Lucifers Hero

Videos of frees paid against Max and Paddy in this http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-08-23/strapped-up-to-the-max-dees-unique-training-technique Paddy's arm looked bent and Max either puts his arm out or gets a knee in the ribs or in the head... The article confirms that clubs have complained to the umpires department. And: "It is also believed some clubs are becoming increasingly frustrated that certain players, who they believe are utilising straight-arm blocks in ruck contests are not being penalised as heavily as others". I guess mfc and Port are the ones getting frustrated! As long as umpires are consistent. My fear is that umpires are watching certain ruckman and will ping them. Not good in finals - there are too many umpiring biases already. In the article, Max confirms he is wearing a sling like device at training.

I think so. Recently, Jason Taylor described Hannan as an 'impact' player. He also has a nice side step and is one of the more composed players on our forward line. On average he kicks 1 goal per game. In terms of role, Harmes is playing upfield a bit when Watts is not in the team. With Watts back its harder to find a role for him. Lastly, Hannan played in a winning VFL team last year. So he has finals experience, albeit not at AFL. Harmes would be stiff to miss out...but I would prefer Hannan...just my thoughts...

Hope you are right re Watts and Salem. It is time to settle the team. And we need to maximise our chances of winning this week. I wouldn't be surprised if Tyson went out. He could then have two weeks at Casey and come back for the Elim. If it isn't Tyson for Viney, I think the most likely would be Harmes. A bit stiff for him but he isn't consistent enough to be in our best 22 when the rest are up and about. Crikey, if we make the finals there will be some disappointed players.

Yeah, I like Eddie. He has been good for football despite his bloopers. Now his passion for his club is blinding him to what really benefits his club. As an update: https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/revealed-pies-secret-blueprint-for-future-success-including-revamped-footy-department/news-story/c36d3fcbf1915621d970e6a0456e0779 If its true that Ch7 were able to film thru a boardroom window it is mind-boggling incompetent by Collingwood. On the list of things to fix is: "Improving specific areas of Collingwood’s game, including kicking skills, goal kicking, tackling and ruck work". One wonders what Buckley and co have been doing for 6 years. They should let him go.

Their demise since 2011 has been Melbourne-esque. Every part of their club has slowly become a rabble. Recruiting: wasted top draft picks on poor choices (Freeman, Kennedy) and 'young stars' (Treloar, Adams, WH-E, Aish). Then burdened themselves with ageing, injury prone and expensive list cloggers. Football Ops: Revolving door of Football Managers and Directors with Walsh, Eade, Balme, Gubby, Walsh Admin: Long standing favourite son CEO gone. Now looking at Lethlean who has no experience at club level President: Keeps finding new ways of embarrassing himself and his club with ignorant comments. Team: Has a few smart alec players who think they deserve to be playing finals because they work hard. Have yet to learn the meaning of 'Team' or what their game plan is. Coach: Has surrounded himself with buddies and can't develop or communicate a decent game plan. Saved only because of love child status with Eddie. They are deluding themselves if they think a bit of tweaking here and there will get them out of the quagmire. They are in for more pain before they realise they need to do a proper list rebuild ala Demons (WB and Carlton) but as usual they want the quick fix to buy their way back up the ladder. I like Eddie but he is blinded by his passion for his club. Popcorn time!

On Talking Footy and FC last night they talked about other clubs complaining about Max's technique - Redleg posted that he heard similar last week. This week Ryder was in the umpire's gun. I would dearly love to know which club(s) did the complaining. Probably a top 8 club(s) trying to put them off their game before finals. Altho I wouldn't put it past Carlton given the ethics of their doctors and their snidey coach.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-08-22/blues-land-exhawk-in-offfield-coaching-coup The years with Clarkson give him a good grounding. Why he would want to join Bolton eludes me. Hawks didn't waste any time replacing him as they have employed Glass to replace him. So sounds like it has been in the pipeline for a while. Was once my favourite player. Wish him well.

That is one very happy man!

Apparently Port didn't read the memo about ruckman 'straight arm blocking' as Paddy also gave away 5 frees on Saturday! https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/max-tax-the-ridiculous-ruck-rule-set-to-impact-paddy-ryder/news-story/ac5459c91203b1bd694b77cb66dc34ff David King is talking sense on this one: “(Paddy) is not really disrupting the opposition ruckman. He’s hanging his arm out, but he’s not really pushing. It’s a protection mechanism and a balancing action.” And amusingly and disturbingly he says: “We saw Max Gawn at training last week and he had his arm in a sling. It is bizarre when last year's AA ruckman and this years main contender are being penalised for a techinque infringement that has never happened before. Umpires should enforce the rules, not change the interpretation 2 weeks from finals against 2 of the premier ruckman. Just ridiculous.

