spirit of norm smith
Annual Member
-
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by spirit of norm smith
-
Ouch. I’d say more Josh Kelly like… and we don’t have one of him. -
It will be interesting. Smillie is now the wildcard pick given he’s slipped down most of the media predictions for top 5. Was certainly equal 1st with Jagga Smith as the start of the year. As I put in another thread, he’s defensive side got exposed at the championships and he didn’t show his true capabilities. But he has very good skills, wins contested footy, kicks goals, kicks it 50-60 easily and has that 5-10 metre burst needed in the midfield. He could be an absolute elite player. At 194cms, he’s a “Cripps” like type of player.
-
@Nascent agree … presumably Tigers take Lalor at 1, then think Dees will choose Langford at “5” (or vice versa) Tigers could then also get Smith at “6”. Might see Kangas try to split 2 to get say 6 & 14 off the Tigers. Tigers could then guarantee themselves Lalor & Smith and a huge PR exercise with picks 1,2 draft combination. Kangas could get Tauru at 6 and get another player like Shanahan at 14. Fixes their key back and key forward outlook in one swoop.
-
Oliver to Geelong in 2025 trading. AFL media bottom feeders will run this story for the next 12 months. It’s the bushfire that won’t go out !!!
-
At 9, hope for either Lindsay, Travaglia or Tauru. Each are also very special youngsters with definite AFL quality futures. Each would also be ready for AFL in 2025. Josh Smillie is an absolute wildcard for me. I’d be doubtful if he gets past the Saints. At start of the year, he was a possible number 1. His form was generally very good and he dominated Coates league footy. But his championships games were average and I think clubs saw his defensive skills as lacking. But his talent is undeniable. 194cms big and strong and good burst across first 5 metres. Kicks it 50-60 metres easily. His centre clearance work is Cripps like. Whoever gets him and then puts the necessary extra physical conditioning into him, could get an absolute steal and a future great.
Dees should hold at 5 & 9 at 5, it’s about who slides, it should be either Lalor, Langford, O’Sullivan, Smith or Draper. Tigers at 1 have to choose between Smith, Lalor or Langford. I think Blues will want O’Sullivan and Crows will grab Draper. So it’s probably out of Smith, Lalor or Langford option. All have excellent futures ahead with exceptional talent. at 9, hope for either Lindsay, Travaglia or Tauru. Each are also very special youngsters with definite AFL quality futures. Each would also be ready for AFL in 2025. Josh Smillie is an absolute wildcard for me. At start of the year, he was a possible number 1. His form was generally very good and he dominated Coates league footy. But his championships games were average and I think clubs saw his defensive skills as lacking. But his talent is undeniable. 194cms big and strong and good burst across first 5 metres. Kicks it 50-60 metres easily. His centre clearance work is Cripps like. Whoever gets him and then puts the necessary extra physical conditioning into him, could get an absolute steal and a future great.
Sounds like he is off to West Coast. Part of the mega deal for the Blues to land pick 3 and try to grab Finn O’Sullivan.
So many options at pick 5 and pick 9. The top 15 “available”. are very good quality , being mostly midfielders but also taller types like Armstrong, Trainor, Tauru and Shanahan. Sam Lalor- GWV. mid/utility Finn O'Sullivan - Oakleigh. mid/utility Harvey Langford- Dandenong. tall mid Sid Draper - Sth Adel. mid Jagga Smith - Oakleigh. Mid. Xavier Lindsay - Gippsland. mid/hbf Josh Smillie - Eastern. Tall mid. Tobe Travaglia - Bendigo. Running mid/hbf. Murphy Reid - Sandringham. Mid. Taj Hotton - Sandringham. Mid/hff Bo Allan - WA. Mid Luke Trainor -Sandringham.⭐️ Tall fwd/back Alix Tauru - Gippsland. tall fwd/back Harry Armstrong - Sandringham. Key fwd Jobe Shanahan - Bendigo (NSW) . Key fwd
Confirmed outs: Alex Neal-Bullen (Traded to Adelaide pick 28) Angus Brayshaw (Retired) Ben Brown (Retired) Lachie Hunter (Retired) Josh Schache (Delisted) Kyah Farris-White (Delisted) Future First (Traded to Essendon) Future Third (Traded to Adelaide) Picks 40, 54, 65 (Traded to Essendon) Pick 28 (from Adelaide, to Essendon) Pick 46 (from Adelaide, to Essendon) Confirmed ins: Tom Campbell (Delisted Free Agent from St Kilda) Pick 9 (Traded from Essendon) Future Third (Traded from Essendon) Draft 5,9,49,83
“No no no”… I’m running… “I said no” Hayes … definitely a No
wtf. Suns are crazy at trading. Why do the Pies get Houston for a future 1st and Noble. That’s it??? Wow.
