Pennant St Dee

I went Max because he was great for 4 quarters. Trac was missing for 10 minutes in the second when they were charging. Although he did come straight back into it and kicked one to show how dangerous he was. I think you can go either way for me it’s more consistent effort vs outright brilliance

Is that like “Pizz Melksham off for good” in the game day thread😂😂😂 Smiths strength is his athleticism 1v1 matchup, and either intercept or provide contest and use your asset at ground level to rebound. Your analysis is the gift that keeps on giving

Second half of the third we started to turn things a little in similar fashion to them in the first quarter

Smith was good when he came on, however I think Tomo might be better against the Crows tall forwards allowing Lever to zone off Spargs got himself in some good spots and created some channels as usual but will be in the gun as his execution was poor for the most part, Chandler will come into consideration Brown stays because when he played the high forward role it opened them up and gave us the separation early.

Kossie’s goal was great- 3 things in it Melksham contested mark, Kossie wins a 1v2 preventing rebound overlap and Tracs backing of Kossie pointing him to back himself and kick it

Was 08 the game when Wona came alive in the last, with Jimmy hugging Wona’s dad

Some good discussion on First Crack

He’s just a born leader and warrior, never gives up. That goal was purely wanting it more than his opponents

I love my Dees and I’m not totally biased to our flaws, but even if we lost tonight I loved that we stuck at it and kept within striking distance. JVR and Brown weren’t great but they continued to compete. May had some horrific moments but was important late. Most people learn from their mistakes but the usual suspects will again next week be posting garbage on the game day thread vs Adelaide

6.Gawn 5. Trac 4. Viney 3. Melk 2. Brayshaw 1. Mcvee Bowey, Hunter and Nibbler also worthy of mentions

Posted the below on the game day thread and it’s directed towards a few who have already posted on here Been saying it forever some of you so called supporters are a disgrace and need to have a good look at yourself Maxy take a bow Trac likewise Melk good defensive forward effort Boys showed a lot of courage tonight Took the game on and yes at times they got burned on the rebound but it is a coaching (yes coached) directive we really stood up in the last quarter thought we may have blown it with those early last quarter misses, but a fantastic win

Been saying it forever some of you so called supporters are a disgrace and need to have a good look at yourself Maxy take a bow Trac likewise Melk good defensive forward effort Boys showed a lot of courage tonight

Yep, but unlike PF Greg Norman would probably never have called for Trac to be dropped. Anyway enough of that, boys need to bring pressure, accountability and lower their eyes tonight. We’re really up against it and the team first approach of 2021 is needed across the board for us to be in this. It’s going to be tough but just want to see something with which we can build on for the remainder of the season. Yes I want 4 points but the bigger picture and inside 50 delivery and structure are what I’m most looking at tonight

The guys is a 🤡 screams for Brown to come in because JVR isn’t up to it. Brown has a poor game against GWS, calls for him to be dropped for JVR or Jefferson. JVR comes in this week still moaning. Bags Spargo for years because you know if it ain’t obvious PF ain’t going to see what he brings, then retracts midway through 22(yes literally it took him that long to see it) only to change his mind again. The bloke is deadset clueless. But hey no matter what happens tomorrow if we lose, it will be because Grundy wasn’t selected Well Pendent or Pendulum or whatever let me just say this. 1 Spargo has played probably 10 good games in his 90 odd, Yep lauded him at one stage when I thought he turned the corner, but his last two games have been garbage. He got dropped then without any return to Casey, returned to the senior side on What?? I don't buy this forward pressure stuff, give me GOALS AND POSSESIONS AND I'LL SHUT UP! 2 I remain a staunch advocate of BBB and believe he MUST Feature for the rest of the year. 3 JVR is Raw but promising, did NOTHING last week at CASEY yet still got a call up. 4 If I am "Clueless"The football department must also be similar with the chopping and changing, NEVER rewarding guys at Casey who have form I.E Schache, Dunstan, Moniz Wakefield et al. So I might be passionate and opinionated BUT with VFL Under 19 experience behind me, Amateur 100 gamer and Senior coaching experience and a couple of Phys-Ed degrees... Nar dont think I'm Clueless. Your turn????! Schache can’t play at this level, been proven time and time again. Dunstan is nothing we don’t already have in the midfield, his disposal is just worse. They are both break glass in case of emergency. And as for your resume, means little when compared with your rants on all things football.

