old dee

rpfc I must be a little thick this morning. Not sure what you are telling me. Can you be less subtle please? Oh is it "the sky is falling"?

Oh so you are advocating that anyone who disagrees should resign as a member. That will do wonders for the membership numbers. I have been a member of the MFC for a very long time and I will be until either I am pushing up daises Or the MFC is amalgamated with GCS. Maybe I am just plain stupid but as a member I have a view and I will put it forward. You take my money you get my view.

Yes wyl. To some extend we have created the monster that could easily devour us. We created this don't go after every win every week attitude. And now we wonder why we cannot beat time with a stick. Even now people are saving we should be tanking this year. To hell with that. The biggest problem is we don't have to tank we are this bad.

I have no confidence we have one. The score board has told me almost ever week this year and a large part of 2011 that we have the worst list in the league. Not sure what "future" you are talking about.

My view is a little shorter than that Biffen If by this time next year there is not significant improvement then This lot should be removed. What is significant improvement? 8 wins, we are never going to play finals in 2014 with this list. Without out improvement in 2013 there will be no MFC to speak of by 2014.

Or we are the world's worst selectors

Just a joke SMF!

I could not agree more rpfc. But I have serious doubts the crop from 2005 is any better. I see very little about the 2005 on recruits that gives me reason to feel the future is wonderful. They look very similar to me. Not good enough. Why do the upper management and board escape scrutiny for our current position?

Perhaps they might strip us of all points this year and all premierships cups since 2005!

So Bif in your view is there ever a point were members should not "get on the Bus"? Because the way you describe it the people running a club should never be queried. Interested in your thoughts.

Mate the last thing the MFC needs is an old crock like me. But that does not mean I don't recognise a disaster when I see one.

That may well be rpfc but the current management / board cannot not even cheat well. In spite of all the tanking we have a team that could not fight their way out a wet paper bag. If we were a good team I could wear it but we are pathetic. Why should they stay? The board / senior management have bought us to this fine spot. So it is time they left so the ship can be righted as it is not going anywhere but backwards under this mob.

Billy those may be the truest words you have ever typed! Could not agree more. It amazes me that a large number of supporters seem blind to our current position. There has to be major changes to the top levels of management / board at the MFC. The current people have bought us to this position it is time they were moved on or were removed.

Don't disagree with that part. I was referring to Sheahan.

This nowhere near makes up for constant 10 goal losses. Afraid I have run out of support jr I want action nothing else matters I have had all the talk I can handle

Sorry Redleg but I think a lot of what he says is correct we are pathetic, have been for 5 years and every chance we will be in 2013. You cannot argue with the results.

So you do not like him then toni?

No No RB you have no faith mate. 2017 is his year By then of course you know who will have played in 3 GF's

Jt He has been the GM through almost all of this unmitigated disaster. When and where does the buck eventually stop. Somewhere some time some one has to shoulder the blame.

JR the problem is we were crap before all the injuries. Now I will admit the injuries have not helped but I seriously doubt the we would have won more than a couple of extra games with no injuries. We have one genuine win against a team that you can be fairly confident is not top eight quality.

Sorry BB I got caught up in the fervour of the moment. ( why is it we cannot win again?)

So am I ! Because we took DB instead.

Spot on for all the sheedy haters. The decision not to take him may turn out to be the biggest mistake the MFC has every made. When the final chapter on the MFC is written that decision may be it.

Me too pitmaster or better still Hawthorn

Old it may be but IMO it is not far from the truth. The thing you cannot defend is the results. We have been the worst side in the competition for 5 years now. What say you to that?