Just note that whilst I’m a big supporter of JT, low draft picks does not guarantee success. Getting 5 & 9 should add two high quality youngsters. It was true for 2021, and in the future , you need the combination of drafting 1st round draftees, wise trades, attracting the right players from other clubs and development of others within the group.
Hope Dees retain list spots to get 4 draftees in this years pool. Super deep and lots of ready to go young talent. Given we have 5&9 and have purged other picks, our two later picks might be in the deep 60s. But there’s still talent. An example is in SA. Woodville-West Torrens U18 captain Jett Hasting was very good in the SA colts grand final (under 18s). Best on ground. I saw him also in the National championships and his run and carry and burst gave him similarities to the Trent Rivers. Endurance is good. Won the SA state coming2km time trial in 6min29secs. Skills are good. Has the pace and composure to be a AFL footballer imv. Probably a rookie pick but shows the quality late in the draft pool.
Any news? Heard this was progressing quickly on Friday morning. I guess the bombers and crows pick swapping has taken the priority Sharp is the third player to potentially nominate the Dees now. 1st … Houston … did he really nominate us? Well the media said he did, so that’s a given. But he’s yes, no , yes has brought out other suitors and MFC off limits 🤮 2nd… Derksen… nominated MFC, Dees very keen and it helps his career, his financials and his family. GWS lost too many players and had poured concrete over Derksen. FFS. 🤨🤨 Hope we can do this deal. He’s the type of player needed and type of trade (22yo, 4 years in system) that can come in straight away and still improve and improve
Yes agree it’s a reminder of the Mahoney days. Good smart trading of picks to move up the order. No complaints. Let’s JT weave some magic. Just to be clear, the call out that was frustrating was the recruitment of players like Schache (and his extension), McAdam and Billings. The extension for Laurie for a further 2 years was highly questionable.
Yes I think both would be handy but we are unlikely to have any picks in the suitable range. Ough showed such improvement that he’s likely to be picked at 35-40 and Boxshall at 50-55.
Love this. Really want us to get Sharp. The deal could be MFC 49 for Sharp & BL 66. Gives Lions extra 200 points for Academy bids while leaves us with a third pick still.
That’s a great get. Dees can use 5&9, and then see if theirs is still rated youngsters left at the end of the draft. There is typically good youngsters left who need to be given a chance. Other delisted free agents might be worth grabbing such as Parfitt.
That was super courageous. Tough win away from home. 3 1/2 day break. Saints are a good team. Our contested footy to win clearances was critical. Like to see more “getting territory” footy though with less handball like we did v crows votes. 6 McNamara 💙❤️ 5 Heath 💙❤️ 4 Hanks 💙❤️ 3 Hore 💙❤️ 2 Goldrick 💙❤️that goal in the 2nd quarter was special 1 Chaplin 💙❤️ Georgia Campbell 👏👏ruck work to compete and kick a nice goal Georgia Gall👏👏be strong at the contest in the absence of Pearce and Harris, great to see GC and GG stand up again Get the pen out to sign up extensions please.
Pick 46 will not even get the chance to open its locker. Likely off to the Dons or Lions in the swap frenzy
Give us pick 9… sell sell sell all those picks
2024 squad = 45. 😭ANB (crows) BBB (⏰)Gus (med ret) , Hunter (⏰) JS29, KFW, Schache. Tomlinson likely to go. 8 off the list. Down to 37 ??? Marty Hore??? Staying or delisted???Likely to stay with Tomlinson going. Add in Campbell and Sharp*, plus potentially another DFA (Parfitt?). Add in 4 in the draft (and leave room for Mentha as a cat B rookie).
