John Crow Batty

Win win, Cotchin gets slapped and Buddy gets a week.

I thought our first half was excellent. But Gawn, Oliver, Petracca and Viney left their mojo in the change rooms at half time. Big fail in the midfield.

What’s with Petracca, did someone slip kryptonite into his muesli?

At least we do didn’t concede a 100 points.

Dr D or watsaname licking his lips.

Tigers were robbed!!!!

Commentators already angling to get him off. Saying it was an open hand. Looked like a fist to me. They have too much influence on the tribunal and MRP. Seems to be a pattern.

Swans kick the ball to Buddy more than an any other of their forwards even when they shouldn’t and there are better options.

Matt Taberner reported to be in doubt for Freo. Could not finish training today and has to pass fitness test tomorrow morning. Huge out for them if so and hard to replace.

Frustrating thing with Tmac is he has been getting injured when just hitting good form and it takes him ages to get it back once he returns from injury.

Delete.

Three things are certain in life: death, taxes and confusing Tribunal and MRP decisions.

That hard tackle on Langdon when he was vulnerable and in no position to absorb its force did not have the potential to cause injury?

If Ginnivan showed signs of injury, pain, discomfort or irritation because of the tackle then fair enough a suspension for Switkowski. What he did deserved a fine maybe for the bad optics.

Not just injuries. The TV commentators have influence also and the tribunal takes notice. With Langdon, the commentators said basically nothing wrong there. With the Chicken wing tackle there was expressions of outrage as with the Viney incident last season. The tribunal acts accordingly. If the commentators didn’t speak up about the chicken wing tackle I doubt anyone would have noticed. Then again if someone like Tom Hawkins applied that limp chicken wing tackle the commentators would have said he had nothing to answer for.

Switkowski is a good player and a big loss for Freo. But how pathetic is the tribunal? A weak chicken wing tackle applied with no force earns a two weeks suspension. He just basically folded Ginnivans arm behind his back. No signs of injury, pain or protest from Ginnivan. No sense of rational proportion at all.

“Super underdogs this weekend. Nothing to lose hopefully we throw everything we have against the dee's.” Tired of hearing this defeatism every week.

A lot of criticism for Ben Brown, but he set up the 2 goals that helped us break the game open late in the third quarter.

Why all this hand wringing over Carlton? There are always viable challengers. If we repeat we have to beat them. Premierships are not an armchair ride.

Its kind of like he had a footballing epiphany after his suspension late last season. Been a different player since.

The tackle was correctly applied. However the WC player lacked situational awareness and lost his balance because he was not braced for contact. No case to answer.

From recent memory Hawkins and Niknat have got off after applying similar tackles that have caused similar injuries.

This game is making me more nervous than if we were playing Freo or Brisbane. I could never trust WC to put in a shocker against us.

Reported that stars Shannon Hurn and and Andrew Gaff are now outs for WC due to “niggles”. Apparently now have only 23 fit players to choose from.

Take GA seating. There isn’t a bad seat at Optus.