brendan

I don't think helmets do much, someone else might know more but I'm pretty sure if you get hit hard enough a helmet wont make any difference

It's a shame he has copped another knock and will just have to wait and see how it plays out, if the doctors give him the ok well the decision to keep going will be upto him, I hope he gets back and reaches his potential but unfortunately the AFL is full of hard luck stories with players who are just flat out unlucky and it's looking like this could be 1 of those stories

Silly question but is that photoshopped

Oh hell yes plenty of scum bags, too many ice heads

Well they finished on 12 wins so if you take jlt series out of it they have won just 2 games since round 10 last year that's not a great stat

Settle down I'm from ballarat we are not all bad, need to wait and see what happened 1st

North are useless I tipped them this week 2

That's not good

I think your sarcasm meter is broken

[censored] hell thats horrible hats off to play out a game like that

I thought the rule was if you elect to bump and the player you bump gets hurt you are gone, no grey area ruggles was concussed so Gibson should have been suspended, cats should have borrowed carltons doctor

I hope we are putting a bit of time into dusty I would be telling the players if your going to try tackling him put your head down and go as low as you can that way if he tries his famous fend off good chance he will get you high and you could draw a free kick, im surprised players don't do this against him he is a bull and almost impossible to tackle

How did Gibson escape any sanction he chose to bump, the player got concussion and took no part in the rest of the game what am I missing

Robbo mentioned this on afl360 last night said something needs to change, got the feeling he was trying to bait Lewis a bit on the subject but conversation went in a different direction pretty quickly

Hogan back will straighten us up, against freo we stuffed around too much getting the ball forward it was like the players had no confidence getting it forward, they should have more confidence with hogan there, if hogan can beat rance we will win

I'm glad I'm not the only 1 that thinks this

When I go to the footy I like to cheer loudly I don't swear or abuse players and I'm at the stage now where I would rather go sit with cheer squad or go to standing room behind them as I have had many Melbourne members tell me I'm too loud, at the Carlton game I would stand up and cheer after a goal only for the lady behind me tell me off for standing up, I always wondered why Melbourne supporters had a reputation for being soft and I get it now, I have tried a few different reserved seats in different areas of the ground and keep getting the same result so either I'm too full on(I don't think I am) or some Melbourne supporters are soft, I don't think there is anything wrong with showing some passion and the cheer squad do this I do remember seeing lots of security in the area and few police officers where I was standing but nothing out of the norm

Might as well forget finals(for now) 1 week at a time if we can't beat the tigers then I would say it makes it too hard, how we lost that game I will never

Hogan and Lewis cost us that win, hogan needs to repay next week

Zero chance we win this and it just cost us 40,000 members Goodwin just got schooled

Once again the club has sucked us in well played

[censored] you hogan and [censored] you lewis

Most pathetic display I have seen we are freo [censored]

Finals pfffft no chance

We are gone here