rjay

Pretty much all footy commentary is reactionary and short term. Gary is the epitome of this type of commentary and it's why I take little notice of what he says. I didn't hear Leppitsch this week but he usually has a better take. I do agree with '@JimmyGadson' above...if we bring the heat so far we've come out on top. Let's see what happens over the rest of the season. I'm not buying into mist...red or otherwise.

I don't think it's going to be an issue... The Hawks are desperate to get Clarkson out and the Pies are desperate to get him in. Something will happen in that space before we get to finals. Kennett needs to let the cash meet his mouth...

Looked like he picked up an injury at the end of the Casey game...so maybe that's a reason. edit...Although I note that he is listed in the emergencies so maybe not a reason...who knows.

No, you would have to go on the last fully completed round...

Thanks for posting 'demonstone'. I've got the play in book form of this and was just thinking of it as well. Must dig it out again and have a read.

If the game gets cancelled then I think maybe the team that's highest on the ladder should get the 4 points.

Same 'Colin'...we would feel robbed of the true experience.

Call the season off now and give the premiership to the team that's on top...

No Gadds, Purdies or Porcaros on AFL lists let alone a Modeliste...

Some good comments in that bunch, but I think this is the pick...

Tracc was great the other night but it was also great to see Clarry back to his one touch brilliance...hitting the ball at speed, puts the hand down and takes the ball so cleanly. He's had a great year but I think he's coming back up to another level as we head to finals...

Would love to go but honestly would love it more if we won...

It's just the way it is now unfortunately. I think the value of an MCC membership has diminished over the last number of years anyway. Despite what the Prez says in the letter, the only real value in an MCC membership is going to games including finals. I used to like walking up to any game. Even pre Covid it was getting harder to do unless I stood, which I tended to do more of.

I do 'Kent'... When he said that you should never listen to coaches when they are talking the good of the game. It's always in self interest. I thought on this occassion he was spot on.

Here's a thought. We either get him or we don't... The whole academy thing apart from the Northern states has been a complete stuff up by the AFL. Again it's Gill and co trying to please all the clubs. Should have been left with the Northern clubs only as that makes some sense but only if the zones are tight and not fluent and encroaching on AFL heart lands like Southern NSW and the NT... The Dogs were lucky to get a break with this one. Can't worry too much about what we haven't got.

Harmes had a shocker and he knew it...head was down just before 3Q time and his teammates tried to rally him. I hope he can turn it around this week...one more shot at it I reckon but need to take first options. Sometimes thinks he's Dusty.

Just hanging in by the old boys network skin of his teeth... A throw back to Sam Newman model of special comments person. Tell it like it is...hardly, he has no idea what it is he's watching.

This is quite good...

Petty - his breakout game

Ha, ha, ha, ha ....the Goody haters got to hate. How dumb do you all look tonight??? No need to name names, you know who you are.... Hahahahahahahahahahahaahah. Moronic posts over the last few weeks. The season is long, we were always going to have a down period. Hahahahahahahaha

Yep...and when the bully boy gets on his high horse you know that's closer to the truth than he would like people to know.

You can almost guarantee that Clarkson will announce he is stepping down next week and his last game as coach will be v us at the MCG round 18. Sorry, been reading too much of the Demonland pessimist posts....sack everyone.

If he goes he goes...he's not the messiah, just part of a good coaching group with us. We look to someone else. For the life of me I never understand how we over blow someones achievements to be almost god like when they are just doing a good job. There will always be someone else around who can do a good or better job. Just not the same...cut and paste this to the Burgess thread or anyone else on the way out.

Yeah, I'm with you here 'bin'...it's not mental exhaustion. We've hit a brick wall and that points to heavy training loads. You could see it with Max going back to the Pies game on...he's just not covering the same ground. I'm not talking about a skinny kid or ageing veteran, I'm talking about a player in his prime. We could be way off the mark 'bin' but as I said to old mate 'Kent' of the sack Goodwin brigade, the next few weeks will tell the story.

No, but kids add energy to the mix and we have been lacking energy recently. That fact that he is an excellent decision maker and kick won't go astray.