Jesse selected in the Team of the Week. http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-08-22/team-of-the-week-r22-did-we-get-it-right A richly deserved reward!

Sad to hear Fitzy is retiring due to concussion issues. http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-08-21/concussion-forces-hawk-jack-fitzpatrick-to-retire-at-26 I recall he was much maligned for his 'tunnel ball' but thought he more than compensated for that when he kicked the winning goal to get the Hawks into the final four last year. Always did his best for the Dees. Good luck Fitzy.

Lever quits his Adelaide radio show spot. http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-08-21/lever-pulls-out-of-regular-radio-spot Sure sign he is leaving the Crows. Seems down to a two horse race: Dees and Pies. Given the pies don't know who their coach will be and its list is all over the shop, it is hard to see they have the nod. Conclusion: It must be the Dees...!

Post game Goodwin said Jesse, while recovering had worked hard on how he plays the game. So, I watched the replay and noticed that his run up is much straighter with only a little hop. I also noticed he didn't sook to the umpires when interfered with and was less frustrated. He also had more second efforts and ground ball work. Those are great signs of a maturing player. Maybe it is getting older, maybe it is the challenges thrown at him this year. Perhaps both. With this maturity on and off the field he will be so much more dangerous and is on the verge of fulfilling his potential.

He has had his right shoulder strapped in every game since he made his comeback vs Carlton. Pic from the North game when he did the collarbone on the left side.

In the article he also says: "When I did it (broke the collarbone) I thought it was like a 12-week injury and I was pretty flat," Hogan said. I saw the surgeon the next day and he basically said, 'You'll be running in four days, playing in two weeks', which kind of surprised me...He (Oppy) happened to be a Dees supporter as well, so he was pretty keen to get me back out there." 'Oppy' deserves a medal for giving Jesse the motivation to work hard and get back, which he did in very fine fashion. Two milestones for Jesse yesterday: Played his 50th game and kicked his 100th goal. In every way a great day for him.

I noticed that the table in yesterday's post has disappeared so here it is again. As an aside, has the 'Edit' button disappeared for other posters or is it just my browser playing up? Edit: Image deleted

Picture of the North game when it was injured Checked videos it was first strapped in his comeback game vs Carlton.

Yes, I noticed. He has had his right shoulder strapped since he came back from cancer surgery.

Best outcome is Rich at the G. It is very possible. StK thrashed Rich by 11 goals 5 weeks ago and they will desperate to give Nick a big farewell. They can do it again. If Port and Syd beat Suns and Carl as expected, whoever has the biggest win will be 4th and Rich will be 6th. To improve our chances to play them at the G we need the biggest possible win vs Pies making it hard for Ess to end up 7th. Places still wide open.

Favouritism. Ess in the finals is this years AFL feel good story like WB were last year. Watch Ess get all the favourable rest breaks like WB did last year. The AFL will do over every team except GWS to help Ess go deep into the finals. As I noted in the post above, Ess will be able to position themselves to avoid playing Syd in the prelim. The AFL will do the rest.

That virtually guarantees Ess a place in the finals!!

Even if we win, a heap of other games will determine where we finish. In order of time played: Syd vs Carlton. Port vs Suns. Ess vs Freo. Rich vs StK. Assuming we win Demons/Ess will finish 7th/8th. But Ess will know the results of most other games so they will know the exact score they need to avoid meeting Sydney in the Elim final. They will milk that advantage for all it is worth. All we can do is go out and win and play our best and que sera sera. But we will need to wait till this time next Sunday to know who we play in the Elim (if we get there). It will be a very long weekend.

I'm glad we won. But that was nothing like an even game by 22 players. At least 6 of our players had no impact at all. It bodes well for improvement but not sustainable if we want to get some real finals action. Hibberd was virtually our only really effective defender. Jetta was ok today but Wagner and the Mcdonalds were poor. Hopefully it is just a bad day and they all bounce back next week. Along with Hannan, Garlett and Gawn.

Wheeeeeewwwwwwwwwwww!! Got out of jail. Will take it. We have work to do to go deep into September. Great return game by Jesse!

Jesse Hogan! Everyone who has doubted him or wanted to trade him, hang your head. All year he’s been Resilient and Courageous. Today he was Inspirational. A terrific 50th game from him. Virtually won the game from his own boot. 6 goals. Welcome back, Jesse.