Little Richard

Pick 13 would be a pretty good deal, you'd bet Eddie would push it as far as he could though.

Doubt he'd agree to this knowing that he would probably miss 75 percent of possible games (if past seasons are anything to go by).

Yep definitely don't want to be stung on a deal, although the bombers are only offering him one year so the fact that his contract is over could work as a bit of leverage.

Imagine the polls Range Rover would start if we didn't draft Jack...

Passing on Jack will be a monumental stuff up on the clubs part and they simply won't do it. This guy is ferocious at the ball and the man, and proved he is ready right away for senior footy after his games for Casey. How many times have you seen a kidmake a point of getting under the nose of a tough AFL veteran (Wojcinski) and putting his body on the line the way he did, where the end result was a broken jaw? The fact is that Viney is as hard as they come, and players like this don't come very often at all. As well as that he comes across very driven, has great leadership qualities and is a good kick. On the off chance we pass (which I guarantee we won't), the posters on Demonland will be crying themselves to sleep every night when we're left with a skinny, 'skilful' kid who turns out to be the next Cale Morton.

Thank God you aren't the MFC recruiter then. Not taking Viney will be stuffing it up... again.

A bit of optimism Old Dee! They didn't have free agency back then so I have faith that we can move up the ranks quicker than that. Some canny recruiting of some more battle-ready players and it shouldn't take more than a few years to get back into top 8 contention.

Sounds pretty promising, and if he can kick he'll already be better than most of our list so go get him.

No no no no no to Caddy if it means parting with pick 13. Nothing so far to show that he is worth it. If he can be packaged with Toy in a reasonable deal maybe, but even Toy is looking to have been overrated a bit.

And considering the state of our list compared with others', another clubs 'rejects' would be our solid players. I think Edwards would pretty useful.

For those interested in the Northern Footy League, I've heard that Brad has signed on for Heidelberg next season. Looking forward to watching him (if the rumour is true).

Obviously the best possible outcome but as we are the MFC, it'll never happen.

If we were to make a deal I'd like us to use pick 4 for MD pick 2. If it's going to cost pick 3 it's overs I think, especially seeing as we have to wait another year for Hogan to even debut. Seeing as our midfield is a pile of dog poop, my preferred would be Viney and Toumpas with Stringer/Kennedy at 13. If a move is made on Hogan I'd like Viney, Hogan (pick 4) and O'Rourke/Kennedy/Stringer at 13.

I thought we were just talking about Toumpas?

Nowhere near as ferocious at the contest though, and is actually more of an outside runner than an inside wrecking ball. If we were to use pick 3 on Viney, Toumpas would be great at pick 4.

Mate, Jack Viney is the player that typifies this new regime and has exactly the kind of qualities Neeld is trying to instill into the rest of the list. It would be madness passing on Viney and they won't do it.

Not worth pick 13 by any means.

It's called hindsight you idiot, as he was drafted in 09. It would have been foresight if this thread was started at the time of the draft.

I had exactly the same view until checking him out a bit more. One stat which is very promising I think is that he is 5th in the entire comp for total bounces taken, so clearly he can get the ball and run. Also 15th for total kicks.

Definitely have a crack

Fairly sure someone did this the other day with another players namesake...

What makes you think he would have even been close to the 22?

Maybe at least two other outside runners would be handy, Bail and Blease just aren't enough.

Lol... That's a very possessive way to talk about women but don't worry you'll learn respect when you get older!

I assume that means you're still a virgin then?