Roger Mellie

Reminiscent of any of our efforts against a bottom side. We stood in the mirror while the toiges came to play. We will never farkin learn. Dead set same as playing Carlton. I'm very clear in my mind about who came to play for the MFC. On the subject of Petterd...Did anyone see him take an unpaid spekky in the last with about 10 mis to go...in the goal square?

Really? Can you elaborate on this?

Petterd: Ricky Bobby Frawley: Chip

Bell - Didak to bench Ward - unusually hit targets PJ - Better than White White - Down on confidence Jones - Leaps and bounds Holland - The Gorilla Keeper Frawley - Would prefer Warnock (but that will change in time) Chook - Gun at 70% fitness Rocca - Threw in towel

Dud

Excluding Clint, the ladies and the spunk (apparently Mick) who are all the crooks in the photo?

At least we wont go into the game (yet again) presuming a win

Maybe just his groin!

I thought there were plenty of positives too: Jones showed plenty Bate had a great game, with scope for a truck load of improvement Nietz gave a target and, apart from being robbed, made an impact when not expected Johnson, in the limited game time found the footy. Rucking needs work though Sylvia is starting to look like he he belongs and with luck, there might be a bit of magic down the track Yze laid some tackles Petterd - love his attitude, aggression and work ethic TJ had a better game Bell, did his job and looks better and better with each game Brown's attack was inspiring Rivers is still a gun Godders shut out Burgoyne White found the footy, but needs to move it Warnock did a couple of nice things and one horrible thing. Great goal Carroll had a much improved game The boys again had a dip. The outcome was shattering, dodgy umpiring and all, but they came to play and we're moving forward.

I think there has been a marked improvement on last year. He has much better awareness and maturity. I hope his groin grief is overcome so we can see if he is midfield material

Davey should be fine. Not a patch on what Goodes did and in play. The Pickett tackle should not even be looked at. Cornes hit his head against the ground FFS.

You've got Garland on the bench and in the outs. Ward - apart from being ordinary, is injured Godfrey on the wing is scarey

Jamar - Back to Sandy (permanently) Petterd - well done son Garland - not quite yet

Is Weetra injured again?

Is Liddell (in the reserves) Chad's brother?

+ve our first win last year was a slog against the swans (if I recall correctly) Paul WIlliams will give us excellent insight into the swannies game plan if we improve on last week, who knows I may be in a time warp, but thought Buchanan was injured??? Jolly is still crap looking forward to seeing the first gamers -ve we'll get murdered in the midfield which will make it hard for the backline to stand up we're still slow the less said the better

Selection Committee = Daniher, P Williams, Riley and Curran. Danners has the final say.

The problem is (just like last year) - we have a good preseason and expect to do well. - we forget (AGAIN) the level of hard work and commitment that is required and assume it will all happen - we wax lyrical about the classy, skilled players we have on the list - we then wonder why we are the turnover kings when we have Ward, Brown, Godfrey, Bruce (yes Bruce) and Miller in the side (amongst others) - we get murdered in the middle, murdered in the ruck - we panic and cough it up - we give away undisciplined frees - 6 GOALS TO HAWKS FROM FREES ALONE............................Helloooo! The most depressing thing is, if our list played like Brisbane, we would be the team to beat, premiership contenders!

I must have been at a different game than most of you: Bruce - a liability today Bell - solid effort today Miller - better show today Bate - half paced butter-fingers Godfrey - battled on typically Ward - His opponent was? Jamar - slow reaction time Jamar - misses the boat When we were down by 6 goals, the only player running and tackling hard was TJ

Out: McLean (inj) Miller, Davey, Jamar, Bartram (underdone), Ward, Bell, Yze, Bate In: Rivers, Pickett ummm

I've got no problems with backwards handball so long as the player is NOT stationary/flat-footed/clueless about the game play

He may be a beautiful kick, but how does a skirt like Aaron Fiora run around on his own all night. :angry:

I'm nervous about Holland. Gehrig dacked him last game (final) but fortunately we could switch him on to peg leg Hamill. No Hamill, no slow codgers...who does he play on????? Kosi's too fast but Holland would be competitive one out. Blake too mobile? Clarke will stay in the ruck, and Rix off the bench, will be too busy getting a belting by White/Jamar. I dont like Miller down back (or forward for that matter) The drive from the backline looks to come from wayward Ward, Whelan (champ), Bell the Worrier/Warrior and the occasional line breaker from lollipops Carroll. The backline makes me nervous. The midfield, forward line (apart from Robbo at CHF - although doubt it will stick), interchange bench and the saints line up, on the other hand, makes me hugely excited! Go Demons

Yes

# The dog is easier on the eye, nose and has less fleas too