CatFishPig

From Herald Sun.. I'm seriously hoping we are into him and he slips to pick 40.. Will Dayle Garlett get drafted? Earlier in the year, it was a resounding yes, but clubs remain nervous about drafting the silky midfield-forward from WA. On talent, he might be top-15. A smooth-moving outside runner who has shades of Harley Bennell, kicking almost 50 goals in the WAFL seniors this year. But defensively he can be poor and many clubs, such as West Coast, have again put a line through his name. In our view, he is worth taking the chance, at a strong club, with a late pick. There will be lots of busts from this year's draft. His best chance might be at Geelong or Hawthorn.

Didak can drive them all around in a mini van...

I'd be very surprised if Garlett doesn't get picked up this year.. I'll actually be upset if he is still available in the PSD and we don't take him. Kid can play..

Like all this, Strauss has all the tools, just needs to get a good run at it with injuries..

Where are they saying Dayle Garlett will go? He would be a fantastic get if still available at 40..

Hogan will win 6-8 games off his own boot.. So I expect us to finish with about 6-8 wins..

It's driving me crazy

Living on hope.. But its likely GWS will have another year where they manage under 4 wins, and unlikely they have a breakout year like the Gold Coast just have.. I wonder how many of Dom's buddies at GWS might become tired of losing and want to return home? If the Dees' can turn the corner this year and win more game, we could be looking like a pretty prospect. Let's hope they think about coming back and playing with their old mate Dom...

Could we possibly get Shiel and Buntine or Bugg for pick 2? They can keep 9.. I hope we play hard ball, seems like GWS really want pick 2.

Look at the positive here, if Bugg is good mates with Shiel.. We take Bugg, Buntine and pick 9 now. Then next year when Bugg talks about how good it is back in Melbourne, Shiel is coming out of contract and nominates Melbourne as his preferred club of choice. And we offer him a large amount of cash.. Question, when is Shiel contracted til??

This thread is killing me.. I keep coming back thinking good news, only to find dribble..

What are we giving up?

Only Beams or Sidebottom and pick 10 for pick 2..

This guy sounds like a bit of a [censored].. But all I want is for him to get the ball.. Bring him on board..

we should be the ones developing them.. Can we just all sit back and relax. Let Roo's get in between there ears and see if he can make them footballers. If not move them on.. At least give the talent they have a year under him please??

This rumour has no merit, he would be unrestricted like Sylvia if he wasn't contracted. Walker is going nowhere...

Do you think a new coach might put certain players on the 'trade table' with no intentions of trading them.. With the intention to click them into gear and hopefully ignite the drive to become much better players than they currently are? This is what I'm hoping for.. We need both of these guys to lift their output dramatically.. I hope Paul can get this out of them..

I understood that clearly. Sorry, I was playing with the emotions of that actually being a realistic outcome..

That would teach them good and proper.

Can rule out the Hawks, Big Boy McEvoy is headed there.. I can't understand the Saints, they have cooked it.. http://www.saints.com.au/news/2013-10-10/saints-get-firstround-pick-and-savage-for-mcevoy He is coming into his prime, will be close to best in the comp next year now he is at the Hawks.. Saints, odds for the spoon??

Yes Nasher, unfortunately that is the case. Maybe in this instance they could just not do the trade, and if he doesn't re-sign, pick him up in the PSD??

GWS should play hardball and find the best trade. They should be dictated by the players club of choice. In the Adams situation. GWS should go with the best offer on the table from any club. They need to make a stand and not allow these kids to dictate where they go or it will send a message to the rest of the playing group that we will send you home to your club of choice if you desire.

Where has this come from?

So Mummy is off to GWS, people can finally stop putting Jamar in their trade scenarios.

Well said..