Demonland Player of the Year Round 18

[45HG 1,539]

If you have to rely on making things up with no basis, then i suppose you could claim anything

[Dee tention 611]

What about Paul Johnson?

I thought he played very well and has been our best big man all year!

[deestroy08 0]

Mark Jamar, I feel, is falling into the same basket as the Ben Hollands and the Simon Godfreys of the world.

He has all the effort but just lacks the skills to cut it as a good footballer who will really positively impact the future of our club.

Everytime I watch him play, I just think to myself that he seems like the kind of player who would miss a shot at goal from 10m out in front in a Grand Final and we'd end up losing by a point.

IMO He's not part of our future.. not a successful one anyway.

[tooly 0]

5- Morton

4- Bate

3- Sylvia

2- Wheatley

1- Jamar

[Doggo 32]

Jamar consistently does (make poor decisions) and it is a flaw. It would be a frustrating forum if everytime we have something to say about one player, we then have to trail through the other 43 players on our list comparing them all

Mark Jamar, I feel, is falling into the same basket as the Ben Hollands and the Simon Godfreys of the world.

He has all the effort but just lacks the skills to cut it as a good footballer who will really positively impact the future of our club

IMO He's not part of our future.. not a successful one anyway .

I've been saying this for years. Jamar can improve all he wants, but ruckwork aside, i dont think he'll ever be AFL-quality.

He has to be the most flawed footballer at our club IMO, if not in the whole league.

[Doggo 32]

6 - James McDonald

5 - Simon Buckley

4 - Cale Morton

3 - Matty Bate

2 - Addam Maric

1 - Mark Jamar (for all his flaws, i still gave him a vote. Beating Hille is no easy feat)

[chapter 2 0]

For anyone complaining about Jamar, i think we really have to look at the facts which are fairly simple.

essendon have led the league in clearances over the past month and yet with a midfield without potentially our 3 best midfielders in brock, jones and moloney we still, for some fairly lengthy patches, really dominated there. Now i admit this is not solely to the credit of Jamar and a consideable amount of respect has to be given to dunn for this, but our mids weren't on fire and many clearances were only gained due to jamar's aggresive tackling and and smart tap work.

For those of you ruing missed opportunities in the forward line the simple fact that Jamar gave us those opportunities was a cause for optimism - we can't expect him to kick 3 a game and if he gets a couple or even one it's a bonus. the fact that he gave us a marking presence there providing opportunities (realised or unrealised) that otherwise wouldn't have presened themselves was enough for me

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,166]

6 Jnr

5 Bate

4 Valenti

3 Morton

2 Sylvia

1 Jamar

[Maybe next year 167]

6 Morton (just wish he could improve his kicking to a player)

5 Bate

4 Sylvia (would have mnore votes if he tried in the 1st quarter)

3 McDonald

2 Garland

1 Valenti

[H_T 2,941]

6. J.McDonald - Very hard worker.

5. M.Bate - Stepped it up.

4. CJ - Consistent all day.

3. Buckley - Great first 3.

2. Sylvia - Some positive signs.

1. Maric - Some good touches. Couple of goals. Progressing well.

How on earth could you not give Morton votes? Did you actually attend the game?

Thats ridiculous............no hang on, ludicrous is more appropriate!

[Nasher 33,246]

Was at my one and only game for the year. Pity we lost.

My votes:

6. Bate

5. Morton

4. Sylvia (a couple of inexcusable mistakes stopped him from being 6 in my eyes)

3. Valenti

2. Buckley

1. (Raffle) Garland.

[_becks_ 35]

Mark Jamar, I feel, is falling into the same basket as the Ben Hollands and the Simon Godfreys of the world.

He has all the effort but just lacks the skills to cut it as a good footballer who will really positively impact the future of our club.

Everytime I watch him play, I just think to myself that he seems like the kind of player who would miss a shot at goal from 10m out in front in a Grand Final and we'd end up losing by a point.

IMO He's not part of our future.. not a successful one anyway.

I think you are right on the money Deestroy08.

[titan_uranus 23,235]

In case anyone cares:

6 - McDonald

5 - Bate

4 - Morton

3 - Sylvia

2 - Jamar

1 - Bruce (for negating Stanton)

A lot of peopel have Garland in their votes. I didn't really think he was one of our best on the weekend.

[H_T 2,941]

In case anyone cares:

6 - McDonald

5 - Bate

4 - Morton

3 - Sylvia

2 - Jamar

1 - Bruce (for negating Stanton)

A lot of peopel have Garland in their votes. I didn't really think he was one of our best on the weekend.

Yes Bruce deserved 1 vote. These 6 would have been mine - I may of swapped Bate and Morton around, but your on the money IMO.

[Demonland 66,975]

Brock McLean hasn't played for a while but still holds the lead:

78.366 Brock McLean

69.590 Brad Green

53.514 Brad Miller

44.698 Paul Wheatley

43.680 Colin Garland

42.742 Chris Johnson

40.082 Austin Wonaemirri

39.766 Paul Johnson

37.927 Matthew Bate

37.636 Cameron Bruce

33.297 Colin Sylvia

31.490 Aaron Davey

31.241 Cale Morton

29.347 Nathan Jones

24.063 James McDonald

21.411 Simon Buckley

17.896 Lynden Dunn

12.282 Brent Moloney

11.331 Shane Valenti

10.684 Jared Rivers

10.482 Nathan Carroll

10.346 Matthew Warnock

8.217 Stef Martin

8.132 Clint Bartram

5.904 Matthew Whelan

5.265 Russell Robertson

5.164 Mark Jamar

5.087 Jeff White

2.845 Adem Yze

0.871 Addam Maric