The guys is a 🤡 screams for Brown to come in because JVR isn’t up to it. Brown has a poor game against GWS, calls for him to be dropped for JVR or Jefferson. JVR comes in this week still moaning. Bags Spargo for years because you know if it ain’t obvious PF ain’t going to see what he brings, then retracts midway through 22(yes literally it took him that long to see it) only to change his mind again. The bloke is deadset clueless. But hey no matter what happens tomorrow if we lose, it will be because Grundy wasn’t selected

This is exactly right, even at development/Colts level, S & C map out a season plan, it’s flexible in terms of injuries, potential state selection/representation and school footy. The focus is on players being managed so they are as fit as possible come the pointy end of the season. That includes resting players and treating niggles if it means they will be fitter at the back end of the year. Theres been times when I have witnessed a couple of weeks of low training loads and been sceptical, but the S&C have been spot on.

Whilst he’s actually playing better than Max, this is the sort of out which forces your hand for the better. Somewhat similar to Fagan having to free Daniher up. Might make us a little more mobile and see us move the ball quicker in transition

Would think we will go in with a forward set up where we prevent Andrews from intercepting either by playing JVR as the high half forward taking him up the ground or bringing in Tomlinson and moving Petty forward and getting separation between Petty and BB. Another option could be Melksham playing a defensive role on him

I believe 1 of Duursma, Caddy, Mckercher, Sanders or Curtin will be available at pick 6. So no doubt JT and the footy department are working through the possibilities

6. May 5. Salem 4. Trac 3. Brayshaw 2. Sparrow 1. Bowey

I know Tomlinson was dropped after the Collingwood game but he was also dropped earlier in the season when he was poor against Brisbane and whilst we won the following 2 weeks against those sides (Swans and Eagles) it was nothing to do with Tomo being dropped. Smith was poor with his positioning against Stewart 4th quarter and last week, whilst Smith was poor, the method of entry was the major factor which enabled Haynes to intercept. We need a total reset with regard to our forward entries and structure. Tomlinson won’t change that, and I prefer our defence to remain strong with Petty back. We need to pause our entries or at least our mids need to drive out of the clearances with their legs and hit a lead or space for our forwards to lead into not just bomb it. Our forwards need some separation or else there is no point playing Ben Brown. Melksham for all his faults is smart enough to play the negating forward and Spargo is very good with his decision making and poise in and around the F50

We have not won since he was dropped- Whilst factual, that is way off the mark and a shocking case of trying to justify an argument whilst also highlighting your total lack of footy knowledge. Tomlinson was dropped after our poor effort at the Gabba and we won our next two, which by the way had little to do with him being dropped. Tomlinson missing in no way effected our inside 50 deliveries, it did not effect our forwards ability to get separation(note Petty is a contested mark, not a leading hit up potential forward) and it certainly did nothing to prevent us from being able to give a Sparrow or Petracca more time forward. We lost against Geelong because we were poor with our conversion and inside 50 deliveries when we were well on top. In the 4th we were poor because we were beaten at the clearances and failed in our ability to be able to lock the ball inside our forward 50. We lost last week because again our conversion and delivery was beyond poor. BB and Melksham over Tomlinson are you seriously asking that question, because at no stage ever in team selection would their magnets have been beside each other for consideration. If we lose tomorrow it will be because we either don’t win the clearances and fail to make the most of our opportunities with our forward entries or because we fail with our forward press to stifle St Kilda’s ability to run in waves and expose us out the back

Congratulations Taj, well earned and I know your parents will be bursting with pride

I think he was guilty of poor delivery like the rest and may benefit from being closer to goal

And just let Kossie play, yes provide tackling pressure but let him play with some freedom and he is one who will benefit from a less congested f50