rhaz

Good way to get Watts into the game, playing down back. Taken two good defensive contested marks in a minute.

A few of the quiet players getting a bit of pill now. Still need Trenners to turn up... as Zaharakis showed against the Crows, a quiet first half doesn't mean you'll remain quiet for the whole game.

Kids aren't having a great day. Watts, Trengove, Tapscott... getting nothing out of em

Haha, Sylvia fly-kicking Cheney in the face. Howe looks like a great pickup.

Maric FFS nice handball... grrrrrrrr

That's better. Pity about the slow start...

Schwab is currently on triple m... when asked he said he would be 'very surprised' is Colin didn't play the rest of career at Melbourne, and suggested that he would get paid quite well in his next contract...

Walkers mark was amazing. It was like a basketball dunk where someone just absolutely destroys the direct opponent.

Give reasoning for your accusations... at the moment your post is just empty of anything that suggests why you think we're amateurish. Scully hasn't yet let the club and neither has Sylvia. If they are both here next year and happy, are we still amateurish?

He had 6 disposals and got dropped the week after a 96 point win. Hasn't shown anything at AFL level this year. Looking at Dunn, Howe, Jurrah, Bate, Petterd, Green in the same side... that is a lot of similar players, one can assume that Petterd will do more midfield work and Dunn less time up forward.

All i want is a better performance than last time we played them. To stay with them for 4 quarters and make them earn the win...

He plays for Richmond so I couldn't care less.

Just thought i'd add another 2 cents about Jones because i didn't really want to start a new thread. There was a time when EVERY WEEK, people were calling for his head... now i cant recall the last time i saw someone mention his name in the 'outs'. Great stuff from chunk.

Surely Richmond would be one of the first to take a punt on Mohr? Interesting that Valenti is listed down the bottom in 'the others'.

Haha, well thats a egg on my face then.

Johnston not in the bests? Doubt he will be around next year.

I wish Tom revelled in girls and fame (but not money). He would definitely stay in Melbourne if that were the case.

I am very, very worried about us getting beaten by Gold Coast in one or more GF's. They should peak at a similar time to us... so much talent there.

At least we wont be the "loss of the round" if we lose tonight! Hoping for a big win, predrinking and watching the game so hopefully i'll be extremely positive heading out tonight

Every player. To have the average losing & average winning margins we have is horrible.

Martin meant almost nothing to me at the end of 2010. I forgot at times that he was even on our list... now he is very, very important and it was incredible what he did whilst Jamar was gone. Voted for Trengove by accident because i misinterpreted the question.

Was reported that he definitely wont play again this season, and career is quite likely finished - is very interested in playing for the NT Thunder next year? This was on Channel 10.

Is this for the rest of the season? I'd go Darling. Not to put a knock on our boys, but it's Tappys first game back, and Howe is a marking forward in greasy decisions.

If we give him power/let him bring his assistants/etc then we can get him. No way is he definitely at Collingwood next year... we can get him if we want him.

Fitz is back! Good news there.