old dee

So Rivers and Gysberts to Geelong for?

The space is not fully occupied BB! Only joking

I think it must be time for bed JT As I thought that was exactly what I was saying. But obviously I missed the mark completely. Yes I agree

Add, that he had 4 weeks off ill and that for 4days he was in a coma. Then came back and played good football for Casey. This guy is tough and wants it badly. Time will tell if he has the skill for AFL But he exhibits all the other required qualities.

That is absolute imagination. If Rivers leaves it because he wants to play finals football and does not see that happening at the dees in his football life. Get over the obsession that Neeld is the devil incarnate.

Now you have hit a nerve dee-luded I think Caddy is one of the most over rated players on the GCS list. IMO we should swap Petterd for caddy that would be a closer deal

I think you are right on the money Devo. As much as I might like him it won't happen. It is Freo or St.Kilda certainly not the Dees

Then I guess we are on the same tram. I thing those are our best two options

So my brain is not total mush. That's the best news for today

First Gysberts is not de listed. He has 1 year of a contract to go. He evidently wants to move on. The MFC is probably fielding offers or looking at a deal. Are you suggesting the delisting etc is finished? The process is very young JT there is a month to go before the real action starts. All will be revealed in the fullness of time.

Funny I wondered what the first bit was about. I was referring to the last line Chippy. Just an observation that when you are crap everyone thinks that most players are poor. What did the first bit say?

BH I think they saw AA next to his name and that was it!

Dee-luded if Gysberts is worth their No.1 pick we should be keeping him. However he is not so I think the best you could expect would for him to be part of some player trade arrangement. Geelong are not that silly

I doubt that with this FD. I get the feeling they are put up or shut up. And seriously doubt they would have picked Cook at number 80 let alone 12.

I agree with most of what you say Just don't trott out the lack of development to excuse every poor pick. Some of them are just not good enough

That will happen Chippy when you finish near last and have a crap list. Funny about that!

Honestly DemonWA Cook was never going to play he was simply not up to it. He was an emergency one week when we were done to the last few players because of injuries. Even then I was surprised. I saw him a few times at Casey and a Couple more on TV this year he still looked like a skinny 17 year old Playing against Men. IMO only ever played well when he could get the ball when on his own. In congested play he was useless. I don't believe I ever saw him take a congesed mark.

Please believe me I am not having a go at you. But I am so tied of this we do not Develop the players we pick. Lets all get over it we made poor selections. It is IMO that simple. Our poor development have not stopped Grimes Tom Mac or Blease inspite of a terrible injury from developing. No the problem is it is hard to pull up your socks when you don't have any on. WE JUST PICKED POORLY

I was agreeing with you Jnr.

The sad part is WJ they should have been forgettable at the MFC

Spot on LH

Hey Jonesbag we don't need an excuse I will buy you a beer. Being a dees man is enough. PS I would prefer to see him play 2013 but the drums are suggesting otherwise

I understand the point you make But he has the excuse of being out injured for a large number of games and it is his first year DC. I would suggest his first game at AFL round 1 showed more than Cooks 2 years at Casey

That is way better than I could manage Bingo. Good effort I hope they use it and it works.

Hard to disagree with any of that RobbieF