Grimseyisgod

disagree, when Melbourne has played Collingwood in the past when they didnt have Daisy Thomas and Dane Swan, he picked up something like 39 possies. He would still be in Melbournes best players

What about Wellingham?? he is a gun and a proven one, we can get him

people. Pick 4 plus Morton.. i do not think we have any opportunity to get him. It is wroth alot of money and good picks, but good luck.. no chance in my opinion

Clinton Young would be an amazing pickup, i said that even before a month ago. we should offer him 4 years, 300k a year.. its worth it

yeah youre right, but i doubt Salopek will be delisted?

there is potential with Salopek

There really arent many players i want, only a couple.. Sharrod Wellingham Chris Knights Josh Caddy Brendon Goddard Travis Cloke there are a couple of others that are good

how could anyone actually want to get Gumbleton. He is a joke.

sure he played well against the bombers, but one good game doesnt make you a good player. Nick Davis? whatd he ever do other than vs Geelong

Garland is beyond overrated. He has little to no football brain. Anyone remember his soccer off the ground against Port in a crucial moment, people with a football brain dont do that

I love how people automatically hear things that are not confirmed and put it all out there. Garland is going nowhere... Melbourne would also like Joel Selwood.. some one make a thread about that

you have made some pretty good points. But honestly, Gold Coast will not settle for just pick 13, we would need to give pettard and pick 13 for that. Weller would be a good pickup, but so would Josh Toy which you havent included. Wellingham could be a potentially a good pickup, but personally i think we should make a big play for Tippet, the least you can do is offer him. Also Watts needs to be included in your core group, Watts has actually become underated, the form he showed this year before he got injured is something that all Melbourne supporters should be excited about, he was as good as Goddard. If Melbourne decide they want him, Grundy will be at the Dees next year. The draft players id like to see at Melbourne next year would be: Toumpas, Grundy, Jack Viney.. I wouldnt actually mind trading the rest of our picks. Pick 13: trade for Wellingham. I would personally go: Stefan Martin and pick 13 for Sharrod Wellingham and Collingwood 4th round pick

I think in the defence we actually arent that bad. Weve got Tom Mcdonald, Frawley, Garland, Watts, Nicho, Grimes can be defence, Rivers is probably going to go. So maybe we need 1 or 2 new defenders. midfielders can argue with that. we do need 2-3 new guns., not average players, guns. Forwards: bit harsh to say 3, i think the forward line is where we arent too bad. Howe, potentially Watts, Sylvia, Clarke, blease, tappas. we arent that bad, just lacking some guns

there are some ridiculously good possible pick up this year from the draft. what about Jay Van berlo, he looked like a really good player and clearly doesnt fit in. Brodie Moles, James Magner like. Wellingham has now denied interest, but i think its bullocks as no offer is yet to be made.

Honestly, in my opinion we will get Wellingham. We will offer picks/ players and plenty of money. It would be crazy to say Melbourne wouldnt be a chance to get him.

Ohhh i think its one of those things that is just "known", that Neeld is a tough guy and clearly did a very very good job with the Collingwood membership

yeah but quite honestly players come to clubs because the club is going for finals and a premiership, lets be honest.. we arent one yet

hahahahahahaha

yeah to be honest we arent an attractive destination but in the end it can become one

you make good points, very intelligent. Melbourne isnt an attractive destination, but you can make it attractive with picks and $ Brynes doesnt excite me either. Gumby and Edwards are horrible

yeah sure you can say that and thats fair, but that is probably because we havent made offers as of yet. realistically we can get Wellingham, Brynes, wed need to make a good offer for Knights, Edwards is crap so is Gumby.

wellingham for martin wont happen unless we give up martin plus pick 13. Wellingham is a star. I reckon Josh Toy would be good, so would Caddy.. What would you give up for caddy?

Honestly, we have no ideea what the the situation with Viney will be.

than again, last year we were not expecting (as supporters) to land a big fish, and we landed a huge one

Reimers is horrible. I still think there are good trades possible and free agents. I trust Neeld, with Clark last year and Sellar (who actually wasnt that bad).. weve done well