each other. In other words, the pictures of players from other clubs may be at least as bad, it's just that she's more intent on damaging StK.

I'm assuming that the photos were all together in a very obvious place on his computer because she was able to download & e-mail 20 of them without anybody else knowing (it sounds like she had SG's permission to use his computer). Either that or she had a long enough time at his computer to search through who knows how many happy snaps and select the 20 or so that were going to create the most mayhem. Searching through them in enough detail to recognise faces etc. Either way, serious stupidity on SG's part, yet again.

Or else it's all bluff (but who's going to take that chance?) This may still have a long way to play out, if it indicates a broader problem across several clubs.

[Louie 39]

To think this is the Captian of the St Kilda Football Club.

I found it interesting when asked if "Saint Nick" was asked if he had spoken to SG and he replied that it was up to SG to approach him. Football clubs are no place of real leadership.

Nick is the captain and so-called leader of the aints. Wouldn't a true leader approach SG and smooth things over rather than let things fester. Just throwing it out there . . .

[Range Rover 1,935]

Should I just copy-paste my previous post, or do you want me to write it out again for you?

No need. I would only write the same response to it.

The article is not making a judgment call on homosexuality. It is merely pointing out that there is a seemingly taboo subtext to this whole story that is getting lost in all the hoo-ha about this silly 17yo girl.

And that taboo subtext is worth discussing, however unpalatable it may be to the conservative folk among us.