Bossdog

Carlton could only give the draft picks that they had (plus players to WCE) otherwise Judd could have gone into the draft as an uncontracted player putting a price on his head (like Ball) and WCE would have lost him for nothing. They did the best deal they could have.

I like the training reports, they keep us who(or should it be whom?)cannot get there, up to date. I do not take peoples take on training as gosspel but I like to read who is doing what. Keep it up lads.

I hate to say this BUT I think Scully will be a better player than Martin (hiding under the bedcovers now)

Did you see Martins post draft photos Seemed a very unhappy lad

All very well in hindsight. Trengove and scully were 1 and 2 and the whole football world knew it

Anyone know what "the issues"are or were????

They might get good players. But where is the support going to come from. Sydney swans took nearly 20 years???? I'll be dead by then

Not saying that he doesn't have to get better WYL just want people to understand that it is a tough game we play and despite some appearances they are all trying to get better. Just don't need the contant degrading comments (not you) that appear on this site.

I don't think it can survive, its not like the GC where there is interest and would be a great place to live. It is Western Sydney where there is no interest, a large number of new Australians who either love soccer or rugby(both codes)or other games from their home land. The AFL will eventually run out of money to promote this club.

I don't think it is tough to sit in the grandstand and bag our players or sit in the comfort of your study and bag them on a supporters site, they are human and as such have faults. Just re watched last years prelim (Haw vs Coll) So many mistakes, so many missed kicks and so many missed shots for goal, yet all players were launded for such a great game. I see the faults but I also see the effort and the direction we are striving for without calling for player's heads. If all of the players that this site bagged were culled, we wouldn't have a team.

I agree with you Stu. So many people on here bag our players. Our supporters are gettin like Richmond members. Eating their own

Jamar to Beamer then out of the centre Happened so many times last year. Did everyone forget???

The whole of GWS is a mess. Not even played a game yet and sacked it's CEO, cannot get a ground to train on, cannot house players without paying huge ammonts to set up Breakfast Point . A senior coach that hasn't coached for four years and is over 60 years old and contracted for this year only. Their senior players are all over 32 years old and most would have retired if not for the money. This venture by the AFL is doomed and after millions of dollars wasted GWS will not survive.

Just that I think he is important to our forward line and until others pass him in performance he would be a monty to stay I think(notsure) he is contracted for 2013

I would back Petterd against Dunn, Bate,Cook going on last years form(which is all I can go on) Tapscott injured, Sellar unproven???McDonald unproven

Thats all fine until injury/poor form hits. Need all these players

Must average more than his 5 diposals (past two years)per game Just does not get it enough for me.

Good to see "Neita" handing a few out. It's a tough old game ours

Sorry. Not a fan, makes us look a bit childish

Ta

Why is Grimes in the rehab group Anyone know?????

Or Alcohol

Do they still make "Bex"?????

Me too Old Dee but it will not be the end of the world. What I was trying to say is that I expect the game plan will take a few rounds to be understood and complied with. I expect us to be alot better over the whole year. People on this site expect us to be world beaters from round 1

CS was responible for the debt demolition, Jimmy the front man. He does a great job, if you can do better . Apply for the job.